{
  "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-r71-preflight-blocker-adversarial-v1",
  "task_id": "st_01a05d9d",
  "captured_at_kst": "2026-09-02T01:05:00+09:00",
  "mode": "independent_read_only_adjudication_except_required_evidence_file",
  "verdict": "CONFIRMED_CORRECTED_GATE_PASS_BOTH_REPORTED_BLOCKERS_ARE_WRONG_CHECKS",
  "done_claim": false,
  "summary": "Neither stopped-r71 preflight blocker proves live drift. Blocker 1 used /usr/bin/python3 3.13.7 without pydantic, but every prior authoritative PASS used the PATH-resolved Miniconda CPython 3.12.9 interpreter whose binary hash is bound in the candidate manifest, with PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 and PYTHONPATH ordered as immutable preseal dependencies/site-packages then controller-source. Re-running the immutable r71 verifier under that exact environment exits 0 with V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED without installation. Blocker 2 is malformed: its expected customer-events value is 66 hexadecimal characters and therefore cannot be SHA-256, while its required draft basename is 33 hexadecimal characters and cannot be a canonical 32-character session id. The actual events file, bindings file, and both canonical draft files exactly match repeated task10 live baselines and current post-crash bytes. The malformed draft name splices the prefix of the active session id with the suffix of the second draft id. Corrected read-only preflight checks all pass. This adjudication does not authorize or invoke r71; the service remains inactive/dead, launcher count is zero, action roots are absent, and protected delivery ledgers are unchanged.",
  "hypotheses": [
    {
      "id": "H1",
      "claim": "The immutable r71 preseal is unverifiable because its dependencies are unavailable on the host.",
      "status": "REFUTED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The exact interpreter/environment used by the prior PASS must still import required dependencies and produce the immutable verifier sentinel without installation.",
      "observed": [
        "The prior task9 audit launched its harness with PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 python; PATH resolved python to /home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python.",
        "The harness launched the verifier through sys.executable, so the verifier interpreter was /home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python, CPython 3.12.9.",
        "The candidate manifest-bound interpreter binary SHA-256 is d9bc96d1ad0161db7ebdc8fdbc690530a9c29299feb2001cba6b29072e2a9051, matching /home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python3.12.",
        "That interpreter imports pydantic 2.12.5.",
        "The exact prior verifier environment set PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 and PYTHONPATH=/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-runtime-authority-r71/dependencies/site-packages:/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-runtime-authority-r71/controller-source.",
        "A current read-only rerun with that interpreter and environment exited 0 and printed status V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "H2",
      "claim": "The /usr/bin/python3 failure reveals corruption or dependency drift in the immutable preseal.",
      "status": "REFUTED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "Immutable artifact hashes would differ or the verified environment would also fail.",
      "observed": [
        "/usr/bin/python3 is a different CPython 3.13.7 installation and cannot import pydantic.",
        "The failed command omitted the previously verified PYTHONPATH and substituted an interpreter not used by the prior PASS.",
        "Current package-manifest, sealed-target, controller-source-manifest, permission package, and protected inventory hashes all equal their task9/task10 authority receipts.",
        "The canonical verifier passes unchanged under the audited environment."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "H3",
      "claim": "The customer events file drifted after the task10 baseline.",
      "status": "REFUTED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The current events.jsonl SHA-256 would differ from independently recorded task10 live baselines.",
      "observed": [
        "Current events.jsonl SHA-256 is 4a718b95dc35f7219be2f0c5c1b7ce1d67690489086b117fb82c898564010155.",
        "The same value is recorded by task-10-debug-observer-r70, task-10-r70-health-recovery, task-10-next-cron-no-send, task-10-debug-r70-startup-registration, and the stopped task-10-r71 production observation.",
        "The rejected required value is 4a718b95dc35f7219be2be54b402f19eb0af41dc35928206d19357a9d6f9053713, which is 66 hexadecimal characters and therefore is not a SHA-256 digest.",
        "The corrected sha256sum gate passes for the current events file."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "H4",
      "claim": "The active customer draft was renamed, deleted, or moved after the task10 baseline.",
      "status": "REFUTED",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The canonical draft basename, embedded session id, active binding, or file digest would differ from established task10 evidence.",
      "observed": [
        "The active canonical draft exists at wizard/drafts/235d1edf627bf3b9ba321caa32a198f0.json with SHA-256 69f6510e555b47984c6462b12da569b5bb67c051b1592ddb2ffb93898564b9c1.",
        "telegram-bindings.json active_session_id resolves to that exact existing basename.",
        "Both live draft basenames are 32 hexadecimal characters and each stem equals its document session_id.",
        "The rejected required basename 235d1edf627bf3b9ba045b41a880b05a7 is 33 hexadecimal characters. It combines the active draft's 235d... prefix with the dc99 draft's ...45b41a880b05a7 suffix and is not a schema-valid session pathname.",
        "The second canonical draft remains dc993802883dbb8ba045b41a880b05a7.json with SHA-256 d717125902230dc362c3e951ef0d6f656d0919dd0665f449f7056158b031dfab."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "H5",
      "claim": "A directory-tree digest was accidentally compared as if it were the customer events file digest.",
      "status": "REFUTED_AS_EXPLANATION_OF_THE_REQUIRED_VALUE_BUT_CONFIRMS_DIGEST_TYPE_CONFUSION",
      "distinguishing_evidence": "The malformed expected value would equal a reproducibly defined wizard or drafts tree digest.",
      "observed": [
        "The current events file SHA-256 is a 64-character file digest.",
        "A deterministic drafts file-tree digest over relative-name:file-sha rows is da603dedd6bc4ff362d9107be24bc82c661f48cd70989dbaf597406e512a70f4.",
        "A deterministic wizard file-tree digest is 99d3399915610f06d4b497832a11f65cf9568c8a1e426aeb6ed0f64227ce0ed9.",
        "A wizard state-tree digest including path, type, mode, size, link count, and file digest is 4cb1d8259ed8a455cd89e4733e46868732dd18f3232fde20778d08b9f079d17c.",
        "The rejected 66-character value equals none of those and cannot be any SHA-256. The preflight check conflated or corrupted values rather than detecting tree drift."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "blocker_1_interpreter_adjudication": {
    "reported_command": "/usr/bin/python3 -B $PRE/controller-source/scripts/verify_nutricoach_v150_preseal_v15.py",
    "reported_result": "exit 1, ModuleNotFoundError: No module named pydantic",
    "reported_interpreter": {
      "path": "/usr/bin/python3",
      "version": "3.13.7",
      "pydantic_available": false,
      "prior_pass_interpreter": false
    },
    "prior_pass_provenance": {
      "source": ".omo/senpi-task/children/st_01a05ae4/sessions/st_01a05ae4/2026-09-01T02-54-03-458Z_01a05ae3-56c2-7d6d-8896-378aa44c8ccd.jsonl",
      "outer_command": "PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 python /tmp/task9_integrity_audit_st_01a05ae4.py",
      "subprocess_api": "subprocess.run([sys.executable, absolute immutable verifier path], env=env)",
      "interpreter": "/home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python",
      "resolved_binary": "/home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python3.12",
      "version": "3.12.9",
      "binary_sha256": "d9bc96d1ad0161db7ebdc8fdbc690530a9c29299feb2001cba6b29072e2a9051",
      "pydantic_version": "2.12.5",
      "environment": {
        "PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE": "1",
        "PYTHONPATH_order": [
          "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-runtime-authority-r71/dependencies/site-packages",
          "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-runtime-authority-r71/controller-source"
        ]
      },
      "prior_assertion": "returncode == 0 and stdout contains V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED"
    },
    "current_read_only_reproduction": {
      "command_interpreter": "/home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python",
      "environment_equal_to_prior_pass": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "status": "V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED",
      "install_actions": 0,
      "artifact_mutations": 0
    },
    "classification": "WRONG_INTERPRETER_AND_MISSING_VERIFIED_ENVIRONMENT",
    "corrected_gate": "Run the immutable verifier with the manifest-bound Miniconda CPython and the prior audited PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE/PYTHONPATH environment; require exit 0 and the sentinel. Do not install dependencies and do not substitute /usr/bin/python3."
  },
  "blocker_2_hash_path_adjudication": {
    "reported_events_expectation": {
      "value": "4a718b95dc35f7219be2be54b402f19eb0af41dc35928206d19357a9d6f9053713",
      "length": 66,
      "valid_sha256_shape": false,
      "classification": "MALFORMED_EXPECTED_DIGEST"
    },
    "actual_events": {
      "relative_path": "data/customers/pilot_20260820_01/wizard/events.jsonl",
      "sha256": "4a718b95dc35f7219be2f0c5c1b7ce1d67690489086b117fb82c898564010155",
      "matches_task10_baseline": true,
      "matches_current_post_crash_bytes": true
    },
    "reported_draft_expectation": {
      "basename": "235d1edf627bf3b9ba045b41a880b05a7.json",
      "stem_length": 33,
      "valid_session_id_shape": false,
      "exists": false,
      "classification": "SPLICED_INVALID_PATHNAME"
    },
    "actual_profile_schema": {
      "draft_rule": "wizard/drafts/<32-hex session_id>.json; basename stem equals document session_id",
      "binding_rule": "telegram-bindings.json active_session_id selects an existing draft with the same 32-hex basename",
      "active_binding_resolves": true,
      "drafts": [
        {
          "basename": "235d1edf627bf3b9ba321caa32a198f0.json",
          "stem_length": 32,
          "stem_matches_session_id": true,
          "sha256": "69f6510e555b47984c6462b12da569b5bb67c051b1592ddb2ffb93898564b9c1",
          "matches_task10_baseline": true
        },
        {
          "basename": "dc993802883dbb8ba045b41a880b05a7.json",
          "stem_length": 32,
          "stem_matches_session_id": true,
          "sha256": "d717125902230dc362c3e951ef0d6f656d0919dd0665f449f7056158b031dfab",
          "matches_task10_baseline": true
        }
      ]
    },
    "binding_file": {
      "relative_path": "data/customers/pilot_20260820_01/wizard/telegram-bindings.json",
      "sha256": "318d62644dc480dbe2be54b402f19eb0af41dc35928206d19357a9d6f9053713",
      "matches_task10_baseline": true
    },
    "directory_tree_vs_file_hash": {
      "events_file_sha256": "4a718b95dc35f7219be2f0c5c1b7ce1d67690489086b117fb82c898564010155",
      "drafts_file_tree": {
        "files": 2,
        "sha256": "da603dedd6bc4ff362d9107be24bc82c661f48cd70989dbaf597406e512a70f4"
      },
      "wizard_file_tree": {
        "files": 9,
        "sha256": "99d3399915610f06d4b497832a11f65cf9568c8a1e426aeb6ed0f64227ce0ed9"
      },
      "wizard_state_tree": {
        "entries": 12,
        "sha256": "4cb1d8259ed8a455cd89e4733e46868732dd18f3232fde20778d08b9f079d17c"
      },
      "assessment": "File SHA-256 and directory-tree digests are different contracts and cannot be substituted. The reported 66-character value is neither."
    },
    "preflight_inventory_context": {
      "snapshot_before_sha256": "d2c084be0865f8e9844452a7b683f97800e31af9bc7e1a113241109a283aada5",
      "current_customer_events_row_present": false,
      "current_customer_draft_rows_present": false,
      "current_telegram_binding_row_present": true,
      "assessment": "The malformed events/draft gate was not an exact replay of rows from the authenticated snapshot-before inventory. Task10's later live baselines are the relevant post-activity byte anchors for these paths."
    },
    "classification": "WRONG_DIGEST_AND_WRONG_PATHNAME; NO_ACTUAL_TASK10_DRIFT"
  },
  "corrected_read_only_gate": {
    "status": "PASS",
    "preseal_verifier": "PASS: exit 0 and V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED under prior audited interpreter/environment",
    "files": [
      {
        "relative_path": "config.yaml",
        "sha256": "6a949de8c8a7c4caff4462f9c2821d49e5517a0f12defa93693e7f3bff97ed17",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "customers/registry.json",
        "sha256": "176a7e3c55e5be95583c122dc535f13b35ef6fd13c1fbf9445f3cc2be95dd95e",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/weekly-operations-topic59.jsonl",
        "sha256": "92ef87536865b4d74c50f9715601de7870c5c3893839f2862dbaf62024e51af5",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/scheduled-deliveries.jsonl",
        "sha256": "1000b155ccb56aa318ac098613f5808d2cb9633fc1178a0b49f280c3a23f72a1",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/scheduled-deliveries-fence.json",
        "sha256": "e647bdcdd1505e3d978c73d69934c9f04c20159bad4e12ac9d0c93b202442555",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/customers/pilot_20260820_01/wizard/events.jsonl",
        "sha256": "4a718b95dc35f7219be2f0c5c1b7ce1d67690489086b117fb82c898564010155",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/customers/pilot_20260820_01/wizard/telegram-bindings.json",
        "sha256": "318d62644dc480dbe2be54b402f19eb0af41dc35928206d19357a9d6f9053713",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/customers/pilot_20260820_01/wizard/drafts/235d1edf627bf3b9ba321caa32a198f0.json",
        "sha256": "69f6510e555b47984c6462b12da569b5bb67c051b1592ddb2ffb93898564b9c1",
        "result": "PASS"
      },
      {
        "relative_path": "data/customers/pilot_20260820_01/wizard/drafts/dc993802883dbb8ba045b41a880b05a7.json",
        "sha256": "d717125902230dc362c3e951ef0d6f656d0919dd0665f449f7056158b031dfab",
        "result": "PASS"
      }
    ],
    "reported_blocker_count_after_correction": 0,
    "launch_authorized_by_this_evidence": false,
    "reason_launch_not_authorized": "This task is adjudication only. Any future launcher command must be separately authorized and must use an interpreter/environment proven for the immutable launcher rather than the broken /usr/bin/python3 prescription."
  },
  "immutable_artifact_recheck": {
    "package_manifest_sha256": "66ede3f1995d644b9ce423c8e8846b50d823c57f76d892cef66694d7e1d3a793",
    "sealed_target_sha256": "b9f0cb2694ea0dcc49af7b0355fa491b3c74452c0f74ebc6c17f0b7c7b183c79",
    "controller_source_manifest_sha256": "0a4ad503db2f26aba4e050071fbc725f2ef0e6bd9216a6869d7123acf2047c8b",
    "permission_package_sha256": "21c8f3d3b2e95b37a1af2123fe196309a01eb6fb768bc38a15efa0973cfa666a",
    "protected_inventory_sha256": "d2c084be0865f8e9844452a7b683f97800e31af9bc7e1a113241109a283aada5",
    "all_match_prior_pass": true
  },
  "final_safe_state": {
    "service": {
      "active_state": "inactive",
      "sub_state": "dead",
      "main_pid": 0,
      "nrestarts": 26,
      "result": "exit-code",
      "not_restarting": true
    },
    "launcher": {
      "matching_process_count": 0,
      "task10_invocation_count": 0,
      "invocations_by_adjudication": 0
    },
    "r71_effect_roots": {
      "authorization": "ABSENT_E_AND_L",
      "execution": "ABSENT_E_AND_L",
      "successor_runtime": "ABSENT_E_AND_L",
      "observer": "ABSENT_E_AND_L"
    },
    "ledgers": {
      "topic59_sha256": "92ef87536865b4d74c50f9715601de7870c5c3893839f2862dbaf62024e51af5",
      "scheduled_deliveries_sha256": "1000b155ccb56aa318ac098613f5808d2cb9633fc1178a0b49f280c3a23f72a1",
      "scheduled_deliveries_fence_sha256": "e647bdcdd1505e3d978c73d69934c9f04c20159bad4e12ac9d0c93b202442555",
      "unchanged_from_task10": true
    }
  },
  "no_effects": {
    "source_or_live_state_edits": 0,
    "service_actions": 0,
    "launcher_actions": 0,
    "cron_or_observer_actions": 0,
    "network_or_provider_actions": 0,
    "customer_actions": 0,
    "dependency_installs": 0,
    "authority_actions": 0,
    "git_or_github_actions": 0,
    "customer_values_exposed": false,
    "only_persistent_artifact": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-r71-preflight-blocker-adversarial.json"
  }
}