{
  "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-11-day-status-continuity-r1-adversarial-v1",
  "task_id": "st_01a05dec",
  "captured_at_kst": "2026-09-02T02:09:52+09:00",
  "status": "NEEDS_FIX_FAIL_CLOSED",
  "verdict": "needs-fix",
  "confidence": "high",
  "confidence_score": 0.99,
  "done_claim": false,
  "DoneClaim": false,
  "blocker_count": 4,
  "authoritative_seal_readiness": {
    "ready": false,
    "decision": "DO_NOT_PREPARE_OR_SEAL_AUTHORITATIVE_ROOTS",
    "approval_phrase_ready": false,
    "claimed_package_digest_authenticated": false,
    "claimed_package_digest": "ba544bcb57d7d273f8d7dbef0e3973403daddd58d841b2c013e6def6114b293d",
    "reason": "No canonical permission package.json exists from which the claimed digest or its complete pin set can be reconstructed, and the wheel lacks an executable production/recovery assembly. The helper wheel is reproducible but is not an authoritatively executable sealed package.",
    "exact_current_disposition": "Keep authorization, execution, preseal, permission, and rehearsal roots absent. Do not issue AUTHORIZE NUTRICOACH DAY STATUS CONTINUITY <digest> for this artifact."
  },
  "blockers": [
    {
      "code": "MISSING_EXECUTABLE_SEALED_CLOSURE",
      "summary": "The wheel provides contracts, pure helpers, and Protocol seams but no CLI/__main__, production ObserverControl, RowExecutor, ReceiptWriter, timer-fence adapter, package loader, or recovery-only entry point.",
      "proof": {
        "modules": ["contract", "controller", "executor", "fdio", "installed", "journal", "observer", "preparation", "recovery", "sealer", "store", "verifier"],
        "cli_or_main_present": false,
        "observer_effect_implementation": "Protocol only",
        "receipt_writer_implementation": "Protocol only",
        "row_executor_controller_implementation": "Protocol only",
        "recovery_executor_present": false,
        "canonical_permission_package_present": false
      },
      "impact": "There is no sealed command that can consume approval, instantiate installed current-root stores, fence/capture the moving observer under the timer fence, publish intent/provenance, or perform approved recovery. Fake ports cannot establish live seal readiness."
    },
    {
      "code": "CRASH_RECOVERY_QUALIFICATION_OVERCLAIMED",
      "summary": "The advertised 52 crash points are byte offsets 1..52 of a 792-byte frame, not transaction-phase crash points. No crash is injected, no journal is reloaded, no pending reservation is authenticated, and no recovery path consumes failure or resumes execution.",
      "proof": {
        "collected_parameter_ids": [1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52],
        "frame_bytes": 792,
        "tested_prefix_fraction": "52/791 strict nonempty prefixes",
        "independent_all_prefix_classification": "791/791 pure classifications passed",
        "actual_phase_crash_executions": 0,
        "recovery_entry_point": null,
        "journal_rehydration": null,
        "second_recovery_guard": null,
        "divergent_consumption_integration": null,
        "inode_drift_recovery_test": null
      },
      "impact": "Prefix classification is correct as a pure function, including complete roll-forward and divergent/extra rejection, but the required one-use crash/restart behavior, no rollback after row bytes, consumed failure, and second recovery guards are unproved and unimplemented."
    },
    {
      "code": "FILESYSTEM_SECURITY_BINDINGS_NOT_ENFORCED",
      "summary": "Several exact fd/path/mode/uid/gid/nlink contracts claimed by the evidence are absent at mutation boundaries.",
      "proof": {
        "root_pins_ignored": "ExactInputVerifier verifies listed file pins only and never reads contract.source_root or contract.target_root.",
        "root_drift_probe": "A contract carrying deliberately wrong source and target inode pins was accepted by ExactInputVerifier.",
        "control_root_probe": "publish_atomic accepted a mode-0755 control directory and published a receipt.",
        "prefix_probe": "complete_prefix accepted a mode-0644 target and trusted caller-supplied current bytes without reading the descriptor; with an empty descriptor and current=b'a', it wrote b'bc'.",
        "missing_prefix_checks": ["uid", "gid", "mode", "bound inode", "named/open identity", "descriptor bytes equal current"],
        "absolute_parent_binding": "verify_file_pin opens an absolute path with O_NOFOLLOW only on the leaf and does not descriptor-walk/pin parent components.",
        "implemented_positive_controls": ["O_NOFOLLOW on leaf/root walk where used", "regular-file checks in selected paths", "nlink checks in selected paths", "short-write loop", "EINTR write/fsync retry", "file fsync", "directory fsync", "0400 receipt readback"]
      },
      "impact": "The package cannot truthfully claim exact authority/control-root identity, safe strict-prefix completion, or complete no-follow permission enforcement."
    },
    {
      "code": "QUALIFICATION_AND_PROVENANCE_EVIDENCE_NOT_REPRODUCIBLE_AS_CLAIMED",
      "summary": "The evidence reports an installed fake-root append/provenance/manual/natural integration and current installed RECORD bindings that are not represented by the tests or a retained package contract.",
      "proof": {
        "tests_only_use": "FakeStore plus FakeVerifier/FakeExecutor/FakeReceipts/FakeObserver; InstalledStoreAdapter and a real WeeklyOperationsStore authority are not exercised by the 66 tests.",
        "provenance_persistence_test": false,
        "permission_or_tamper_receipt_integration_test": false,
        "foreign_root_integration_test": false,
        "network_send_update_manual_cron_oracle_harness": false,
        "current_live_installed_record_sha256": {
          "hermes_agent": "d363039d3c970923a9228cf9b3c84bbff5708a65651624c2defabea1e916f6d9",
          "physique_checkin_cli": "ddc5f34d1b9646f4715f6af9bc6ebe88caa6a2568e56702801485b7b3ece1319"
        },
        "evidence_reported_record_sha256": {
          "hermes_agent": "225516500a1ab18aabca6af8b05181db7dc82ebf3324b5b91ce132bde2d02977",
          "physique_checkin_cli": "8b823301c800c28959f8ed7d3d46ae6a66dcaf7128991823913a910030fb9b83"
        },
        "retained_package_json_to_adjudicate_difference": false
      },
      "impact": "The current installed identities and claimed integration effects cannot be authenticated into the claimed ba544b... package digest."
    }
  ],
  "confirmed_primitives": {
    "source_architecture": {
      "result": "PASS_WITHIN_HELPER_SCOPE",
      "source_modules": 13,
      "maximum_physical_lines": 193,
      "all_modules_le_250": true,
      "single_responsibility_review": "The helper modules are narrowly separated by contract, fd I/O, store seam, execution, journal, observation, recovery classification, preparation, sealing, and verification.",
      "strict_escape_audit": "AST found no Any or cast usage; rg found no type-ignore/noqa escape in source."
    },
    "strict_checks": {
      "ruff_check": "PASS",
      "ruff_format_check": "PASS: 18 files already formatted",
      "basedpyright": "PASS: 0 errors, 0 warnings, 0 notes",
      "ty": "PASS with explicit installed checkin_cli extra search path",
      "compileall": "PASS",
      "lsp_source": "13 files, 0 diagnostics",
      "lsp_tests": "5 files, 0 diagnostics"
    },
    "tests": {
      "source": "66 passed in 0.13s",
      "installed_wheel": "66 passed in 0.13s with package import resolved from isolated target site",
      "nondeterministic_sleeps_or_polling": 0
    },
    "wheel": {
      "path": "nutricoach-v150-day-status-continuity-r71-r1/dist/nutricoach_v150_day_status_continuity_r71_r1-1.0.0-py3-none-any.whl",
      "sha256": "f1a32507f2d343229d50ee45fa5da84fb24b076445b6517fb84f9ea6e86383be",
      "size": 16559,
      "internal_record_sha256": "28d1245b822f90487b1e2b4d79c1a29b90ff4b6bbd020c5f04481f18bb35629f",
      "installed_target_record_sha256": "4aa1c2b4a248e8991fb7387171c561f4f45d5a53d6cd42d75631a3e60bebb395",
      "record_all_rows_verified": true,
      "wheel_members_equal_source": true,
      "rebuild_generator": "setuptools 84.0.0 with SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH=1704067200",
      "different_named_roots": ["/tmp/nutricoach-rebuild-alpha.<random>", "/tmp/nutricoach-rebuild-omega.<random>"],
      "both_rebuild_sha256": "f1a32507f2d343229d50ee45fa5da84fb24b076445b6517fb84f9ea6e86383be",
      "byte_identical_to_retained_wheel": true
    },
    "source_manifest": {
      "sha256": "1f52daef5f479e6ab4a86ad3a50781fde07ef8c943fbeeeb43e3c4460ab4dcf0",
      "entries": 14,
      "every_entry_size_and_sha256_verified": true,
      "declared_hash_stream_sha256": "e1c79cacbf56f1f241078b6099640b493856e01cdc715fa86f4f232bfc0e246a"
    },
    "typed_row_reconstruction": {
      "runtime": "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/.strict-runtime/a41c97c8-v150/venv/bin/python",
      "method": "validate_history_bytes plus installed WeeklyOperationInput/WeeklyOperationRow/canonical_weekly_row/weekly_row_digest",
      "bytes": 792,
      "frame_sha256": "7a8d7d6ecc66c863bc27793df6a5f3efd1ba0661cf3568095b6b9bcf4cb45208",
      "row_digest": "405b519c7f0ae51d413d26e4ca5bb1fd69786c3eb11a5dbe1f00e2701bd90d26",
      "exact_source_bytes_equal": true,
      "sequence_zero_digest": "dd9cdc73c717380a6aa3e1d35edfcafc8ba949eaf7203029b159422330257cdf"
    },
    "moving_observer_admissibility": {
      "design_is_safe": "A moving failed-chain head must not be a static package pin; capturing it only after reservation while the timer is fenced is the correct admissibility model, so natural pre-execution FAIL appends need not invalidate a static package.",
      "source_controller_order": "reserve -> fence_timer_and_capture_failed_head -> second static verifier -> append intent",
      "implemented_production_capture": false,
      "current_read_only_snapshot": {
        "rows_file_size": 3130,
        "sha256": "2e76e47950e02913971e2b580811f26caac67df25bf5bfaf37fcee732303936f",
        "head": "c3d56b1bc6cb99f68690f3d0104a5a1bc866d53cd5b50728e20381d2845cb74f",
        "head_status": "FAIL",
        "head_failures": ["first_day_status"]
      }
    }
  },
  "live_read_only_binding": {
    "candidate_digest": "a41c97c8a467b0308b9f50ac072cc3adae1c2d47ca515b76f123e7c1debee9be",
    "config_sha256": "9e3bf9fb0233e1c317b968eab6f51f5bc73f729d5a09a6b4011829eb7352f86b",
    "r71_authorization_consumed_sha256": "fc242dec4cab503922222377b047503529528c8aa666e38e0c34aaa77e297e19",
    "r71_phase_sha256": "4e5ff24c555205b9bfe7417cc02f70c375254065c70d6073a4025faf53b8ec9d",
    "r71_production_evidence_sha256": "a34a44aca67772f894cfac6f081f28c5a1f5e8ef43974216702dc434c12f84eb",
    "observer_static_sha256": {
      "contract": "9cc44ea117490aa8cbd7eb8c3ff02b0dcff40dbaf9893d7de5ed80dad579bea5",
      "runtime": "fa9c29f271e0d0bcc3f51d76721b3370af25c456104db3da1c0d6c8fef734f2e",
      "final": "7f818e0b643155fc3705adba6dc2f2785f92d216f52e56b18276b0cec81b9475",
      "service": "acdac5b18ab36a8e4a02c07f54694b82671e69c071a5e8338822d61fb9c9b97a",
      "timer": "098fb18c1302d5e48df8b708954b8c4d5ed7b53425f19c371a44bb7f9eec8e0e",
      "checksum": "67b311f3bd139733f74f0669bea3656a7e4db43474d14848f6aa644941f3479b"
    },
    "gateway": {
      "unit": "hermes-gateway-dualcoachtest.service",
      "active_state": "active",
      "sub_state": "running",
      "main_pid": 3376522,
      "nrestarts": 0,
      "unchanged_during_verification": true
    },
    "timer": {
      "active_state": "active",
      "sub_state": "waiting",
      "unit_file_state": "enabled",
      "manual_actions": 0
    }
  },
  "authority_inventory": {
    "r70": {
      "root": "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/data/weekly-operations-authority-81a7a06ec2e7a159",
      "device": 66306,
      "inode": 45242251,
      "mode": "0700",
      "uid": 1000,
      "gid": 1000,
      "nlink": 2,
      "children": 4,
      "marker_sha256": "39d786bef523af384252b1be17ae929b26435b70b759746eb3704072a9f11a8f",
      "registry_sha256": "542555cf4068012028711441ed220e6c80ab182462bbfd6eff95856bb0ba472f",
      "data_inode": 45242255,
      "data_size": 792,
      "data_sha256": "7a8d7d6ecc66c863bc27793df6a5f3efd1ba0661cf3568095b6b9bcf4cb45208",
      "lock_inode": 45242254,
      "all_children_regular_mode_0600_uid_gid_nlink1": true
    },
    "r71": {
      "root": "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/data/weekly-operations-authority-a41c97c8a467b030",
      "device": 66306,
      "inode": 45242337,
      "mode": "0700",
      "uid": 1000,
      "gid": 1000,
      "nlink": 2,
      "children": 4,
      "marker_sha256": "dd5981f94300d1fa9269fac018c8c309badee2dd4096daab82237630d105c57f",
      "registry_sha256": "b7a5dde559c7de527a69a41037e95d2337579370bf22668b064a7295e7b19e20",
      "data_inode": 45242341,
      "data_size": 0,
      "data_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
      "lock_inode": 45242340,
      "all_children_regular_mode_0600_uid_gid_nlink1": true
    },
    "r70_r71_registration_and_sequence_pin_binding": "Confirmed by exact marker/registry hashes, sole typed source history, empty current target, and exact sequence-zero digest."
  },
  "protected_post_verification": {
    "customer_events": "4a718b95dc35f7219be2f0c5c1b7ce1d67690489086b117fb82c898564010155",
    "telegram_bindings": "318d62644dc480dbe2be54b402f19eb0af41dc35928206d19357a9d6f9053713",
    "draft_235d": "69f6510e555b47984c6462b12da569b5bb67c051b1592ddb2ffb93898564b9c1",
    "draft_dc99": "d717125902230dc362c3e951ef0d6f656d0919dd0665f449f7056158b031dfab",
    "scheduled_deliveries": "1000b155ccb56aa318ac098613f5808d2cb9633fc1178a0b49f280c3a23f72a1",
    "scheduled_fence": "e647bdcdd1505e3d978c73d69934c9f04c20159bad4e12ac9d0c93b202442555",
    "topic59": "92ef87536865b4d74c50f9715601de7870c5c3893839f2862dbaf62024e51af5",
    "matches_authoritative_prior_anchors": true
  },
  "exact_next_authoritative_preparation_inputs": {
    "gate": "ONLY AFTER ALL FOUR BLOCKERS ARE FIXED AND THE REBUILT WHEEL IS REQUALIFIED",
    "required_source_closure": [
      "production CLI/package loader",
      "descriptor-bound r70/r71 InstalledStore construction",
      "production ReceiptWriter",
      "production observer timer fence/manual/subscription/restore adapter",
      "recovery-only launcher that authenticates the existing reservation and reloads the phase journal",
      "complete-prefix implementation that reads/rebinds the descriptor and enforces exact inode/uid/gid/mode/nlink"
    ],
    "required_canonical_package_json_pins": [
      "new wheel sha256 and internal RECORD plus every wheel member",
      "current installed interpreter identity and current hermes_agent/physique_checkin_cli RECORD files plus validation of every RECORD member",
      "r70/r71 root device/inode/uid/gid/mode/nlink and exact complete four-child inventories",
      "r70 marker/registry/data/lock identities and exact 792-byte row",
      "r71 marker/registry/empty data/lock identities and sequence-zero canonical registration",
      "config, original r71 CONSUMED/SUCCEEDED receipt, COMMITTED phase, and production evidence hashes",
      "current observer source/unit/timer/checksum static identities",
      "admissibility rule for a dynamic FAIL observer-r71 head captured only after reservation under timer fence",
      "customer events/bindings/drafts, scheduled ledgers/fence, Topic59, gateway PID/NRestarts, and zero send/edit/update/model/network/manual-cron oracle"
    ],
    "required_qualification": [
      "66 unit tests plus installed-wheel tests",
      "actual named crash injection before/after every durable phase boundary and every write/fsync/rename/readback boundary",
      "all 791 strict nonempty row prefixes or a justified exhaustive syscall fault matrix, complete-frame roll-forward, divergent/extra/inode drift consumed failure",
      "normal second-launch rejection and recovery-only second-use/replay guards",
      "two differently named disposable roots reproducing the new wheel and canonical package digest",
      "real installed WeeklyOperationsStore fake-authority append with external provenance receipt",
      "fresh observer manual PASS followed by subscribe-before-timer natural linked PASS",
      "permission/symlink/hardlink/foreign-root/tamper/EINTR/fsync matrix",
      "AF_INET/AF_INET6/send/edit/update/model/manual-cron counters all zero",
      "cleanup proof and independent postcondition verifier"
    ],
    "fresh_absence_recheck_paths": [
      "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-authorization-v15/nutricoach-v150-day-status-continuity-r71-r1",
      "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-executions-v15/nutricoach-v150-day-status-continuity-r71-r1",
      "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v15-day-status-continuity-r71-r1",
      "/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/preflight-v15-day-status-continuity-r71-r1",
      "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/task-v15r71-day-status-continuity-r1-rehearsal"
    ],
    "digest_and_phrase_rule": "After the final canonical package.json is retained and independently rehashed, compute SHA-256 over canonical JSON excluding only package_digest, insert that digest, verify model round-trip, and only then prepare the exact phrase AUTHORIZE NUTRICOACH DAY STATUS CONTINUITY <verified_new_digest>. The current ba544b... value is not an acceptable input."
  },
  "scope_and_cleanup": {
    "source_edits": 0,
    "live_profile_authority_service_timer_observer_edits": 0,
    "git_actions": 0,
    "network_customer_provider_actions": 0,
    "send": 0,
    "edit": 0,
    "update": 0,
    "manual_cron": 0,
    "manual_timer": 0,
    "disposable_roots_removed": true,
    "source_test_typecheck_caches_removed": true,
    "authoritative_continuity_roots_absent": true,
    "only_persistent_write": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-11-day-status-continuity-r1-adversarial.json"
  }
}