## Summary
The immutable stage-05 plan hash is verified by its same-run index as `375abe88f57525dfd6087ce44c07450964d6e78e90d9a944fd79166a0e0db9a9`. It resolves the prior canonical-baseline, unsafe-warmth, OpenAI-only identity, one-wire timeout, ledger, config-file, and attribution findings, and its direct shared-module approach is generally proportional. It cannot yet be approved because the specified adaptive slot exists only in one of two active profile card schemas, leaving the production-profile adaptive surface without a real bounded editor.

## Claims
- `.gjc/_session-019fa820-c65f-7000-8f82-c3af63262111/plans/ralplan/019fa7fb-3be3-7000-b23f-03f6c05d81ff/index.jsonl` binds stage 05 to the requested path and SHA-256.
- The plan replaces free-form daily feedback with exact complete/missing canonical text and removes the legacy helpers (`stage-05-revision.md:34-42, 151-157`).
- It uses exactly direct OpenAI Chat Completions at `https://api.openai.com/v1`, `max_retries=0`, and rejects every alternate provider/transport (`stage-05-revision.md:100-125`).
- The frozen ledger and owner-deadline rule resolve the prior `timeout` versus abandoned-claim contradiction (`stage-05-revision.md:127-146`).
- The profile actually imported by `tests/gateway/test_adaptive_nutrition.py:11-13` is `physique-coach`; its `render_operator_card` has decision/reason/fact/status lines, not the plan's proposed current-judgment/review-reason spans (`/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/workspace/checkin_cli/checkin_cli/adaptive_nutrition.py:4649-4688`). The richer dualcoachtest schema does have those spans (`/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/workspace/checkin_cli/checkin_cli/adaptive_nutrition.py:4877-4916`).

## Analysis
### Spec compliance
Daily and weekly meet the requested bounded-editor boundary: canonical rendering precedes postprocessing, locked non-slot content remains code-owned, failure/recovery is canonical, and weekly enhancement precedes the existing digest/reservation seam. Adaptive is incomplete across the deployed profile variants. The requested adaptive operator surface cannot be declared selected in the physique-coach profile because its canonical renderer supplies none of the plan's specified slots; the release requirement for a valid selected adaptive output therefore cannot be satisfied honestly for that profile.

### Architecture
The direct OpenAI-only factory, opaque-anchor protocol, strict parser, append-only claim ledger, and no-recovery-call rule are a sound narrow replacement for the legacy daily free-form path. Keeping all new logic in a shared gateway module and not changing `agent.auxiliary_client` avoids broad provider coupling.

The plan should add a versioned canonical-surface builder that recognizes both profile card schemas. It must define an actual semantic-only eligible slot for the physique-coach variant, or intentionally introduce a code-owned locked presentation paragraph before `mark_publish_pending`; unknown card shapes must be canonical/no-call. Also route every eligible fresh-card ingress through that builder or explicitly keep that ingress ineligible and remove it from the cross-adaptive claim.

The durable selected artifact is described as encrypted but the format is not frozen. A random HMAC key and 0600 mode do not define authenticated encryption or a compatible replay object. This is a maintainability and privacy gap, not a reason to broaden the provider surface.

## Root Cause
The revision generalized the renderer module but assumed the dualcoachtest adaptive card shape. The current shared gateway supports two materially different profile-local adaptive renderers, so a surface contract defined from only one cannot provide all-profile adaptive coverage.

## Findings
1. **HIGH — `stage-05-revision.md:31-51`: Define an eligible adaptive slot for the physique-coach card schema.** Reported as P1. The plan names current-judgment/review-reason spans that do not exist in the profile imported by the gateway adaptive suite. Impact: adaptive selected output is impossible or an implementation must invent unreviewed slot rules, violating the cross-surface product request. Fix: version profile card builders, define exact locked slots for each supported schema (including an explicit semantic-only physique-coach slot), and test selected/canonical/replay behavior in both profiles.
2. **MEDIUM — `stage-05-revision.md:134-143`: Freeze the sealed-presentation cryptographic format and dependency.** Reported as P2. No AEAD format, key derivation, nonce/AAD binding, atomic file layout, or direct guaranteed crypto dependency is specified. Fix: version an authenticated encrypted artifact (for example AES-256-GCM using HKDF-derived encryption key, random 96-bit nonce, and schema/surface/artifact-key AAD), pin/use a guaranteed primitive, and test tamper/replacement failures as canonical/no-call.

## Recommendations
1. Resolve the P1 before implementation: enumerate supported adaptive render versions and their deterministic slot/manifest builders; add a code-owned safe paragraph to the physique-coach renderer if it lacks a nonsemantic existing span.
2. Include the note-revision `AdaptiveOperatorService.handle_text` card route in the same fresh-card/persistence design or explicitly keep it canonical and narrow the product claim accordingly.
3. Freeze the sealed artifact cryptographic envelope and dependency, retaining the current HMAC identity ledger and fail-closed behavior.
4. Retain all resolved prior controls: direct OpenAI-only/no retry, no auxiliary router, canonical daily cutover, prior-reservation weekly placement, fresh-card-only adaptive placement, immutable recovery, and enum-only telemetry.

## Architectural Status
BLOCK

## Code Review Recommendation
REQUEST CHANGES

## Tradeoffs
- **Support both current card schemas with versioned builders:** fulfills adaptive coverage and preserves profile compatibility; requires two golden manifests.
- **Support only the richer dualcoachtest schema:** smaller first patch, but does not meet cross-adaptive coverage for the physique-coach deployment.
- **Add one code-owned semantic-only legacy presentation paragraph:** gives the physique-coach card a bounded slot without changing proposal authority; modest visible-layout change that must be golden-tested and durably pinned.