## Verdict
**ITERATE**

## Claim Checks

- **Artifact identity verified.** The same-run `index.jsonl` binds revision stage 3 to `/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.gjc/_session-019fa80a-aa06-7000-aed8-cdd8fd418149/plans/ralplan/019fa7fb-3be3-7000-b23f-03f6c05d81ff/stage-03-revision.md` with SHA-256 `f2fb0bc0a113d75d0c52b9b0f80f6f4844cd71e55b54d402ed77c9a59ebf15a4`, matching the assignment.
- **The canonical baseline blocker is resolved.** Current `telegram.py:_nutrition_daily_text` still accepts `feedback`, and `_nutrition_daily_interpretation(None)` returns the missing-data sentence even for a complete snapshot. The revision now freezes the complete-data canonical line as `저장된 오늘 기록을 확인했습니다.`, preserves the existing missing-data literal, removes legacy feedback as a render input, leaves already-sent messages alone, and makes legacy replay canonical/decision-ledger based. This is actionable and reconciles the current complete fixture and guide with the intentional cutover.
- **The durable one-attempt architecture is materially resolved.** The proposed `attempt_started` append before invocation, single lock-winner authority, canonical terminalization of abandoned/in-flight claims, conditional late finalization, and `daily:<finalized_event_id>` key can provide at-most-one request across process races, restart, and replay. The current bridge already holds `session.finalized_event_id` while returning only snapshots, so adding a validated `(snapshot, finalized_event_id)` accessor is a representative, feasible path. Corrections already receive new final event IDs.
- **Weekly and adaptive invariants are correctly narrowed.** Current `_send_nutrition_coaching_tick` computes the weekly body and `template_digest` before `reserve_customer_task_delivery`; current adaptive callback/recovery paths publish durable service payloads. The revision gives both surfaces zero cosmetic slots, leaves weekly body/digest/reservation bytes untouched, and permits only a nonblocking new-card classification event before adaptive publication. This avoids the original race and durable-card mutation entirely.
- **Rollout modes are now representable.** The strict four-key config has explicit `disabled|shadow|enabled` modes, actual-bool checks, bounded integer timeout, default-disabled behavior, canonical-only shadow rendering, immutable decision replay, and disabled rollback. It remains outside adaptive feature epochs and cannot override provider, destination, credential, or delivery authority.
- **The one-wire transport direction fits the current code.** `openai==2.24.0` is pinned; present OpenAI constructors do not set `max_retries=0`; `_AnthropicCompletionsAdapter` presently calls `create_anthropic_message` with its default `prefer_stream=True`; and Codex currently uses one low-level `responses.create(stream=True)`. A separate restrictive resolver, policy-only zero-retry constructors, Anthropic `prefer_stream=False`, unsupported-wrapper rejection, and conditional late-result discard directly address these paths without changing unrelated 30-second callers.
- **Resolved Kimi screening is much stronger, but its positive permission boundary is not frozen.** The revision requires one consolidated NFKC/casefold predicate over configured and resolved provider/model/base URL and covers current repository-recognized Kimi/Moonshot aliases, family slugs, aggregator paths, and official hosts. However, the current resolver supports auto resolution, named custom providers, endpoint overrides, many OpenAI-compatible providers, Codex wrappers, and Anthropic wrappers. “A compiled safe provider/endpoint allow-list” does not say which exact identities are allowed, so the executor still has to choose the feature’s provider surface.
- **Privacy is otherwise well specified.** The provider document is constant and content-free; the ledger stores only an opaque local key and bounded enums/hash-chain metadata; telemetry has exactly six allow-listed fields and bounded values; identity, prompt, response, body, text hashes, customer/address IDs, values, and exception strings are excluded. Sink failure is explicitly nonblocking.
- **Test coverage is broad and maps to the real seams.** The plan covers strict parsing, slice invariants, crash/concurrency/replay, corrupt and hostile storage, one-wire HTTP failures, Kimi identities and near misses, late completion, daily save/replay, unchanged weekly delivery, adaptive publication/recovery, both unchanged profile suites, and subprocess package-origin isolation. The shared Hermes module fixes the current `physique-coach` versus `dualcoachtest` import ambiguity.
- **Attribution is substantively complete but not literally verbatim.** The current Kiro port license contains both stated copyright lines and the MIT grant/disclaimer, and the original repository has epoko77-ai’s MIT notice. The revision includes the correct repositories, selected principles, exclusions, and full notice. The current Kiro raw `LICENSE`, however, ends in `SOFTWARE` without a period, while the plan’s supposedly verbatim block ends in `SOFTWARE.`.

## Missing Evidence

1. **Definitely inconsistent semantic invariant:** `warm_ack_v1` is `오늘도 빠짐없이 기록해 주셔서 감사합니다.`. `빠짐없이` is a completeness judgment/customer-specific assertion, contradicting the plan’s claim that variants contain no judgment or customer-specific assertion. The eligibility predicate only checks whether seven rendered fact rows end in `기록 없음`; it does not prove every recorded field is complete. In current code, water affects actions but is not one of those fact rows, and a partial free-form macro value can be rendered without ending in `기록 없음`. The alternative can therefore assert completeness that the canonical renderer has not established.
2. **Definitely under-specified resolved-provider permission contract:** no exact provider IDs, allowed normalized hosts/paths, transport pairing, or base-URL override rule is listed for the “compiled safe provider/endpoint allow-list.” The negative Kimi predicate alone cannot define which of the repository’s many raw OpenAI-compatible routes is supported.
3. **Definitely contradictory terminal outcome:** the state machine and telemetry define an owner-observed outer deadline as `timeout`, but the provider test requires the same outer-deadline/late-success scenario to persist `claim_incomplete_canonical`. The latter is otherwise reserved for a second renderer or restart discovering an unfinished claim. Both cannot be the expected terminal outcome for the same transition.
4. **Thin durable schema detail:** the append-only v1 row says only “finite outcome” and “row digest.” Exact ledger outcome values, logical-key validation/length, timestamp format, canonical digest input (including whether `row_digest` is omitted while hashing), and row encoding are not frozen. The state machine is sound, but independent executors/tests would still invent an incompatible durable schema.
5. **Verified file-list omission:** removal of `PhysiqueCheckinConfig.coaching_feedback_enabled` requires `/home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent/gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_config.py`, where the field and parser actually live. The prose orders the removal, but the file-level implementation list names only `physique_checkin.py`; it also does not name a focused parser regression.
6. **Minor exact-attribution mismatch:** the included block is not byte-verbatim to the current Kiro `LICENSE` because of the added final period.

## Approval Boundary

Execution may carry forward the deterministic complete/missing canonical cutover, deletion of the legacy daily feedback path, shared Hermes module placement, zero-slot weekly/adaptive policy, pre-call durable claim architecture, strict modes, content-free telemetry, restrictive resolved-identity/single-wire architecture, package-isolation strategy, rollout boundaries, and MIT attribution approach.

Product implementation and rollout are not approved until the warm variant no longer adds an unproved completeness assertion, the positive provider/endpoint allow-list is exact, timeout versus abandoned-claim terminal outcomes are reconciled, and the durable row contract is frozen. Existing active-turn/conversation behavior, adaptive lifecycle/delivery schemas, profile-local `adaptive_nutrition.py` files, real-customer activation, and Gate-D remain outside approval.

## Summary

- **Clarity:** Strong on canonical cutover, surfaces, modes, and flow; weak on the positive provider list and exact ledger enum/digest schema.
- **Verifiability:** Excellent adversarial matrix overall; one timeout acceptance contradicts the state machine, and the license’s “verbatim” claim is off by one character.
- **Completeness:** Resolves the prior baseline, durability, shadow, package, privacy, and coverage blockers; misses the actual config-parser file in the implementation inventory.
- **Big Picture:** Finite local selection plus zero-slot durable surfaces remains the correct architecture. The current warm string accidentally reintroduces a semantic assertion at the only editable slot.
- **Principle/Option Consistency:** Mostly consistent; `빠짐없이` conflicts with no-judgment/no-customer-assertion principles, and timeout conflicts with `claim_incomplete_canonical` in tests.
- **Alternatives Depth:** The free-form versus finite-choice decision is strong. Provider permission alternatives remain shallow because the exact supported identity set is deferred to implementation.
- **Risk/Verification Rigor:** Strong crash, race, storage, transport, privacy, and immutable-delivery testing. It needs exact durable schema vectors and one unambiguous deadline outcome.

## Required Changes

1. Replace `warm_ack_v1` with a literal that adds warmth but no completeness, quality, frequency, or other unproved judgment. A representative safe form is `저장된 오늘 기록을 확인했습니다. 기록해 주셔서 감사합니다.`. Update the semantic claim and exact-byte tests accordingly; do not broaden eligibility to rescue `빠짐없이`.
2. Freeze the positive identity policy: enumerate exact normalized provider IDs, allowed endpoint host/path pairs per `openai_chat_completions|codex_responses|anthropic_messages`, whether provider aliases are accepted, and whether any configured base-URL override is permitted. Everything else must return `unsupported_transport` or `provider_disallowed` before completion. Add matrix tests for allowed identity/transport pairs as well as Kimi denials.
3. Make outer-deadline semantics singular. Prefer terminal `timeout` when the claim owner’s deadline expires and reserve `claim_incomplete_canonical` for a different renderer/restart that observes `attempt_started`; change the late-success test to match. If a different rule is intended, update the state machine, telemetry signal, replay rules, and pre-mortem consistently.
4. Specify the exact decision-ledger v1 contract: field set and types, all state/outcome enums, key regex/length, UTC timestamp syntax, JSON canonicalization, previous/row digest calculation, newline encoding, file/dir/lock modes, and validation behavior. Add at least one fixed hash-chain test vector so persistence implementations cannot drift.
5. Add `gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_config.py` and its parser tests to the file-level steps; verify removal/rejection of the obsolete `coaching_feedback_enabled` key without changing unrelated exact-address parsing.
6. Either reproduce the current Kiro license bytes exactly (remove the terminal period) or stop calling the notice verbatim and document the deliberate punctuation normalization. Add a documentation assertion/manual check for both copyright lines and the complete notice.