## Verdict
**ITERATE**

## Claim Checks
- Reviewed `.gjc/_session-019f8455-334a-7000-99ca-318dfd0e06b1/plans/ralplan/019f8455-334a-7000-99ca-318dfd0e06b1/stage-14-revision.md`; the RALPLAN index identifies the reviewed revision SHA-256 as `cc2b45593affc9b4d1b86e1bee216610e27b5ee2795a37325b32054a1af2de3c`.
- Projection is materially improved: authoritative session-start KST day, per-root graph validation, per-flow terminal folding, zero-versus-missing preservation, explicit window bounds, sample thresholds, and D+ boundary fixtures are present. Current source confirms `WizardSession.kst_day` already exists, while `WizardService._event` currently stamps save time, so the proposed source-day change has a representative implementation path.
- Serialization is improved by fixed-scale decimal strings, sorted compact JSON, explicit digest preimages, pinned baseline/policy/catalog versions, and a 47-byte callback form. It is not yet an exact cross-implementation canonical-byte contract.
- Arithmetic fixes the pass-13 residual defect: daily energy must satisfy `4C+4P+9F`, the search is bounded/deterministic, no fractional/post-hoc residual is allowed, and infeasibility becomes `human_review`.
- Resolver scope and fail-closed multiplicity are explicit, and current `customer_grounding.py`/`customer_reporting.py` contain direct baseline lookups that can be replaced by the named sole resolver. Resolver history semantics remain contradictory.
- Lifecycle/recovery is substantially expanded: live revalidation, revision digests, append-only transition events, attempt-before-transport, unknown-result reconciliation, explicit replacement authorization, receipt conflict handling, and one sent audit are specified. The current generic Telegram transport returns a receipt or raises undifferentiated `RuntimeError`, so the proposed confirmed-versus-unknown branches still lack an implementable certainty contract.
- Config gives an exact topic route, feature epoch, staged flags, private modes, and stale-card behavior. Verified existing files include `gateway/platforms/nutrition_coaching.py`, `gateway/platforms/telegram.py`, `gateway/platforms/nutrition_coaching_config.py`, the active profile `config.yaml`, and `activation/telegram-config.template.yaml`; the required parser file is omitted from the plan's file/order section.
- Privacy is mostly resolved: it accurately retains the manual runbook mechanism, enumerates adaptive data/backup/export/card paths, requires tombstones before restore startup, and does not claim a nonexistent delete command. Rollback compatibility is not resolved because the canonical event model/schema are strict and reject additive fields.
- Acceptance has focused profile/gateway/migration/privacy suites, a crash matrix, manual Telegram proof, and explicit intent blockers for Gates B-D. No tests or source commands were run, as this assignment is plan-only.

## Missing Evidence
Definitely missing or under-specified:
1. The source graph uses `correction_of`, but the existing canonical event wire uses `supersedes`; no compatibility mapping is defined. A generic correction also has no independent flow discriminator. MORNING and NUTRITION both claim appetite/digestion/Bristol authority without defining namespaced fields or cross-flow precedence, and the complete-day energy tolerance has no named policy field.
2. Canonicalization does not fix non-ASCII escaping/Unicode normalization, enumerate each decimal field's scale, define Decimal ingestion from current JSON numbers without binary-float ambiguity, or state how wall-clock fields are excluded/pinned for byte-identical rebuilds.
3. The calorie step's reference is undefined after an overlay is already effective (immutable baseline versus seven resolved active targets). The weekly target and category-share distance function/units are not specified, nor is the decision rule for `macro_redistribution_candidate`.
4. Resolver step 2 rebuilds at the current feature epoch, while step 5 promises rollback only changes future targets and preserves history. No epoch/effectivity-as-of rule ensures past adherence continues to use the overlay that was effective then.
5. There is no typed transport outcome/error taxonomy to distinguish confirmed-not-sent from ambiguous exceptions. The stated lock does not identify a lock shared by registry consent/activation/config writers, and the absolute “no transport after authority loss at any point” claim has no external-I/O linearization rule.
6. Feature-flag dependency behavior (`delivery => activation => operator_candidates => analytics_shadow`) and atomic config/epoch-event update/recovery are unspecified.
7. Revision 14 says it incorporates Revision 13 but omits the prior meal catalog/compiler contract, exact model/file map, release-gate exit criteria, and alternatives rationale. It does not state that Revision 13 remains normatively incorporated by reference.

## Approval Boundary
Planning may continue with the chosen separate adaptive stream, immutable baseline, deterministic compiler, sole resolver, and append-only delivery lifecycle. No implementation gate is approved from this artifact. Gates B-D remain blocked on the six listed user decisions; Gate A also remains outside approval until the canonical source-wire/downgrade and deterministic-rebuild contracts are corrected.

## Summary
- Clarity: Stronger locally, but source correction fields, repeated-adjustment arithmetic, and lifecycle certainty still require executor guesses.
- Verifiability: Broad test matrix; several assertions lack exact expected semantics, especially epoch history, canonical bytes, config combinations, and transport certainty.
- Completeness: Core architecture is present; meal compilation, exact file/symbol routing, and gate exits were dropped unless Revision 13 is explicitly normative.
- Big Picture: Separate stream and immutable baseline fit the current system; additive canonical-event writes currently contradict the downgrade claim.
- Principle/Option Consistency: Determinism and fail-closed behavior are consistent. Current-epoch rebuilding conflicts with preserved history, and the Gate A wording must explicitly say candidate numeric fields are disabled/null before approved policy.
- Alternatives Depth: Thin in this standalone artifact; retain or normatively reference Revision 13's rationale.
- Risk/Verification Rigor: Good breadth, but TOCTOU/transport classification and config epoch transaction recovery are not closed.

## Required Changes
1. Define the canonical source adapter exactly: map existing `supersedes` to logical correction edges (or migrate it explicitly), define correction flow derivation/discriminator, namespace or prioritize overlapping MORNING/NUTRITION fields, and name the observed-energy tolerance policy field.
2. Publish one canonical-byte specification: non-ASCII/Unicode rules, field-by-field scales, source-number-to-Decimal conversion, digest encoding, and deterministic treatment of timestamps; narrow byte-identical acceptance to precisely named rebuild artifacts.
3. Specify compiler state composition: the exact seven-day input target selected by the resolver, whether changes accumulate from the current overlay, effective/expiry intervals, weekly-total formula, category-share objective/tie order, and macro-redistribution eligibility.
4. Give the resolver bitemporal rule and tests: rollback/epoch change returns baseline only from its effective date forward, while a historical query continues to resolve the overlay effective on that KST day; define blocked versus baseline outcomes for every authority failure.
5. Add a typed transport result contract. Treat every post-attempt unclassified exception as `delivery_unknown`; permit confirmed replacement only from a provider-confirmed-not-sent result. Define the shared lock participants and delivery authorization linearization point, then scope the no-stale-send acceptance claim accordingly. Complete held/superseded transitions from approved/effective states.
6. Add `nutrition_coaching_config.py` and exact config paths/symbols to the file plan; enforce flag implications; make flags+epoch an atomic config replacement; define fail-closed recovery for config/adaptive-epoch mismatch.
7. Resolve downgrade: current `Event(extra=forbid)` and `checkin-event.schema.json(additionalProperties=false)` cannot be read by old binaries after `observation_kst_day` is written. Stage a reader-compatibility release before enabling writers and set a rollback floor, or keep source-day metadata outside the old canonical wire. Add old/new reader fixtures.
8. Make Revision 14 standalone, or explicitly declare Revision 13 normative except for listed supersessions. Restore/reference the meal catalog/compiler constraints, alternatives, exact gate exits, and file/symbol map; state unambiguously that Gate A emits no personalized candidate numbers.

ITERATE