## Verdict
**ITERATE**

Reviewed only the assigned immutable revision `/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.gjc/_session-019f8531-7966-7000-88f0-3cf2a6708ab7/plans/ralplan/019f8531-7966-7000-88f0-3cf2a6708ab7/stage-10-revision.md`, bound by its sibling index to SHA `0252b05cf79deb09e906372d248af0394237765c9a2e543f6c95b41a9500614e`, against `/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.gjc/_session-019f8455-334a-7000-99ca-318dfd0e06b1/specs/deep-interview-dual-coach-single-customer-pilot.md`. Architect output was not consumed.

## Claim Checks
- **The bounded product scope is correct.** The revision keeps one external paid customer, KRW 150,000 bank transfer, an up-front 12-week plan, only the first four weeks automated, weekday adaptive check-ins, trainer records, Telegram plus a loopback Richard-only console, human approval, weekly summaries, and the four-way KPI conjunction. It does not introduce the prohibited generic redesign/auth/systemd/browser/concurrency/deployment/multi-customer work.
- **Stage-9 change 2 is resolved.** The existing canonical contract at `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/contracts/checkin-event.schema.json` has `additionalProperties:false`, and the existing `models.Event` has only `check_in`, `safety`, and `payload_ref`. Stage 10 now names that contract in the owner map and gives exact discriminated properties for all eight pilot event types plus deterministic non-null dedupe keys.
- **Stage-9 change 3 is resolved.** The extension command/state is removed, the KST day-28 boundary is hard, renewal has no scheduling effect, and the denominator is the exact eligible weekday-date set in the fixed 28-day window.
- **Stage-9 change 5 is resolved.** F-NORMAL-1, F-ANOM-SLEEP-1, F-ANOM-COND-1, F-ANOM-PERF-1, and F-CHANGE-1 now make exact follow-up IDs and short-versus-detailed outcomes reproducible.
- **Representative activation simulation exposes an unresolved implementation contradiction.** Current `CustomerSpec` contains the customer address but not the registry `owner`; `owner` exists only on `RegistryDocument`. Therefore the stated `CustomerSpec` invariant cannot reject `enabled=true` based on all three customer/trainer/owner identities. G2 also requires a plan file in the customer data root, while the current canonical 12-week plan exists inline as `CustomerSpec.plan`; no plan-file format or creation step is defined. The stated function signature does not take the claimed explicit data-root input. The guard is conceptually present, but executors still must invent or duplicate state to implement it.
- **Representative safety simulation shows stage-9 change 4 is incomplete.** The revision requires `raw input → stored signal with class+reason → owner notice with reason`, and says both signal and reason are written on `Event.safety`. But its contract change explicitly leaves `safety` untouched. Existing `Safety` and the JSON schema contain only `level`, `signals`, and `coaching_held`; the prescribed signal value is only `class:matched_field`. There is no canonical location for the matched snippet/reason that AC17/AC21 require downstream.
- **Representative KPI simulation can undercount and falsely pass.** `operator_time_record` uses `operator-time:{customer_id}:{work_on}:{task}` as its dedupe key, so two legitimate sessions for the same task on one day collapse to one event even though AC12 requires all operator work time. The plan also permits `amount_krw >= 0` and defines renewal success as mere presence of a renewal event, so a zero/wrong-amount event can satisfy a pilot whose specified price is KRW 150,000. It does not state whether every weekly bucket or a four-week average must meet the 60-minute limit.

## Missing Evidence
- **Definitely missing activation ownership:** an implementable location for the owner-inclusive enabled invariant and one canonical plan source for G2.
- **Definitely missing safety representation:** a schema/model field or exact bounded encoding that persists the matched reason required by AC17/AC21.
- **Definitely missing KPI correctness:** non-colliding operator-time entry identity and a renewal predicate that proves the actual KRW 150,000 renewal; weekly time aggregation is not defined.
- Existing referenced Python owners were verified under `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/workspace/checkin_cli/checkin_cli/` and `/home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent/gateway/platforms/`; `checkin_cli/operator_console.py` is correctly new. The generic `Docs` entry remains path-unspecific but is not by itself a rejection reason.

## Approval Boundary
The product boundary, canonical pilot-event approach, hard four-week scheduler stop, deterministic branch fixtures, and bounded safety classes are approved as planning direction. Execution and any real-customer activation remain unapproved until the activation model, stored safety reason, and KPI event/judgement defects below are fixed. No generic platform or post-day-28 automation work is approved.

## Summary
- **Clarity:** Strong scope and flow; activation state ownership and safety-reason placement contradict the concrete models.
- **Verifiability:** Strong branch, routing, HTTP, scheduler, and E2E test outline; KPI truth can still falsely pass.
- **Completeness:** Four of five stage-9 changes are complete; activation and input-safety changes remain partly unimplementable.
- **Big Picture:** Correct bounded four-week single-customer pilot.
- **Principle/Option Consistency:** Hard stop and typed-event decisions are consistent; “safety untouched” conflicts with storing a reason, and dedupe semantics conflict with recording all time.
- **Alternatives Depth:** Adequate and bounded.
- **Risk/Verification Rigor:** Good overall, but the remaining activation, safety-evidence, and KPI-truth gaps are load-bearing.

## Required Changes
1. Make activation implementable without duplicated/invented state: validate the existing inline `CustomerSpec.plan` as the canonical 12-week plan (or fully specify creation/format/ownership of a separate plan artifact), put the owner-inclusive enabled invariant on `RegistryDocument` while keeping customer/trainer-local checks on `CustomerSpec`, and make the guard signature/input description consistent. Preserve one failure test per G1–G5 and removal of every direct enable path.
2. Add an exact canonical representation for the safety hold reason. Either extend `Safety` in both `models.py` and `checkin-event.schema.json` with a bounded typed reason structure, or define a lossless bounded encoding in `signals`; then state how `customer_grounding.py` and the adapters retrieve that stored reason. Keep the AC21 raw-input-to-zero-send E2E fixtures.
3. Make KPI judgement incapable of false success: give each operator-time entry a stable per-entry identity/dedupe key so multiple same-task/day sessions are all counted (with append-only correction semantics), define whether the 60-minute condition requires each of the four weekly buckets to pass, and require the renewal KPI to prove the expected KRW 150,000 bank-transfer renewal period rather than any `kind="renewal"` event with an allowed zero/wrong amount. Add duplicate-retry and multiple-entry/day fixtures plus wrong/zero renewal rejection tests.