{
  "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-10-sep2-zero-projection-recovery-v1",
  "task_id": "st_01a05d18",
  "generated_at_kst": "2026-09-01T22:16:46+09:00",
  "verdict": "RECOVERABLE",
  "confidence": 0.98,
  "scope": "Read-only adjudication except this required evidence file. No Git, source/live edit, service action, cron tick, observer run, launcher, network, provider, or customer action was performed.",
  "decision": {
    "summary": "The smaller original verified r71 candidate-r3/preseal path becomes safe immediately after the 2026-09-02 KST rollover, provided the mandatory just-in-time zero-projection gate still passes. Sep 2 is Wednesday, not the configured Monday weekly day; all requested ticks are before the 08:00 daily boundary, 20:00 reminder boundary, and 23:00 cutoff; and current canonical authority contains only Sep 1 lineage. The installed correlation predicate therefore returns MISSING for Sep 2 and creates no current-day sidecar row. With no current-day row, Topic59 publication is not claimed, historical sending slots are not examined for retry, the tick returns success with zero send/edit provider calls, and scheduler mark_job_run changes latest status to ok. After the separately fixed observer root selection is admitted by its checksum manifest, one observer-r70 oneshot can append PASS. The original sealed r71 artifacts still verify and its action roots and approval remain unused. The partial r71b package is neither needed nor allowed on this path.",
    "hard_condition": "Abort if any Sep 2 canonical event, Sep 2 weekly-operation sidecar row, Sep 2 Topic59 projection, newly due delivery, route/config/authority drift, or nonzero send/update oracle appears before the restart or launcher.",
    "preferred_window": "2026-09-02T00:01:00+09:00 through 2026-09-02T00:05:00+09:00",
    "fallback_window": "2026-09-02T02:00:00+09:00 through 2026-09-02T02:05:00+09:00, with the identical fresh gates; do not rely on the expired/partial r71b maintenance package."
  },
  "authoritative_sep2_zero_projection_proof": {
    "calendar": {
      "kst_day": "2026-09-02",
      "weekday": "Wednesday",
      "python_weekday": 2,
      "configured_weekly_weekday": 0,
      "configured_weekly_day": "Monday",
      "prior_day": "2026-09-01",
      "prior_day_weekday": "Tuesday"
    },
    "boundaries": {
      "daily_time": "08:00:00",
      "reminder_window": "[20:00:00,23:00:00)",
      "cutoff_time": "23:00:00",
      "requested_ticks_before_all_boundaries": true
    },
    "current_authority_shape_redacted": {
      "configured_authority_root": "data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159",
      "configured_root_selected_by_live_config": true,
      "enabled_schedule_count": 1,
      "enabled_schedule_inside_pilot_on_sep2": true,
      "canonical_event_count": 2,
      "canonical_event_days": [
        "2026-09-01",
        "2026-09-01"
      ],
      "sep2_canonical_event_count": 0,
      "sidecar_row_count": 1,
      "sidecar_days": [
        "2026-08-31"
      ],
      "sep2_sidecar_row_count": 0,
      "topic59_rows": 4,
      "topic59_logical_slots": 2,
      "topic59_latest_states": {
        "sending": 2
      },
      "sep2_topic59_slot_count": 0,
      "activation_completion_notice_ledger_present": false,
      "owner_draft_delivery_ledger_present": false
    },
    "business_rule_trace": [
      "build_due_customer_tasks rejects all customer tasks before daily_time; therefore daily, weekly, reminder, and cutoff task counts are zero at every requested early tick.",
      "Even though dispatch_weekly_operations_tick visits every weekly-authority customer, _project_checkin asks canonical lineage for exactly local_now.date().",
      "resolve_canonical_lineage cannot select Sep 1 events for Sep 2 because lineage root occurred_at_kst.date must equal the requested KST day.",
      "With no selected Sep 2 lineage and CHECKIN action before cutoff, project_canonical_checkin returns operation=None/outcome=MISSING. It is not a parser/preparer failure and appends no sidecar row.",
      "The dispatcher filters sidecar rows to kst_day == Sep 2; the empty result skips Topic59DayCard.from_sidecar and skips Topic59PublicationLedger.claim entirely.",
      "The Wednesday weekday guard returns before weekly owner-draft/model/provider work.",
      "The weekly policy is present, so the generic activation-completion notice branch is skipped; the reminder-driven owner review-card drain is also unreachable."
    ],
    "why_r71b_preparer_blocked_correctly": "r71b preparation required exactly one target Sep 2 Topic59 projection. Authoritative current data and the installed business predicates produce zero, so TARGET_TOPIC59_PROJECTION_ABSENT is a truthful requirement mismatch. The strict YAML parser had already parsed current profile fields successfully; candidate-r3 verification passed before preparation, and the blocker occurred only at the exact target projection cardinality check."
  },
  "tick_oracle": [
    {
      "scheduled_at": "2026-09-02T00:01:00+09:00",
      "topic59_projection_count": 0,
      "daily_due": 0,
      "reminder_due": 0,
      "cutoff_due": 0,
      "weekly_owner_due": 0,
      "activation_notice_due": 0,
      "owner_review_drain_due": 0,
      "due_send_count": 0,
      "due_update_count": 0,
      "uncertain_historical_slots": 2,
      "uncertain_retry_count": 0,
      "expected_cron_result": "ok/no-op",
      "provider_send_or_edit_calls": 0
    },
    {
      "scheduled_at": "2026-09-02T00:02:00+09:00",
      "topic59_projection_count": 0,
      "daily_due": 0,
      "reminder_due": 0,
      "cutoff_due": 0,
      "weekly_owner_due": 0,
      "activation_notice_due": 0,
      "owner_review_drain_due": 0,
      "due_send_count": 0,
      "due_update_count": 0,
      "uncertain_historical_slots": 2,
      "uncertain_retry_count": 0,
      "expected_cron_result": "ok/no-op",
      "provider_send_or_edit_calls": 0
    },
    {
      "scheduled_at": "2026-09-02T00:03:00+09:00",
      "topic59_projection_count": 0,
      "daily_due": 0,
      "reminder_due": 0,
      "cutoff_due": 0,
      "weekly_owner_due": 0,
      "activation_notice_due": 0,
      "owner_review_drain_due": 0,
      "due_send_count": 0,
      "due_update_count": 0,
      "uncertain_historical_slots": 2,
      "uncertain_retry_count": 0,
      "expected_cron_result": "ok/no-op",
      "provider_send_or_edit_calls": 0
    },
    {
      "scheduled_at": "2026-09-02T02:00:00+09:00",
      "topic59_projection_count": 0,
      "daily_due": 0,
      "reminder_due": 0,
      "cutoff_due": 0,
      "weekly_owner_due": 0,
      "activation_notice_due": 0,
      "owner_review_drain_due": 0,
      "due_send_count": 0,
      "due_update_count": 0,
      "uncertain_historical_slots": 2,
      "uncertain_retry_count": 0,
      "expected_cron_result": "ok/no-op",
      "provider_send_or_edit_calls": 0
    },
    {
      "scheduled_at": "2026-09-02T02:01:00+09:00",
      "topic59_projection_count": 0,
      "daily_due": 0,
      "reminder_due": 0,
      "cutoff_due": 0,
      "weekly_owner_due": 0,
      "activation_notice_due": 0,
      "owner_review_drain_due": 0,
      "due_send_count": 0,
      "due_update_count": 0,
      "uncertain_historical_slots": 2,
      "uncertain_retry_count": 0,
      "expected_cron_result": "ok/no-op",
      "provider_send_or_edit_calls": 0
    },
    {
      "scheduled_at": "2026-09-02T02:02:00+09:00",
      "topic59_projection_count": 0,
      "daily_due": 0,
      "reminder_due": 0,
      "cutoff_due": 0,
      "weekly_owner_due": 0,
      "activation_notice_due": 0,
      "owner_review_drain_due": 0,
      "due_send_count": 0,
      "due_update_count": 0,
      "uncertain_historical_slots": 2,
      "uncertain_retry_count": 0,
      "expected_cron_result": "ok/no-op",
      "provider_send_or_edit_calls": 0
    }
  ],
  "historical_no_replay_proof": {
    "topic59_ledger_sha256_at_analysis": "92ef87536865b4d74c50f9715601de7870c5c3893839f2862dbaf62024e51af5",
    "latest_sending_slot_count": 2,
    "message_id_present_count": 0,
    "rule": "Topic59PublicationLedger.claim filters only rows whose card_slot equals the current projection card_slot. Different customer/day slots are not retried. A same-slot nonterminal state returns incident, never retry; here no Sep 2 projection exists, so claim is not called at all.",
    "required_post_tick_state": "The four historical rows and their file SHA-256 remain byte-identical. Do not convert, reconcile, fail, audit, or synthesize receipts for them."
  },
  "fresh_r70_restart_trace": [
    "The single systemd restart replaces the stale long-lived process and creates a fresh coordinator/canonical file-pin set from the unchanged configured authority root.",
    "The recurring scheduler reads the persisted enabled one-minute job. A stale run older than grace is fast-forwarded; a due run inside grace is advanced before execution. Neither behavior replays a burst.",
    "At the first admitted Sep 2 minute, run_one_job invokes nutrition-coaching-tick under scheduled_transport authority.",
    "Planning returns no due tasks. Weekly dispatch still verifies current authority, but CHECKIN correlation returns MISSING and the Sep 2 sidecar row set remains empty.",
    "No Topic59 claim, scheduled-delivery reservation, send, edit, activation notice, owner model, or owner transport callback is reached. The two old sending slots remain untouched.",
    "The Telegram adapter returns SendResult(success=True); launch_scheduled_card returns sent=true as the scheduler's processed-success signal even though no customer message was transmitted.",
    "run_one_job calls mark_job_run(success=true), atomically writes cron/jobs.json with last_status=ok/last_error=null and writes the no-op job output."
  ],
  "observer_r70_recovery": {
    "root_selection_fix_present": true,
    "fixed_source_sha256": "96218c4405cb6ecac1711f20a7af1b38c422f4c716eafcf0e2dec8a122889689",
    "fixed_behavior": "_day_status_days parses weekly_operations_authority_path from the active profile and reads the configured candidate-suffixed authority root.",
    "current_checksum_gate": "BLOCKED_UNTIL_OPERATIONALLY_UPDATED",
    "stale_manifest_expected_source_sha256": "1beaf13e799a8330e5cfb1e9b44a77bb4cc214b5b5d5ee7fb34412e36dfe99a7",
    "required_minimum_operational_change": "Replace only the observer-runtime SHA-256 line in /home/cube/.config/systemd/user/nutricoach-v15-seven-day-observer.sha256 with the fixed source hash, after rechecking all four source hashes; do not edit observer source or authority data.",
    "oneshot_result": "With the configured root, the already-existing required day-status is present, so collect/evaluate appends exactly one hash-linked observer-r70 PASS row without customer input. The checksum manifest update is outside the original r71 protected profile inventory and does not collide with r71 or r71b authority roots."
  },
  "original_r71_artifact_state": {
    "candidate_root": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/task-v15r71-candidate-r3",
    "candidate_digest": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
    "candidate_manifest_sha256": "a019f0b9a0bf1a393d2d307d0e755251a140e3449058077632209e2101090766",
    "candidate_files": 362,
    "candidate_writable_files": 0,
    "candidate_symlinks": 0,
    "candidate_canonical_verifier_rerun": "NUTRICOACH_V150_CANDIDATE_PASS",
    "preseal_root": "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-runtime-authority-r71",
    "preseal_files": 595,
    "preseal_writable_files": 0,
    "preseal_symlinks": 0,
    "preseal_tree_sha256": "a76a0961829d8222814c1c88fac8e68f90ad7faf822e6d5ea3efb655545b7ee8",
    "preseal_canonical_verifier_rerun": "V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED",
    "permission_package_sha256": "21c8f3d3b2e95b37a1af2123fe196309a01eb6fb768bc38a15efa0973cfa666a",
    "protected_inventory_sha256": "d2c084be0865f8e9844452a7b683f97800e31af9bc7e1a113241109a283aada5",
    "rehearsal": "13/13 PASS, external_events=0, immutable",
    "approval_consumed": false,
    "authority_window": "2026-08-27T00:00:00+09:00 <= now < 2026-09-30T23:59:59+09:00",
    "authoritative_verifier_selection": "Use the immutable verifier copies under the original r71 preseal controller-source. The current worktree verifier now targets r71b and correctly failed against the incomplete r71b package; that is not an original-r71 artifact failure."
  },
  "protected_inventory_and_profile_drift": {
    "config_sha256_current_and_task9": "6a949de8c8a7c4caff4462f9c2821d49e5517a0f12defa93693e7f3bff97ed17",
    "registry_sha256_current": "176a7e3c55e5be95583c122dc535f13b35ef6fd13c1fbf9445f3cc2be95dd95e",
    "selected_protected_customer_hashes_match_task10_baseline": true,
    "scheduled_deliveries_sha256": "1000b155ccb56aa318ac098613f5808d2cb9633fc1178a0b49f280c3a23f72a1",
    "cron_jobs_class": "volatile",
    "cron_output_class": "volatile prefix",
    "scheduled_deliveries_class": "volatile",
    "topic59_inventory_membership": "absent from inherited stable and volatile snapshot rows; the safe tick must leave it unchanged",
    "capture_verify_assessment": "PASS-capable. Original r71 validates the immutable inventory file and fixed registry digest, then captures current bytes for inherited stable paths and verifies those same bytes through stop/switch. A truthful cron status update touches volatile cron/jobs.json/output only; the observer append is outside the profile; the checksum manifest is not the gateway unit/drop-in/credential contract. Re-run capture/verify immediately and abort on any protected drift."
  },
  "r71_action_roots": {
    "authorization": "ABSENT",
    "execution": "ABSENT",
    "successor_runtime": "ABSENT",
    "observer_r71": "ABSENT",
    "launcher_invocation_count": 0,
    "approval_unused": true
  },
  "r71b_tombstone_separation": {
    "input_r3": "PRESENT_IMMUTABLE_11_FILES",
    "candidate_r3": "PRESENT_IMMUTABLE_397_FILES",
    "partial_preseal": "PRESENT_PARTIAL_624_FILES_NO_PACKAGE_MANIFEST",
    "partial_preflight": "PRESENT_PARTIAL_1_FILE_NO_PERMISSION_PACKAGE",
    "authorization": "ABSENT",
    "execution": "ABSENT",
    "successor_runtime": "ABSENT",
    "observer_r71": "ABSENT",
    "collision_assessment": "No collision. r71b uses authority/preseal/preflight names ending r71b-maintenance and a different candidate digest; original r71 hard-codes the r71 preseal, r71 authority ID, r71 action roots, and a41c97c8 runtime. Preserve every r71b root byte/mode-identically as a tombstone. Never run the current worktree launcher, whose constants now select r71b; invoke only the immutable original r71 controller-source launcher."
  },
  "exact_event_driven_sequence": [
    {
      "order": 1,
      "time_kst": "2026-09-02T00:01:00+09:00 to 2026-09-02T00:01:15+09:00",
      "action": "Run the pure rollover gate against one read snapshot.",
      "required_checks": [
        "KST day is exactly 2026-09-02 and time is before 08:00.",
        "Config/registry/route/authority digests equal the recorded current values; weekly remains enabled and configured authority root is unchanged.",
        "Sep 2 canonical-event count=0, Sep 2 sidecar-row count=0, Sep 2 Topic59 projection/slot count=0.",
        "For 00:01, 00:02, and 00:03: due_send=0, due_update=0, daily/reminder/cutoff/weekly-owner/activation/owner-drain=0, uncertain_retry=0.",
        "Historical Topic59 ledger SHA-256 remains 92ef8753... and latest sending count remains two without reinterpretation.",
        "Original r71 action roots absent; original approval unused; original candidate/preseal verifiers PASS; r71b partial roots unchanged."
      ],
      "abort": "Any mismatch. Do not restart."
    },
    {
      "order": 2,
      "time_kst": "before the restart, no later than 2026-09-02T00:01:20+09:00",
      "action": "Subscribe before triggering: arm a bounded Linux inotify subscription for atomic replacement/close events in cron/jobs.json and cron/output/6e042d5dff68, and a systemd D-Bus or journal-follow subscription for the gateway ActiveState/MainPID transition. Use a 120-second timeout; do not sleep or poll. Record the pre-restart MainPID and the exact ledger hashes.",
      "abort": "Subscription setup failure or any unexpected file event before the trigger."
    },
    {
      "order": 3,
      "time_kst": "2026-09-02T00:01:20+09:00",
      "action": "Restart hermes-gateway-dualcoachtest.service exactly once through systemd. Do not pause/resume/trigger/run/tick the cron job and do not restart again.",
      "expected_event": "ActiveState returns active/running with a new MainPID and fresh canonical pins."
    },
    {
      "order": 4,
      "time_kst": "2026-09-02T00:02:00+09:00 scheduled tick, bounded completion by 00:03:00",
      "action": "Await the already-armed cron output/jobs events. Accept only the normal scheduled job completion whose last_run_at is Sep 2, last_status=ok, last_error=null, enabled=true, state=scheduled, and next_run_at is future.",
      "required_postconditions": [
        "Topic59 and scheduled-delivery ledger hashes unchanged.",
        "No Sep 2 sidecar or Topic59 row appeared.",
        "No activation notice or owner-delivery ledger appeared.",
        "Provider send count=0 and edit/update count=0 by the exact eligibility/call-path proof.",
        "Historical sending slots unchanged and no retry/reconciliation occurred."
      ],
      "abort": "Timeout, cron error, any provider-eligible state, any delivery-ledger mutation, or a second restart."
    },
    {
      "order": 5,
      "time_kst": "after cron ok and before 2026-09-02T00:10:00+09:00",
      "action": "Admit the already-tested observer fix only: re-hash all four observer files, update exactly the stale observer-runtime line in nutricoach-v15-seven-day-observer.sha256 from 1beaf13e... to 96218c44..., then require sha256sum --check to pass. Subscribe to observer-r70/observations.jsonl and systemd oneshot completion before starting nutricoach-v15-seven-day-observer.service exactly once.",
      "required_postconditions": [
        "Exactly one new hash-linked observer row.",
        "Latest observer status PASS with no failures and configured authority-root day set.",
        "No authority-row copy, synthetic day status, customer input, provider call, or timer restart."
      ],
      "abort": "Any source hash mismatch, more than one append, or non-PASS result."
    },
    {
      "order": 6,
      "time_kst": "immediately after observer PASS",
      "action": "From outside the worktree rerun the immutable original r71 controller-source candidate verifier and preseal verifier; require NUTRICOACH_V150_CANDIDATE_PASS and V15_RUNTIME_AUTHORITY_PRESEAL_VERIFIED. Run the established sealed capture/verify-only protected-inventory preflight and exact successor compatibility checks; require no protected drift and no action roots created.",
      "abort": "Do not substitute current worktree r71b scripts. Any failure stops before approval."
    },
    {
      "order": 7,
      "time_kst": "immediately after order 6 and still before 08:00 KST",
      "action": "Repeat the immediate production gate: cron latest ok from the Sep 2 no-op, observer-r70 latest PASS, service active/running, config/registry/protected hashes current, due_send/update=0, original r71 action roots absent, approval unused, and r71b tombstones unchanged. Subscribe to r71 authorization/execution/runtime/service phase events before launch.",
      "abort": "Any changed predicate, Sep 2 customer event/projection, or occupied original r71 action root."
    },
    {
      "order": 8,
      "time_kst": "one invocation only",
      "action": "Invoke /home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-runtime-authority-r71/controller-source/scripts/execute_nutricoach_v150_sealed_live.py once with the exact approval phrase emitted by the just-rerun original preseal verifier. The launcher uses bwrap --unshare-net and the sealed original r71 closure.",
      "required_postconditions": [
        "r71 authorization CONSUMED/SUCCEEDED exactly once.",
        "r71 execution COMMITTED.",
        "current runtime and authority select candidate a41c97c8..., with no r71b path selected.",
        "No customer delivery ledger change and zero send/edit provider calls through the early-window path.",
        "No replay invocation."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "no_replay_rules": [
    "Do not perform the restart before Sep 2 rollover or at/after 08:00 without a new oracle.",
    "Do not proceed if a Sep 2 canonical event or sidecar row appears; a customer action can invalidate the zero projection after this analysis.",
    "Do not run cron tick, cron run, trigger, pause/resume, or a second restart. Let one normal scheduled tick produce the truthful ok result.",
    "Do not touch either historical Topic59 sending slot and do not fabricate delivered/sent_audited/failed/unknown state or a provider receipt.",
    "Do not run the r71b preparer, partial preseal, verifier, controller, approval, or launcher; do not delete/reuse/repair/chmod its roots.",
    "Do not invoke candidate/preseal/launcher modules from the mutable current worktree; select immutable original r71 controller-source roots.",
    "Do not manually append/copy a day-status or observer row. Only the fixed configured-root collector may append the one observer result.",
    "Do not reuse the original r71 approval phrase or launcher after any invocation, regardless of success or failure."
  ],
  "evidence_basis": [
    "task-10-r71b-authoritative-package.json",
    "task-10-r71b-authority-verification.json",
    "task-10-r71b-candidate-r3-overlay-recovery.json",
    "task-10-r71b-profile-yaml-fix.json",
    "task-10-r71b-final-source-freeze.json",
    "task-10-r71b-package-source-freeze.json",
    "task-10-cron-no-send-recovery-analysis.json",
    "task-10-next-cron-no-send.json",
    "task-10-debug-cron.json",
    "task-10-debug-observer-r70.json",
    "task-10-r70-health-recovery.json",
    "task-8-r71-candidate.json",
    "task-8-r71-r3-preseal-verify.json",
    "task-8-r71-r3-source-freeze.json",
    "task-9-r71-preseal-rehearsal.json",
    "task-9-audit-closure.json",
    "task-9-audit-integrity.json",
    "task-9-audit-privacy.json",
    "task-10-r71-production.json",
    "installed r70 scheduler/dispatcher/correlation/ledger code and current redacted config/authority/task/ledger metadata"
  ],
  "verification_performed_read_only": {
    "original_candidate_verifier": "PASS",
    "original_preseal_verifier": "PASS",
    "observer_fixed_source_checksum_vs_current_manifest": "EXPECTED_MISMATCH_IDENTIFIED",
    "r71_action_roots_absent": true,
    "r71_approval_unused": true,
    "r71b_partial_roots_present_and_separate": true,
    "customer_values_in_deliverable": false
  },
  "forbidden_effects": {
    "git_or_github": 0,
    "source_edits": 0,
    "live_profile_or_systemd_edits": 0,
    "service_restarts": 0,
    "cron_job_or_tick_actions": 0,
    "observer_invocations_or_appends": 0,
    "launcher_invocations": 0,
    "network_provider_customer_actions": 0,
    "candidate_preseal_permission_tombstone_mutations": 0
  }
}