## Verdict
**ITERATE**

## Claim Checks

- The immutable target was read in full. The RALPLAN index records `stage-30-revision.md` as revision stage 30 with SHA-256 `700d443d4570a32a42e3a2d92dd6758cd59cfbd109f48f65d9c5c2a489ab7e3c`, matching the assignment.
- Stage 30 materially closes the package-resource portion of Stage 29: it keeps explicit `pyproject.toml` package-data scope, requires a network-disabled wheel build/inspection/temp-target import test, and pins the embedded SHA-256 to the exact raw `importlib.resources` bytes before JSON decoding. This fits the current setuptools backend in `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/workspace/checkin_cli/pyproject.toml`, which currently has no package-data declaration and therefore needs the named change.
- The full-triple route requirement is closed: `DiagnosticRoleRoute` carries `user_id/chat_id/topic_id` plus generation, lookup compares all three, and mismatch requires product/provider row zero.
- The Stage-28 detachment race is addressed by a clear conservative winner rule. One `DiagnosticHost._admission_lock` surrounds final state/generation/pin validation, reservation, the bounded provider invocation, and durable receipt/unknown terminalization; detach/close/expiry/stop use the same lock. If delivery wins, detaching cannot be appended until the attempt is durably resolved; if detach wins, reservation/provider deltas are zero. The required pause/cancel/timeout/restart interleavings make the contract verifiable. This is a necessary fit for the current gateway path, where `deliver_latest_once` persists `delivery_attempt_started`, releases its existing locks, revalidates, then invokes `send_adaptive_customer`, whose transport separately persists `delivery_attempt_consumed` before the Telegram call.
- Four of the five stated read-lock mappings match current writers: `WizardStorage` uses `.wizard.lock`; `EventStore` uses `.events.lock`; the adaptive event/source/authority/config journals use `.adaptive.lock`; `CanonicalSequenceJournal` uses its configured `.events.lock`; and schedule writers use `.scheduled-deliveries.lock`. The no-create `O_RDONLY|O_NOFOLLOW|O_CLOEXEC` reader contract, writer hardening, before/after tree comparison, and concurrent coherence tests close the original mutating-reader problem for those domains.
- The fifth row is internally incorrect: Stage 30 places `overlay_path` under `AdaptiveEventStore.read_adaptive_locked()` and `.adaptive.lock`, but the current `OverlayJournal` sets `self.lock_path = self.root / ".authority-transition.lock"` and every append/replace/rollback writer takes that inode (`checkin_cli/adaptive_nutrition.py`, `OverlayJournal`). A reader taking `.adaptive.lock` therefore does not synchronize with the actual overlay writer. The addendum also calls the table column the “Existing writer inode” and promises ordinary production remains unchanged, so an executor cannot safely infer that the production writer lock should silently migrate instead.

### Representative implementation simulation

1. **Read-only source export:** wizard, canonical EventStore, adaptive main journals, canonical sequence, and schedule can each gain a no-create shared reader around their actual writer inode and be read sequentially with the full revision-token retry. Overlay evidence breaks this simulation: a concurrent `OverlayJournal._append` holds `.authority-transition.lock` while the planned reader holds `.adaptive.lock`, so the acceptance claim that every evidence read synchronizes with its actual writer inode is false.
2. **Diagnostic close versus delivery:** route lookup releases the adapter route lock, then final admission takes the host lock. A close that wins that lock appends detaching/removes routes before admission; a delivery that wins retains the lock through the current reservation, transport consumption, one provider call, and terminal persistence. This removes the earlier check-to-call gap without an external lease or counter.
3. **Installed policy:** add the policies package and JSON, configure setuptools package data, build a wheel offline, inspect/extract it into an isolated target, load raw bytes through `importlib.resources`, compare the embedded digest, then parse the closed schema. This path is actionable and source-tree-only success is explicitly rejected.

## Missing Evidence

Definitely missing:

1. A correct lock domain for `adaptive-overlays.jsonl`. The actual writer inode is `.authority-transition.lock`, not `.adaptive.lock`; no matching read API or concurrent writer-vs-reader test is specified for that sixth domain.

Thin and requiring an exact choice before execution:

2. The provider bound is described only as a “hard configured timeout” below remaining TTL and an “absolute test-safe maximum.” No constant/config field, numeric maximum, validation/pinning rule, or timeout primitive is named. Current `deliver_latest_once` catches `asyncio.CancelledError` and returns an unknown result instead of re-raising, so the diagnostic-only wrapper/integration point must be explicit to satisfy Stage 30’s terminalize-then-re-raise shutdown rule.

## Approval Boundary

Execution may proceed conceptually with the separate dormant process, root/spec/bot policy, bounded source-export architecture, synthetic replay/promotion boundaries, full-triple generation routes, raw-byte wheel resource proof, and single-lock detachment/provider winner rule. Do not approve the evidence-lock implementation or claim final consensus until overlay reads synchronize on `.authority-transition.lock` (or a deliberately specified, compatibility-tested writer migration replaces that domain) and the provider timeout/cancellation integration is pinned. Live Telegram, credentials, manual P2–P6, real-customer activation, deployment, and rollout remain outside approval.

## Summary

- **Clarity:** High except for the incorrect overlay lock row and unpinned provider timeout integration.
- **Verifiability:** Strong deterministic race and wheel proofs; overlay synchronization cannot pass the stated actual-inode acceptance as written.
- **Completeness:** Stage-29 package and route items are closed; physical read isolation is not fully closed.
- **Big Picture:** The separate-process diagnostic model and conservative serialization preserve fail-closed behavior and ordinary production authority.
- **Principle/Option Consistency:** Raw-byte packaging and detachment choices are consistent; claiming `.adaptive.lock` for an `.authority-transition.lock` writer contradicts the shared-inode principle.
- **Alternatives Depth:** Snapshot copying, source-only policy, and detach-without-fence alternatives are adequately rejected.
- **Risk/Verification Rigor:** Strong overall, but one real writer domain is omitted and shutdown timing still requires executor invention.

## Required Changes

1. Add `OverlayJournal.read_locked()` (or equivalently named read-only snapshot API) as a separate evidence row using the existing `.authority-transition.lock` inode, with the same no-create/no-follow ownership/mode/link/inode checks and a concurrent overlay-writer test. Keep `overlay_path` out of `AdaptiveEventStore.read_adaptive_locked()`. If migrating overlay writers to `.adaptive.lock` is instead intended, state that explicitly, analyze the lost `.authority-transition.lock` synchronization, and add compatibility/race tests; do not label it the existing writer inode.
2. Pin the diagnostic provider timeout contract: exact constant or closed config/spec field, numeric absolute maximum, validation against remaining TTL, the `asyncio.timeout`/`wait_for` integration point, and diagnostic cancellation behavior that persists exactly one unknown or audit-pending terminal state before re-raising cancellation and releasing `_admission_lock`.