{
  "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-debug-observer-r70-v1",
  "task_id": "st_01a05b00",
  "captured_at": "2026-09-01T12:28:21+09:00",
  "mode": "read_only_runtime_debug",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED_OBSERVER_INPUT_ROOT_BUG_WITH_SEPARATE_UNRESOLVED_CRON_RUNTIME_DEFECT",
  "summary": "observer-r70 reads a legacy unsuffixed weekly-operations authority root containing only 2026-08-30, while the active r70 config and dispatcher use data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159, which already contained a valid 2026-08-31 operational day-status row before the 23:05 deadline. The exact evaluate() calculation toggles FAIL to PASS solely by selecting the configured root. Customer input is not required. The schedule dispatcher error began later, immediately after a 09:36:59 canonical event/sequence update, and remains an independent Todo10 blocker whose lower-level in-process cause was not safely toggle-confirmed under the read-only/no-restart constraints.",
  "hypotheses": [
    {
      "id": "H1",
      "claim": "The active schedule dispatcher failed to produce the required 2026-08-31 day-status output.",
      "status": "REFUTED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The runtime-configured authority root must lack a 2026-08-31 row if this is true.",
      "observed": [
        "config.yaml:654 selects data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159.",
        "That root's day-status file has one row with kst_day=2026-08-31 and occurred_at_kst=2026-08-31T23:00:00+09:00.",
        "The file mtime is 2026-08-31T23:00:42.538693496+09:00, before FIRST_DAY_DEADLINE=2026-08-31T23:05:00+09:00.",
        "The row state is missed and canonical_sequence is zero, proving the operational cutoff generated a status without requiring a customer check-in."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "H2",
      "claim": "observer-r70 reads a stale policy/input root rather than the authority root selected by active r70 configuration.",
      "status": "CONFIRMED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The observer path and active config path differ, and swapping only the root's day set toggles evaluate() at the failure timestamp.",
      "observed": [
        "scripts/nutricoach_v150_observer_runtime.py:152-160 hard-codes PROFILE/data/weekly-operations-authority.",
        "config.yaml:654 selects data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159.",
        "scripts/nutricoach_v150_weekly_authority.py:43-52 intentionally suffixes a successor authority with candidate_digest[:16] whenever the predecessor root already exists.",
        "The unsuffixed root contains only kst_day=2026-08-30; the configured r70 root contains kst_day=2026-08-31.",
        "Two copied-state evaluation rounds at 2026-09-01T12:20:26.471912+09:00 produced legacy observer path => FAIL(first_day_status) and configured path => PASS, with every other RuntimeSnapshot field held at the observed healthy value."
      ],
      "toggle_proof": {
        "round_1": {
          "legacy_unsuffixed_days": "FAIL:first_day_status",
          "configured_r70_days": "PASS"
        },
        "round_2": {
          "legacy_unsuffixed_days": "FAIL:first_day_status",
          "configured_r70_days": "PASS"
        },
        "scope": "Copied day-status files and the production evaluate() function; no observer append or live mutation."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "H3",
      "claim": "The first_day_status failure is genuinely customer-dependent and requires a new customer check-in or external condition.",
      "status": "REFUTED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "A qualifying day-status must already exist without a customer event, or evaluate() must ignore status contents and require only day membership.",
      "observed": [
        "scripts/nutricoach_v150_observer_contract.py:73-74 checks only membership of date(2026, 8, 31) in day_status_days.",
        "The configured root's 2026-08-31 row is state=missed with no source event and canonical_sequence=0.",
        "That row existed at 23:00:42 on 2026-08-31, hours before the later 09:36:59 event/sequence update on 2026-09-01."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "H4",
      "claim": "The latest observer failure is caused directly by the current schedule dispatcher error.",
      "status": "REFUTED_AS_DIRECT_CAUSE_BUT_REMAINS_AN_INDEPENDENT_BLOCKER",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The required day-status output chronology and observer input path determine whether the failures share one mechanism.",
      "observed": [
        "The required configured-root status was successfully generated at 2026-08-31T23:00:42+09:00.",
        "Cron output remained successful through 2026-09-01T09:36:46+09:00.",
        "Canonical events, canonical sequence, and weekly view changed at 2026-09-01T09:36:59+09:00.",
        "The first cron failure appears at 2026-09-01T09:37:46+09:00 and says weekly operations failed: canonical authority identity drift.",
        "Observer first_day_status had already been failing since 2026-08-31T23:10:26+09:00 because it never read the configured root."
      ],
      "cron_lower_level_disposition": "UNRESOLVED_READ_ONLY",
      "cron_runtime_evidence": [
        "cron/jobs.json is enabled, scheduled every minute, and latest status is error with last_error=weekly operations failed: canonical authority identity drift.",
        "Installed code checkin_cli/weekly_operations_canonical_snapshot.py:55-67 raises that exact error when a pinned descriptor's device/inode/mode/owner/link tuple differs.",
        "At capture, persisted root/events/sequence/lock identities all match their canonical registration row, process fds 20/23/24/25 point to those exact files, and those fd identities also match. This rules out a continuing on-disk identity mismatch but does not expose the in-memory pin/object lifecycle that raised during the tick.",
        "No service restart, tick trigger, debugger mutation, customer operation, or cron repair was performed, so restart/reacquisition as the corrective toggle remains intentionally untested."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "policy_and_calculation": {
    "window_start": "2026-09-01T00:00:00+09:00",
    "window_end": "2026-09-08T00:00:00+09:00",
    "first_day_deadline": "2026-08-31T23:05:00+09:00",
    "required_day": "2026-08-31",
    "rule": "At or after FIRST_DAY_DEADLINE, append first_day_status only when 2026-08-31 is absent from snapshot.day_status_days.",
    "collection_rule": "_day_status_days() unions kst_day values from *.day-status-v1.jsonl under one hard-coded authority directory.",
    "policy_window_assessment": "The deadline is internally consistent with the 23:00 cutoff and the configured row was generated before it. The stale element is the authority root binding, not the deadline/window."
  },
  "observer_94_row_anchor": {
    "path": "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/observer-r70/observations.jsonl",
    "row_count": 94,
    "file_sha256": "0ec164bc4577691f7267c04c8362e236d61bec3972d84ea37c5c35628e099f14",
    "hash_chain_verified_rows": 94,
    "hash_chain_valid": true,
    "head": "09f1a3bce0ad593963a9d1c689aa7f275ba062e57c74166eae68d89824091bfa",
    "latest": {
      "observed_at": "2026-09-01T12:20:26.471912+09:00",
      "status": "FAIL",
      "failures": [
        "first_day_status"
      ],
      "row_digest": "09f1a3bce0ad593963a9d1c689aa7f275ba062e57c74166eae68d89824091bfa",
      "previous_row_digest": "8dffae47792fe5fd448680883cc715d5e22ba8906ba2331745cc6d903eb46f86",
      "day_status_days": [
        "2026-08-30"
      ],
      "other_snapshot_invariants": "active, candidate match, committed receipts, capacity five, Channel Inbox OFF, zero restarts, two Telegram sockets, weekly enabled, and clean journal all passed"
    }
  },
  "pass_fail_transition": {
    "initial_pass": "2026-08-31T20:52:04.951528+09:00",
    "last_pass": {
      "observed_at": "2026-08-31T23:00:26.475077+09:00",
      "row_digest": "f28a035323178a78060b5231e140ad93022af978d8c58e4c140b66ee738c7905",
      "reason": "Before the 23:05 policy deadline; day set was still only 2026-08-30."
    },
    "first_fail": {
      "observed_at": "2026-08-31T23:10:26.484358+09:00",
      "row_digest": "1a9ca7d72078dfcd2fcbe6d38077476aca992c67225377c9181c880f4f0c66f9",
      "failures": [
        "first_day_status"
      ],
      "reason": "Deadline crossed while the hard-coded legacy root still lacked 2026-08-31."
    },
    "persistence": "first_day_status appears in every subsequent row through row 94; brief additional telegram_connection/service_journal failures cleared independently."
  },
  "runtime": {
    "gateway": {
      "service": "hermes-gateway-dualcoachtest.service",
      "active_state": "active",
      "sub_state": "running",
      "main_pid": 2447108,
      "nrestarts": 0,
      "runtime": "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/.strict-runtime/81a7a06e-v150/venv"
    },
    "observer": {
      "service_result_at_anchor": "failed:exit-code",
      "timer": "active/waiting",
      "checksum_manifest": "all four observer source files OK",
      "source_runtime_sha256": "1beaf13e799a8330e5cfb1e9b44a77bb4cc214b5b5d5ee7fb34412e36dfe99a7"
    },
    "configured_authority": {
      "relative_path": "data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159",
      "day_status_sha256": "7a8d7d6ecc66c863bc27793df6a5f3efd1ba0661cf3568095b6b9bcf4cb45208",
      "days": [
        "2026-08-31"
      ]
    },
    "observer_selected_authority": {
      "relative_path": "data/weekly-operations-authority",
      "day_status_sha256": "a9486be5f4d0bd6cda3e1c1f5635dbb8e5817574d32200e64754874da1074bda",
      "days": [
        "2026-08-30"
      ]
    }
  },
  "safe_recovery_plan": {
    "customer_input_required": false,
    "canonical_observer_pass_possible": true,
    "conditions_before_todo10_retry": [
      "Fix observer-r70 collection to read the authority path selected by the active r70 config, or bind it explicitly to data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159; do not merge or copy legacy rows into the configured authority.",
      "Add a failing-first regression where an unsuffixed predecessor root has 2026-08-30 and a configured candidate-suffixed root has 2026-08-31; require collection/evaluation to select the configured root and PASS after the deadline.",
      "Update the observer checksum manifest under the authorized operational workflow before any observer execution.",
      "Diagnose the cron descriptor/object lifecycle using a copied profile or controlled authorized restart. The first failure boundary is the 09:36:59 canonical event/sequence update; prove a fresh coordinator reacquisition or code fix yields one normal scheduled cron status=ok without sending a customer message.",
      "Do not launch r71 until cron latest status is ok and a new canonical observer-r70 row is PASS. The new observer row may be produced by the normal timer or an explicitly authorized manual observer run; either append is an operational action outside this read-only task.",
      "Immediately recheck r71 authorization, execution, successor runtime, and observer roots absent; recheck draft hash and launcher count zero before returning to Todo10."
    ],
    "important_separation": "Repairing cron alone cannot change observer-r70 because observer-r70 reads the wrong directory. Repairing the observer binding alone can produce PASS from already-existing operational output, but Todo10 still requires cron latest success. Both gates must be healthy.",
    "do_not_do": [
      "Do not request or fabricate a customer check-in.",
      "Do not append/copy a synthetic 2026-08-31 row into the legacy root.",
      "Do not restart services or timers without the separate operational authority and preserved-state preflight.",
      "Do not invoke the r71 launcher while either gate is unhealthy."
    ]
  },
  "protected_state": {
    "launcher_invocation_count": 0,
    "launcher_process_count": 0,
    "r71_authorization_root": "ABSENT",
    "r71_execution_root": "ABSENT",
    "r71_successor_runtime_root": "ABSENT",
    "observer_r71_root": "ABSENT",
    "live_draft": {
      "sha256_before_and_after": "69f6510e555b47984c6462b12da569b5bb67c051b1592ddb2ffb93898564b9c1",
      "touched_by_debug_task": false,
      "customer_values_recorded": false
    }
  },
  "no_effects": {
    "git_or_github_actions": 0,
    "source_or_live_state_edits": 0,
    "observer_rows_appended_by_task": 0,
    "service_or_timer_restarts": 0,
    "network_or_customer_messages": 0,
    "customer_updates": 0,
    "authority_actions": 0,
    "launcher_invocations": 0,
    "temporary_artifacts": "Copied-state repro directory was removed; no /tmp/st_01a05b00-repro.* path remains.",
    "only_persistent_artifact": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-debug-observer-r70.json"
  }
}