## Verdict
**OKAY**

## Claim Checks
- The reviewed revision is the requested immutable artifact: its `index.jsonl` records stage `revision`, `stage_n: 3`, path `/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.gjc/_session-019fadfd-c01c-7000-a075-15571c91a314/plans/ralplan/019fadfd-c01c-7000-a075-15571c91a314/stage-03-revision.md`, and SHA-256 `5511ef03c220b36f4f4aaa4be6d85ce77d3ccfc98e3a45845d1d2dd5f3dc3cbe`.
- Pass-3 review was delta-only. The carryover HIGH on plugin authorization is resolved: the exact temporary-home configuration now contains `plugins.enabled: [dual_coach]`, fixes both manifest and entry-point identity to `dual_coach`, and keeps `plugins.dual_coach.enabled`, ingress, console, scheduler, activation, and delivery flags false. Current host evidence corroborates the contract: `hermes_cli/plugins.py::_get_enabled_plugins` reads the allow-list; `_discover_and_load_inner` skips non-bundled standalone/entry-point plugins not present in it; `_scan_entry_points` sets both name and key from `ep.name`. The planned negative/positive E2E proves no CLI load without authorization and successful discovery, help, and preflight with authorization while operational flags and network/provider/write counters remain disabled.
- The carryover HIGH on host/plugin deliverable conflation is resolved. Topology A pins `HERMES_BASE`, a separate `PLUGIN_SHA`, and plugin wheel checksum, runs the private suite/build from `PLUGIN_ROOT`, installs host plus exact plugin wheel for E2E, and explicitly creates no Hermes replacement PR or replacement candidate SHA. Topology B pins separate host/plugin source revisions and wheel checksums, runs verification from `HERMES_HOOK_ROOT` and `PLUGIN_ROOT`, installs both exact artifacts for joint E2E, and limits the replacement PR to approved generic host paths. Topology C remains stopped absent its existing two-human written exception and topology-specific identities/tests/rollback.
- Representative execution paths are determinate. For discovery, an executor can install the named plugin artifact into an isolated environment, run the negative allow-list case, apply the exact all-disabled config, and run list/help/preflight with explicit zero-effect and redaction assertions. For A, the executor uses only the private plugin root and immutable host compatibility input, with no fictitious host diff or legacy host test. For B, the executor independently builds/tests host hooks and plugin, then verifies the exact compatibility tuple before any generic-only PR.
- The current-pass Architect artifact is also the requested immutable artifact; its index records SHA-256 `31a655b8751ace99adb9876692fdc5784bd850ebe2b879052bbc14bb1a47c802`. Its CLEAR/APPROVE analysis stays confined to the two pass-2 HIGHs, preserves prior gates and stop boundaries, and introduces no unjustified scope expansion. No Architect inflation defect is present.

## Missing Evidence
None at plan-review time. The named-human topology/`invalid`-premise decision and signed hunk appendix are deliberately pre-implementation gates, not evidence the executor may assume; absence, ambiguity, or rejection remains a stop.

## Approval Boundary
Execution is approved only after the plan's explicit two-human topology/maintainer gate and signed hunk-ledger gate are satisfied. Proceed with exactly one selected topology row, its named roots, source identities, binary checksums, tests, E2E inputs, PR semantics, and rollback contract. Pre-gate work is limited to read-only evidence and gate preparation. No executor merge, force update, remote deletion, mutation of #74072, live credentials/accounts/providers, Gate-D, activation, customer delivery, rollout, or crossing of any stated stop condition is approved.

## Summary
- **Clarity:** The pass-3 delta explicitly separates host discovery authorization from behavioral disablement and distinguishes topology-specific artifacts and commands.
- **Verifiability:** Exact allow-list identity, negative/positive isolated discovery, distinct SHAs/checksums, root-specific suites/builds, joint E2E, write-set, network, and redaction assertions are actionable.
- **Completeness:** Both carryover HIGHs are closed without reopening previously approved topology, isolation, ledger, rollback, offline, or safety ground.
- **Big Picture:** A remains the least-coupled default, B is a maintainer-approved generic host extension plus private consumer, and C remains exception-only.
- **Principle/Option Consistency:** Plugin-first placement, generic-only public hooks, immutable provenance, and fail-closed no-live boundaries remain consistent across the matrix.
- **Alternatives Depth:** A/B/C tradeoffs and ownership consequences are sufficient for the required human decision; no new alternative analysis is needed on pass 3.
- **Risk/Verification Rigor:** Discovery-key mismatch, artifact/root conflation, wrong-head publication, leakage, I/O, resend ambiguity, and topology drift have explicit proofs or stop conditions.

## Required Changes
None.