## Verdict
**OKAY**

## Claim Checks

- The immutable target was read in full. Its run-local `index.jsonl` records `stage-38-revision.md` at revision stage 38 with SHA-256 `0047d53be842ef9bbc5990c826e617777f535fc6af73722ecc0f7dada84ec0a5`, exactly matching the assignment.
- Stage-37 Required Change 1 is closed. Revision 38 replaces the prior all-terminal `DiagnosticDuplicateNoSend(status="duplicate")` collapse with three exact non-authorizing variants: unknown preserves `status="delivery_unknown"` and the no-resend/reconciliation warning; receipt/delivered/audit-pending preserves `status="audit_pending"`, the receipt-recovery warning, and reconciliation availability; only a chain containing `sent_audited` becomes duplicate with the already-processed text. Every no-send variant fixes `provider_authority=false`.
- Terminal precedence is now non-contradictory and implementable: `sent_audited` wins for a valid completed chain; otherwise receipt/delivered/audit-pending maps to audit-pending; otherwise unknown maps to unknown; exact started/consumed uncertainty is terminalized once to unknown; conflicting receipts, terminal mixtures lacking canonical normalization, and invalid order fail closed. This covers valid audit-pending→sent-audited replay without reopening provider authority.
- Stage-37 Required Change 2 is closed. The promised matrix names started, consumed, unknown, receipt-only, delivered-without-audit, audit-pending, audit-pending→sent-audited, and direct sent-audited chains, and requires exact result class, status, Korean text, row delta, provider delta, and reconciliation availability in both same-process replay and restart recovery.
- The mapping matches the retained executable contract at `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/workspace/checkin_cli/PILOT_RUNBOOK.md:133-142,183-187`: unknown and receipt-present/audit-pending remain distinct terminal no-retry outcomes, while only an audited repeat is duplicate. It also fits the present gateway seam: `adaptive_delivery_result_text` already owns the three exact Korean messages (`gateway/platforms/nutrition_coaching.py:2715-2726`), `_delivery_status_without_reconciliation` already distinguishes audited duplicate from receipt/audit-pending (`:10370-10440`), `_canonical_delivery_projection` validates durable ordering (`:10280-10365`), and reconciliation uses existing receipt evidence without provider invocation (`:10442-10640`). The new diagnostic authority/host can return sealed equivalents rather than inventing a parallel status model.
- Referenced existing construction seams were verified: profile `checkin_cli/store.py` contains `EventStore`; `checkin_cli/wizard.py` contains `WizardService`; `checkin_cli/customer_coaching.py` contains `CustomerRuntime` and the registry loader; gateway `nutrition_coaching.py` contains `AdaptiveNutritionCoordinator`, retained `customer_runtime`, and ordinary `deliver_latest_once`. The existing focused gateway/profile test files named by the plan exist. `gateway/platforms/diagnostic_isolation.py`, its diagnostic tests, and profile `diagnostic_evidence.py` are intentionally planned new files and do not yet exist; their required constructors, methods, ownership, and verification cases are specified cumulatively.
- Representative unknown replay simulation is closed: startup or first replay converts an exact receipt-free started/consumed chain to one linked unknown, the host immediately returns `DiagnosticUnknownNoSend`, and later same-process/restart calls add no rows and perform no provider call.
- Representative receipt recovery simulation is closed: receipt-only, delivered, or audit-pending evidence returns `DiagnosticAuditPendingNoSend`; only the separately authorized reconciliation action may append recovery audit state with provider zero; after `sent_audited`, replay returns `DiagnosticDuplicateNoSend` with no row/provider delta.
- Representative corruption simulation is closed: mixed unknown/receipt evidence without canonical audit-pending normalization, multiple receipts/terminals, or invalid row order raises `DiagnosticReservationConflict` before any new row or provider authority.

## Missing Evidence

None.

## Approval Boundary

Execution may proceed with the cumulative Stage-33 closure plus Revision 35 sealed registered/standalone factories, Revision 36 host-owned reserve-and-verify sequence, Revision 37 host-only reservation ownership and crash-state algebra, and Revision 38 canonical terminal no-send variants/matrix. Approval includes automated profile/gateway, packaging, lock/race, digest-vector, restart, and provider-zero verification. Live Telegram, credentials, manual P2–P6, real-customer activation, deployment, and any change to retained Stage-33 contracts remain outside approval.

## Summary

- **Clarity:** High; terminal result types, texts, precedence, authority, and replay behavior are explicit.
- **Verifiability:** High; exact type/status/text/row/provider/reconciliation assertions cover same-process and restart paths.
- **Completeness:** Stage-37's sole bounded contradiction and its matrix gap are fully closed.
- **Big Picture:** Preserves at-most-once delivery and exposes operator recovery only when durable receipt evidence exists.
- **Principle/Option Consistency:** Consistent with sealed authority, durable identity, fail-closed corruption handling, and no optional production fallback.
- **Alternatives Depth:** Adequate cumulatively; the rejected terminal-state collapse is replaced without topology changes.
- **Risk/Verification Rigor:** Strong for crash replay, provider-zero no-send states, audit reconciliation, conflict handling, and restart equivalence.

## Required Changes

None.