{ "schema": "AdversarialVerify-v1", "task_id": "st_01a058bc", "todo": 1, "subject": "Typed nutrition_daily unknown state and partial canonical event projection", "verdict": "confirmed", "confidence": { "score": 0.99, "basis": "The refreshed receipt's three changed-file SHA-256 values exactly match the inspected bytes. Independent focused and required suites passed, and an isolated synthetic flow exercised every frozen blocker through the real WizardService and durable storage boundary." }, "scope": { "implementation_root": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "updated_implementation_evidence": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-1-domain-unknown.json", "prior_blocker_ledger": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-1-adversarial-verify.json", "frozen_blockers": [ "reserved free-text sentinel leakage", "future unknown marker/cursor coherence", "all-unknown branch must remain null while known evidence remains normal" ], "reviewed_files": [ "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard_models.py", "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard.py", "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard_storage.py", "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py", "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_customer_nutrition_wizard.py", "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_customer_reporting.py", "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_wizard_domain.py" ], "product_or_test_edits": false, "network_or_customer_messages": false, "commit": false }, "hash_verification": { "result": "PASS", "receipt_inventory_match": true, "files": { "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard_models.py": { "expected_sha256": "97cf03d068038ac3fc641806ae366c0a7762c72576910412fa61bfdd37819db0", "actual_sha256": "97cf03d068038ac3fc641806ae366c0a7762c72576910412fa61bfdd37819db0", "match": true }, "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard.py": { "expected_sha256": "9ad1549953df5401bb5fe94f3636c0e433abd05d7e4ca2a9ff657529e7d16586", "actual_sha256": "9ad1549953df5401bb5fe94f3636c0e433abd05d7e4ca2a9ff657529e7d16586", "match": true }, "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py": { "expected_sha256": "593e3eb1ff201f62141fbf1aeeaf779149ff830a566b0e93edd2b557c4d49dc5", "actual_sha256": "593e3eb1ff201f62141fbf1aeeaf779149ff830a566b0e93edd2b557c4d49dc5", "match": true } }, "dirty_inventory": { "result": "unavailable", "reason": "The implementation root has no .git directory; the exact receipt-to-byte hash match is the available source-identity check." } }, "evidence": { "focused_blocker_suite": { "command": "cd /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/dualcoach/profile && uv run pytest -q tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py -k 'reserved_unknown_literals or cursor_rejects_future_markers or all_unknown_nutrition or complete_known_nutrition_flow_remains_canonical'", "result": "13 passed, 6 deselected in 0.53s", "exit_code": 0, "coverage": [ "all ten literal/free-text boundary combinations", "future-marker and unrepresented-history validation", "all-unknown branch and canonical null projection", "complete known normal nutrition flow" ] }, "required_regression_suite": { "command": "cd /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/dualcoach/profile && uv run pytest -q tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py tests/test_customer_nutrition_wizard.py tests/test_customer_reporting.py tests/test_wizard_domain.py", "result": "96 passed in 4.41s", "collected": "96 tests collected in 0.11s", "exit_code": 0, "regression_result": "PASS" }, "isolated_manual_synthetic_flow": { "command": "uv run --directory /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/dualcoach/profile python -B /tmp/st_01a058bc-task1-manual-verify.py", "result": { "sentinel_rejections": 10, "future_marker": "rejected_before_resume", "all_unknown": { "branch": null, "canonical_check_in": {}, "unknown_steps": 11 }, "known_flow_branch": "normal", "temporary_home_removed_on_exit": true }, "exit_code": 0, "independent_exercise": [ "For each of meals, digestion, appetite_stress, training_summary, and optional_note, both exact reserved literals unknown and 모름 returned INVALID without changing version, answers, or unknown_steps.", "A fresh v2 bodyweight draft forged with unknown_steps=[calories] raised ValidationError containing future or unvisited both during direct validation and when a new WizardService attempted to resume the tampered persisted draft.", "Eleven explicit unknown transitions plus optional-note skip saved one accepted event with branch=null, an empty serialized canonical check_in, and eleven private unknown markers.", "A separate complete known flow saved with branch=normal, preserving the normal regression contract." ], "cleanup": "PASS: the disposable driver was removed after execution and a final absence check returned MANUAL_DRIVER_FINAL_ABSENT=PASS." }, "diagnostics": { "wizard_models_py": "PASS: LSP returned No diagnostics found.", "test_nutrition_daily_unknown_py": "PASS: LSP returned No diagnostics found.", "wizard_py": { "result": "30 basedpyright diagnostics", "classification": "pre-existing unrelated diagnostics", "basis": "The exact source hash matches the refreshed implementation receipt, which records the same whole-file wizard.py diagnostics as pre-existing; no source hash mismatch or suppression change exists.", "examples": [ "unused timedelta import", "legacy private API usage", "existing unknown/Any mappings", "existing unused-call-result reports" ] }, "suppression_scan": { "result": "PASS", "command": "rg -n '(#\\s*(type:\\s*ignore|pyright:|mypy:|noqa)|basedpyright:)' checkin_cli/wizard_models.py checkin_cli/wizard.py tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py", "output": "no matches" }, "timing_scan": { "result": "PASS", "command": "rg -n '(time\\.sleep|asyncio\\.sleep|wait_for|poll)' checkin_cli/wizard_models.py checkin_cli/wizard.py tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py", "output": "no matches" } } }, "blocker_disposition": [ { "id": "T1-SENTINEL-LEAKAGE", "result": "PASS", "prior_failure": "Exact unknown and 모름 submitted as ordinary nutrition free text were accepted and could serialize into a canonical event.", "confirmed_closure": "The parser rejects both literals at all five nutrition free-text boundaries before state mutation. The isolated flow confirms ten INVALID outcomes and no answer/unknown-marker mutation; the all-unknown canonical event contains neither literal." }, { "id": "T1-FUTURE-MARKER-CURSOR", "result": "PASS", "prior_failure": "A v2 bodyweight draft carrying a future calories unknown marker could resume and skip calories without an action.", "confirmed_closure": "WizardSession rejects the forged marker as future or unvisited. The persisted-tamper resume attempt also raises ValidationError before a cursor transition, so the malformed state cannot silently skip the field." }, { "id": "T1-ALL-UNKNOWN-BRANCH", "result": "PASS", "prior_failure": "An all-unknown nutrition save returned branch=normal.", "confirmed_closure": "The isolated all-unknown flow returns and persists branch=null while the accepted canonical check_in is empty. A separate full known flow returns and persists branch=normal." } ], "repro": [ { "case": "reserved free-text literals", "steps": [ "Start an isolated nutrition_daily WizardService session.", "Use explicit unknown only to reach each free-text boundary.", "Submit unknown and 모름 separately with action=value.", "Read the durable draft after each attempt." ], "expected": "Each reserved literal is INVALID and leaves version, answers, and unknown_steps unchanged.", "actual": "10/10 attempts were rejected; no state mutation occurred." }, { "case": "future unknown marker", "steps": [ "Start an isolated v2 nutrition draft at bodyweight.", "Forge its JSON-compatible payload with unknown_steps=[calories] and no completed calories state.", "Validate the model, then place that payload at the draft path and attempt resume through a new WizardService." ], "expected": "Validation rejects the future marker before resume or cursor advancement.", "actual": "Both checks raised ValidationError containing future or unvisited." }, { "case": "all unknown versus known branch", "steps": [ "In one isolated session, submit explicit unknown for all eleven eligible nutrition fields, skip optional_note, and save.", "In a separate isolated session, submit valid known values for every nutrition field, skip optional_note, and save." ], "expected": "All-unknown saves as branch=null; known normal evidence saves as branch=normal.", "actual": "All-unknown produced branch=null, 11 markers, and canonical_check_in={}; known flow produced branch=normal." } ], "adversarial_disposition": { "regressions_introduced_by_fixes": "PASS: focused blocker selection and the full required 96-test suite passed in one run.", "post_save_replay": "PASS: covered by the all-unknown regression test in the required suite; replay is rejected without a duplicate event.", "legacy_transition_and_navigation": "PASS: covered by the required suite's v1 upgrade, defer/resume, previous, correction replacement, and stale-version tests.", "nondeterminism": "PASS: inspected Todo 1 source/test files contain no sleep, polling, or wait patterns; tests and manual flow use isolated filesystem state.", "prompt_injection": "not applicable: this typed profile-domain surface consumes no prompt/model input.", "network_or_customer_messages": "not invoked: only standalone local WizardService, temporary filesystem storage, and local pytest were used.", "diagnostic_suppression": "PASS: no type/lint suppression directive is present in the three changed files." }, "completion_gate": "Satisfied: all three frozen blockers and regressions are independently confirmed on receipt-hashed bytes." }