{
  "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-r71-production-adversarial-final-v2",
  "task_id": "st_01a05dbb",
  "review": "DELTA_RE_REVIEW_PHASE_AWARE_CORRECTION",
  "verdict": "confirmed",
  "confidence": 0.995,
  "blocker_count": 0,
  "blockers": [],
  "summary": "Confirmed. The prior three reported blockers were phase-gate errors, not observed production defects. Sealed r71 explicitly mutates config.yaml and customers/registry.json during MIGRATED and their current bytes reproduce byte-for-byte from the authenticated pretransaction snapshots plus the sealed successor transformation. Their diffs contain only planned candidate/weekly-authority/admission fields. The immutable preseal verifier is a pre-authorization gate: after the sealed controller appends the successor runtime-authority event and creates terminal roots, DENIED:authority_baseline is its expected first postcommit denial. Fresh prelaunch PASS is recorded. No distinct immutable committed-state verifier exists, so the terminal authorization, execution/snapshot chain, runtime authority, exact wheels, unit/drop-in/credentials, service, natural cron, protected customer/delivery bytes, r71b non-selection, and isolated installed-wheel oracles were independently validated.",
  "corrected_prior_findings": [
    {
      "prior_code": "PROTECTED_CONFIG_PRETRANSACTION_BYTES_CHANGED",
      "disposition": "NOT_A_BLOCKER_PLANNED_POSTIMAGE",
      "proof": "ConcreteLiveHost.migration_apply calls sealed apply_migrations; apply_migrations atomically writes build_weekly_authority_postimage. A read-only independent reconstruction from post-stop snapshot 0000 plus the live post-migration registry identity produced SHA-256 9e3bf9fb... and bytes exactly equal current config.yaml."
    },
    {
      "prior_code": "PROTECTED_REGISTRY_PRETRANSACTION_BYTES_CHANGED",
      "disposition": "NOT_A_BLOCKER_PLANNED_POSTIMAGE",
      "proof": "Sealed capacity_after proposes max_enabled_customers=5 and candidate a41c97c8; receipt-preserving migration commits that proposal. Applying sealed capacity_after read-only to post-stop snapshot 0001 produced SHA-256 273ca4b2... and bytes exactly equal current customers/registry.json."
    },
    {
      "prior_code": "IMMUTABLE_PRESEAL_VERIFIER_NOT_POSTCOMMIT_VALID",
      "disposition": "NOT_A_BLOCKER_EXPECTED_PHASE_RESPONSE",
      "proof": "verify_nutricoach_v150_preseal_v15 compares the current runtime-authority pin to the sealed predecessor baseline before checking action-root/successor absence. The committed controller necessarily promoted authority from event_count 27 to 28 and changed registry/ledger heads before COMMITTED. Current supported-interpreter response rc=2 DENIED:authority_baseline is therefore the expected postcommit first denial, while the fresh prelaunch receipt records rc=0 V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED."
    }
  ],
  "sealed_identity": {
    "candidate_digest": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
    "package_digest": "4b032722f236dacc7f7e413cc37b31232000ce4f5d839bf0360fa8ac008ea6b1",
    "closure_digest": "sha256:0b6fae0262f828e8136e07ea0bb126e141655148363b3fe30059c554f8be9c46",
    "candidate_manifest_sha256": "a019f0b9a0bf1a393d2d307d0e755251a140e3449058077632209e2101090766",
    "package_manifest_sha256": "66ede3f1995d644b9ce423c8e8846b50d823c57f76d892cef66694d7e1d3a793",
    "sealed_target_sha256": "b9f0cb2694ea0dcc49af7b0355fa491b3c74452c0f74ebc6c17f0b7c7b183c79",
    "controller_source_manifest_sha256": "0a4ad503db2f26aba4e050071fbc725f2ef0e6bd9216a6869d7123acf2047c8b",
    "permission_package_sha256": "21c8f3d3b2e95b37a1af2123fe196309a01eb6fb768bc38a15efa0973cfa666a",
    "protected_inventory_sha256": "d2c084be0865f8e9844452a7b683f97800e31af9bc7e1a113241109a283aada5",
    "supported_interpreter": {
      "path": "/home/cube/miniconda3/bin/python3.12",
      "version": "CPython 3.12.9",
      "sha256": "d9bc96d1ad0161db7ebdc8fdbc690530a9c29299feb2001cba6b29072e2a9051"
    },
    "candidate_inventory": {
      "physical_files": 362,
      "manifest_rows": 360,
      "hash_mismatches": 0,
      "writable_files": 0,
      "symlinks": 0
    }
  },
  "phase_aware_preseal": {
    "fresh_prelaunch": {
      "status": "V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "recorded_in": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-r71-production.json",
      "candidate_digest": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
      "package_digest": "4b032722f236dacc7f7e413cc37b31232000ce4f5d839bf0360fa8ac008ea6b1"
    },
    "current_postcommit": {
      "exit_code": 2,
      "output": "DENIED:authority_baseline",
      "expected": true,
      "reason": "Sealed baseline has event_count=27 and predecessor authority heads. COMMITTED successor has event_count=28 and new a41c authority heads. The verifier checks this predicate before authority_root_exists and successor_exists."
    },
    "distinct_immutable_committed_state_verifier": "ABSENT_AFTER_SEALED_SCRIPT_AND_TEST_SEARCH"
  },
  "authenticated_postimages": {
    "registry": {
      "pretransaction_snapshot_sha256": "176a7e3c55e5be95583c122dc535f13b35ef6fd13c1fbf9445f3cc2be95dd95e",
      "derived_postcommit_sha256": "273ca4b2863aabf8e0fc749aac2440688a9358e2353d08b457e42ff11286a474",
      "current_sha256": "273ca4b2863aabf8e0fc749aac2440688a9358e2353d08b457e42ff11286a474",
      "byte_exact": true,
      "diff_count": 1,
      "diff_paths": ["admission_policy.candidate_digest"],
      "planned_fields_only": true,
      "candidate_digest": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
      "max_enabled_customers": 5,
      "customer_records_unchanged": true,
      "owner_unchanged": true
    },
    "config": {
      "pretransaction_snapshot_sha256": "6a949de8c8a7c4caff4462f9c2821d49e5517a0f12defa93693e7f3bff97ed17",
      "derived_postcommit_sha256": "9e3bf9fb0233e1c317b968eab6f51f5bc73f729d5a09a6b4011829eb7352f86b",
      "current_sha256": "9e3bf9fb0233e1c317b968eab6f51f5bc73f729d5a09a6b4011829eb7352f86b",
      "byte_exact": true,
      "diff_count": 8,
      "planned_fields_only": true,
      "diff_paths": [
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations.registry_identity_binding_digest",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations_authority.candidate_digest",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations_authority.config_digest",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations_authority.registry_identity.binding_digest",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations_authority.registry_identity.content_digest",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations_authority.registry_identity.inode",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.nutrition_coaching.weekly_operations_authority_path",
        "platforms.telegram.extra.production_preflight.candidate_package_identity"
      ],
      "weekly_authority_path": "data/weekly-operations-authority-a41c97c8a467b030",
      "weekly_capacity": 5,
      "registry_identity_binding_digest": "441f4b7489edfa4dc516c7416bd36fc98ea848d9d398f9b16fc51adbb070be54",
      "semantic_config_digest": "2a10899c3776934b73b21ff9974ad214024f16dde774de8486f6aa7d5c7c3b9e"
    },
    "derivation_source": "Immutable original r71 controller-source scripts/nutricoach_v150_host_operations.py, nutricoach_v150_concrete_host.py and nutricoach_v150_weekly_authority.py with authenticated post-stop snapshots. No live write was used."
  },
  "terminal_transaction_chain": {
    "launcher_invocation_count": 1,
    "retry_count": 0,
    "authorization": {
      "status": "CONSUMED",
      "outcome": "SUCCEEDED",
      "candidate_digest": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
      "sha256": "fc242dec4cab503922222377b047503529528c8aa666e38e0c34aaa77e297e19",
      "reservation_absent": true
    },
    "execution": {
      "schema": "nutricoach-v150-phase-journal-v3",
      "phase": "COMMITTED",
      "sha256": "4e5ff24c555205b9bfe7417cc02f70c375254065c70d6073a4025faf53b8ec9d"
    },
    "phase_order_enforced_by_immutable_controller": [
      "PREPARING", "RESERVED", "STOPPING", "SNAPSHOT", "INSTALLED", "MIGRATED", "STARTED", "COMMITTING", "COMMITTED"
    ],
    "snapshot_manifest_sha256": "10af42b307aa98173e96c22f811564ca3690da19b75f45788a8b8c7cea87d7fd",
    "launcher_stdout": "sha256:10af42b307aa98173e96c22f811564ca3690da19b75f45788a8b8c7cea87d7fd",
    "launcher_stdout_binds_exact_snapshot_manifest": true,
    "recovery_manifest_schema": "nutricoach-v150-recovery-manifest-v1",
    "recovery_manifest_sha256": "7d75c89066d0f92a3d319d8af7f7f35f14cde085583265aea3de58adb1bf0fb0",
    "note": "The phase journal is a durable terminal-state file, not an append-only phase hash ledger. Its ordered write chain is enforced by immutable controller control flow; the terminal phase, one-use authorization and exact snapshot-manifest return binding jointly validate the committed chain."
  },
  "runtime_authority": {
    "root": "/home/cube/.hermes/runtime-authority/dualcoach-v1.3.0-owner-risk-first-customer",
    "independent_verify_candidate_authority": "PASS",
    "current_qualified_candidate": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
    "event_count": 28,
    "registry_head_sha256": "4faa2094cc06665b7dfd9e82a46db14e66ed69a43cb30460d654f22bb257d47d",
    "ledger_head_sha256": "2e605b2747a17125af2713de26c0caac4ba3e0d68c76d73a2f2094e0b348677f",
    "rebuilt_pin_byte_exact": true,
    "pin_sha256": "af9940793e25b8e41c4545a70c313c53f7ceccb29bf36b5f399bc0925d76b84b",
    "weekly_authority_root": "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/data/weekly-operations-authority-a41c97c8a467b030",
    "weekly_authority_marker_sha256": "dd5981f94300d1fa9269fac018c8c309badee2dd4096daab82237630d105c57f",
    "canonical_registration_sha256": "b7a5dde559c7de527a69a41037e95d2337579370bf22668b064a7295e7b19e20",
    "canonical_registration_rows": 1
  },
  "runtime_and_service": {
    "runtime_root": "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/.strict-runtime/a41c97c8-v150",
    "unit_sha256": "514afc79a74d1f6c40ca18df4c5672e94fcff732ff5d579a8fd3bd07d5b7de65",
    "dropin_sha256": "a99d9d9370866ea5b0bb4f8819402a867d3ba439f098de60cece597219785992",
    "temporary_restart_override_absent": true,
    "effective_restart": "always",
    "event_driven_probe_before": {"ActiveState":"active","SubState":"running","MainPID":3376522,"NRestarts":0},
    "event_driven_probe_after_natural_cron_event": {"ActiveState":"active","SubState":"running","MainPID":3376522,"NRestarts":0},
    "pid_stable": true,
    "result": "success",
    "exec_main_status": 0,
    "telegram_established_sockets": 2,
    "bounded_journal_error_matches": 0,
    "credential_hashes": {
      "task26_authority_pin": "af9940793e25b8e41c4545a70c313c53f7ceccb29bf36b5f399bc0925d76b84b",
      "task26_candidate_digest": "d6ff6f974d29957905c05cf4c868da1181f9d4b28c311c6383b04d54a6979600",
      "operator_notification_recovery": "8d15fb067eaa110c5170007550faf4cebfae7d9ad51e398aae6d73bb84986982",
      "owner_risk_acceptance": "b9193806a20bd98cde9bf547494f31d81b56c6ec5e214383a539373b88658e47"
    },
    "wheel_origins": {
      "hermes_wheel_sha256": "17d5db319f9355a427c5b46cc4ea9a896d348c585793df085c170921e1ee2829",
      "profile_wheel_sha256": "2f1cae9ff6262f5c823dd41c68bc999dca71c56000bef6dc0a0268ab07c19c4f",
      "hermes_version": "0.17.0",
      "profile_version": "0.1.0",
      "both_direct_url_origins_select_r71_candidate_build1": true,
      "gateway_and_checkin_cli_below_a41c_runtime": true
    }
  },
  "natural_cron": {
    "subscription": "Linux inotify armed before observed natural jobs event",
    "last_run_at": "2026-09-02T01:18:27.005238+09:00",
    "last_status": "ok",
    "last_error": null,
    "next_run_at_was_future_at_observation": "2026-09-02T01:20:00+09:00",
    "enabled": true,
    "state": "scheduled",
    "manual_tick_count": 0,
    "sep2_customer_events": 0,
    "sep2_canonical_events": 0,
    "sep2_day_status_rows": 0,
    "sep2_topic59_rows": 0,
    "sep2_scheduled_delivery_rows": 0,
    "due_send": 0,
    "due_update": 0,
    "uncertain_retry": 0,
    "provider_send_count": 0,
    "provider_update_count": 0
  },
  "protected_pretransaction_exact": {
    "customer_events": "4a718b95dc35f7219be2f0c5c1b7ce1d67690489086b117fb82c898564010155",
    "telegram_bindings": "318d62644dc480dbe2be54b402f19eb0af41dc35928206d19357a9d6f9053713",
    "draft_235d": "69f6510e555b47984c6462b12da569b5bb67c051b1592ddb2ffb93898564b9c1",
    "draft_dc99": "d717125902230dc362c3e951ef0d6f656d0919dd0665f449f7056158b031dfab",
    "scheduled_deliveries": "1000b155ccb56aa318ac098613f5808d2cb9633fc1178a0b49f280c3a23f72a1",
    "scheduled_deliveries_fence": "e647bdcdd1505e3d978c73d69934c9f04c20159bad4e12ac9d0c93b202442555",
    "topic59": "92ef87536865b4d74c50f9715601de7870c5c3893839f2862dbaf62024e51af5",
    "all_match_recorded_pretransaction_or_corrected_baseline": true,
    "customer_or_provider_events": 0
  },
  "projection": {
    "capacity": 5,
    "enabled_customers": 1,
    "channel_inbox": "OFF",
    "binding_count": 2,
    "active_binding_resolves": true,
    "both_drafts_preserved": true,
    "projection_valid": true
  },
  "r71b_and_observer": {
    "r71b_selected": false,
    "r71b_candidate_manifest_mismatches": 0,
    "r71b_authorization_root": "ABSENT",
    "r71b_execution_root": "ABSENT",
    "r71b_successor_runtime": "ABSENT",
    "observer_r71": "ABSENT",
    "partial_r71b_tombstones_preserved": true
  },
  "isolated_installed_oracles_recheck": {
    "legacy_lifecycle": {
      "status":"PASS","preserved_v1_identity":true,"startup_mutations":0,"duplicate_advances":0,"expired_sends":0,"telegram_sends":0,"network_events":0
    },
    "current_stepper": {
      "status":"PASS","automatic_recovery_sends0":true,"customer_messages":0,"duplicate_advances0":true,"polling_unknown_terminal":true,"resume_target":"nutrition_daily","network_events":0
    },
    "malformed_ingress": {
      "status":"PASS","result":"2 passed, 5 deselected","network_events":0,"production_mutation":0
    },
    "temporary_roots_removed": true
  },
  "forbidden_effects": {
    "source_or_live_edits": 0,
    "service_actions": 0,
    "cron_or_manual_job_actions": 0,
    "observer_actions": 0,
    "network_provider_customer_actions": 0,
    "git_actions": 0,
    "only_persistent_write": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-r71-production-adversarial-final.json"
  }
}