{ "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-r71b-controller-source-adversarial-v4", "task_id": "st_01a05c3d", "reviewed_task_id": "st_01a05c0f", "review_mode": "final_delta_two_blocker_re_review", "captured_at": "2026-09-01T19:48:36+09:00", "worktree": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "amended_receipt": { "path": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-r71b-controller-source.json", "sha256": "2ae4db9e39752777abd3f0df192878ffa4b0e03c540945563b080cdfbb679306", "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-r71b-controller-source-v4" }, "verdict": "confirmed", "confidence": 0.99, "blocker_count": 0, "ready_for_disposable_packaging": true, "prior_blocker_disposition": { "TASK10_OBSERVER_AND_COLLECTOR_EVIDENCE_NOT_EXACT_OR_VALIDATED": "closed", "ACTUAL_PRECONFIRM_ROLLBACK_AND_PERSISTED_CONFIRM_RECOVERY_NOT_TERMINAL": "closed" }, "evidence": { "task10_evidence_boundary": { "status": "PASS", "exact_sources": [ { "logical_name": "r70_error", "path": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-cron-no-send-recovery-analysis.json", "sha256": "968a3ea4e15d149736d47c239d410ed9b88b7dbb20e0703214a2a6b19c3025d0", "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-cron-no-send-recovery-analysis-v1", "task_id": "st_01a05b16", "verdict": "NO_SAFE_PATH" }, { "logical_name": "observer", "path": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-debug-observer-r70.json", "sha256": "5f367a44f23dfa072ea1a1bb4fbdb9e216e8c832fbcc608157ad0624de4541a9", "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-debug-observer-r70-v1", "task_id": "st_01a05b00", "verdict": "CONFIRMED_OBSERVER_INPUT_ROOT_BUG_WITH_SEPARATE_UNRESOLVED_CRON_RUNTIME_DEFECT" }, { "logical_name": "health_recovery", "path": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-r70-health-recovery.json", "sha256": "b1bbe2fec619d66570b5025d7760878ae3f0421825c50b19630065fbf8963f13", "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-r70-health-recovery-v1", "task_id": "st_01a05b07", "status": "BLOCKED_RESTART_SAFETY_NO_REPLAY" } ], "source_contract": "The CLI requires all three paths. Validation requires the fixed absolute path and parent, regular/no-follow/single-link form, exact 0664 mode, effective UID/GID, exact SHA-256, duplicate-key-safe JSON object, exact schema/task/status, and report-specific no-action semantics. The sealer writes canonical provenance envelopes; candidate verification and preparer replay independently reread the fixed sources and compare the embedded source document.", "manifest_binding": "The three canonical candidate copies appear in input_inventory with individual digests; their exact three-row inventory digest is included in derivation_inputs and candidate_digest. Candidate verification independently invokes verify_candidate_task10_evidence after physical hash verification, so recomputing the outer manifest cannot bypass fixed-source provenance.", "preparer_consumption": "collect_authoritative_r71b_preflight loads the three candidate-bound copies through verify_candidate_task10_evidence and places canonical Task10 provenance rows into package binding inputs.", "independent_substitution_matrix": { "exact_three_sources": "PASS", "empty_object_source": "REJECT task10_evidence_path", "non_json_observer": "REJECT task10_evidence_path", "stale_collector": "REJECT task10_evidence_path", "right_basename_wrong_parent": "REJECT task10_evidence_path", "candidate_symlink": "REJECT candidate_task10_evidence_file", "candidate_hardlink": "REJECT candidate_task10_evidence_file", "candidate_wrong_mode": "REJECT candidate_task10_evidence_file", "candidate_wrong_group_ownership": "REJECT candidate_task10_evidence_file", "canonical_recomputed_copy_and_manifest_substitution": "REJECT candidate_task10_evidence_substitution", "omission": "REJECT by required CLI argument, source read, exact candidate path set, or physical inventory", "postseal_tamper": "REJECT by candidate inventory hash and independent fixed-source comparison" } }, "maintenance_transaction": { "status": "PASS", "committed_lifecycle": { "surface": "ConcreteLiveHost.disposable, actual R71bMaintenanceFiles, real inotify jobs.json replacement, synchronous fake maintenance tick, real post_fence", "phase": "COMMITTED", "successor_dropin": "exact retained successor postimage", "maintenance_credential": "exact authority bytes, regular single-link mode 0400, retained for authenticated same-day repeat no-ops", "audit_cron_ledger": "canonical audit, cron ok/error-null row, typed output, unchanged publication ledger", "provider_calls": 0, "network_calls": 0 }, "preconfirm_start_fault": { "surface": "Actual ConcreteLiveHost.disposable start-stage fault through execute_disposable", "predecessor_bytes_restored": true, "maintenance_credential_absent": true, "cron_enabled": false, "cron_state": "paused", "cron_known_incident_error_preserved": true, "service_running": true, "service_nrestarts": 0, "phase": "ROLLED_BACK_SAFE_CRON_PAUSED", "terminal": true, "provider_calls": 0, "network_calls": 0 }, "terminal_recovery_replay": { "recover_pending_result": "no-op", "phase_after": "ROLLED_BACK_SAFE_CRON_PAUSED", "service_state_unchanged": true, "predecessor_bytes_unchanged": true, "second_rollback": false }, "persisted_confirmed_recovery": { "surface": "Process-death simulation with a new ConcreteLiveHost instance and empty in-memory postimage map", "postimage_source": "Canonical candidate-bound successor-postimages.json persisted at switch, then loaded with exact path-set, candidate, canonical encoding and current-file digest validation", "post_fence": "real, not monkeypatched", "audit_cron_ledger_credential": "revalidated from durable success state", "phase": "COMMITTED", "authorization_outcome": "SUCCEEDED", "service_running": true, "provider_calls": 0, "network_calls": 0 }, "focused_lifecycle_file": "3 passed in 1.89s" }, "strict": { "ruff_current_receipt_29_files": "PASS", "ty_current_receipt_29_files": "PASS", "basedpyright_current_receipt_29_files": "0 errors, 0 warnings, 0 notes", "lsp_current_receipt_29_files": "29 of 29 no diagnostics", "compile_import_current_21_sources": "PASS", "escape_scan": "No new Any, ignore, noqa, broad catch, sleep, skip, xfail, or assertion weakening in the final delta. One established cast in nutricoach_v150_concrete_host.py:766 is inherited outside the final postimage delta and all strict analyzers are clean." }, "tests": { "focused120": "120 passed in 18.77s", "maintenance_runtime240": "240 passed in 8.73s", "controller_safety_adversarial_closure_observer81": "81 passed in 17.56s" } }, "current_hashes": { "receipt_source_count": 21, "receipt_test_count": 8, "all_29_match_before_and_after": true, "mismatches": [], "additional_delta_files_detected": [], "receipt_sha256": "2ae4db9e39752777abd3f0df192878ffa4b0e03c540945563b080cdfbb679306" }, "immutable_and_effect_boundaries": { "fresh_r71b_candidate_preseal_preflight_authorization_execution_rehearsal_observer_roots_absent_before_and_after": true, "old_r71_preflight_tree_list_sha256": "d5b413e7b412a0040f5b1467035bc2b080220c3b74909edfe5f7245b656c3b3c", "old_r71_preseal_tree_list_sha256": "0b1e0fa2f1494cf83d28aa25d3412195950e143f724670c73f21013e8091689d", "old_r71_candidate_r3_tree_list_sha256": "4e941e2ddcfae789ab22ecdc9ab741c752578f53ece2c2644d5524ab17011c86", "old_r71_hashes_match_prior_receipt": true, "package_builds_or_seals": 0, "live_profile_service_cron_actions": 0, "network_provider_customer_actions": 0, "git_or_github_actions": 0 }, "repro": { "task10_matrix": "Validate fixed sources; use wrong-parent disposable source substitutions for empty/non-JSON/stale/right-basename cases; mutate canonical disposable candidate copies by symlink, hardlink, mode, supplementary-group ownership, and canonically recomputed embedded document. All substitutions reject without authoritative mutation.", "transaction": "Run tests/test_nutricoach_v150_r71b_disposable_lifecycle.py against TemporaryDirectory roots, plus call recover_pending on a terminal safe-paused disposable journal and compare service/protected bytes before and after.", "strict": "Run Ruff, ty, basedpyright, compile/import and per-file LSP over every path in v4 source_sha256 and test_sha256." }, "cleanup": { "review_source_or_test_edits": 0, "only_persistent_artifact_updated": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-10-r71b-controller-source-adversarial.json", "all_disposable_fixture_roots": "TemporaryDirectory-owned and removed", "review_owned_temporary_files_remaining": 0, "generated_bytecode_created": 0, "patch_backup_or_reject_files_in_worktree": 0 } }