{ "schema": "AdversarialVerify-v1", "task_id": "st_01a058bd", "todo": 2, "verdict": "confirmed", "confidence": { "score": 0.995, "basis": "Fresh source inspection, matching receipt hashes, one-run focused and related suites, strict diagnostics, and an independent manual driver all agree. Both frozen blockers are closed, the parent-fsync evidence now states the observed post-replace ambiguity accurately, and no regression was found in the verified scope." }, "evidence": { "reviewed": [ "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/plans/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper.md (Todo 2)", "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-2-adversarial-verify.json", "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-2-binding-projection.json", "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_bindings.py", "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/tests/gateway/test_physique_checkin_projection.py", "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin.py (related binding selection)" ], "hash_match": { "result": "PASS", "receipt_sha256": "682d4e773d194e6ada02ce3aebd441966bca50933df7b6ea8860734b06429b50", "files": { "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_bindings.py": { "receipt_sha256": "d52f05764fc4a1de405c3cadd967241e0bbf42875fdbb2ff10137eef81797cd7", "observed_sha256_before_and_after_verification": "d52f05764fc4a1de405c3cadd967241e0bbf42875fdbb2ff10137eef81797cd7", "match": true }, "tests/gateway/test_physique_checkin_projection.py": { "receipt_sha256": "1bc389695fd605d7d1d1af8f8243aa41db8321e7f2a6b4944a69b6a8f636706f", "observed_sha256_before_and_after_verification": "1bc389695fd605d7d1d1af8f8243aa41db8321e7f2a6b4944a69b6a8f636706f", "match": true } } }, "blocker_ledger": { "T2-NOFOLLOW-001": { "result": "CONFIRMED_CLOSED", "source_observation": "_open_private_parent_directory opens each absolute or relative parent component from the preceding descriptor with O_DIRECTORY|O_NOFOLLOW|O_CLOEXEC. Missing components are mkdirat-created and reopened through the same no-follow path.", "independent_manual_repro": { "load": "BindingStoreError before external target mutation", "save": "BindingStoreError before external target mutation", "target_entries_after_each_attempt": 0 }, "test_observation": "The load/save parameterized blocker test passed in the blocker-only selection." }, "T2-PRIVACY-002": { "result": "CONFIRMED_CLOSED", "source_observation": "Telegram IDs and receipt ID are bounded integers, chat ID is a bounded nonzero signed integer, session IDs are exactly 32 lowercase hexadecimal characters, cursor steps use a finite allowlist, cursor versions are bounded integers, and ingress kind remains a concrete enum.", "independent_manual_repro": { "identity_fields_checked": 13, "fields": [ "ingress.update_id", "ingress.kind", "ingress.message_id", "ingress.actor_id", "ingress.chat_id", "ingress.topic_id", "source_cursor.session_id", "source_cursor.step", "source_cursor.version", "target_cursor.session_id", "target_cursor.step", "target_cursor.version", "receipt_message_id" ], "tokens_per_field": 2, "tokens": [ "SENTINEL_RAW_ANSWER", "pc1:aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa:calories:1:a0" ], "constructor_rejections": 26, "serialized_decode_rejections": 26, "accepted": 0, "persisted_customer_content": false } } }, "evidence_correction": { "result": "CONFIRMED", "source_and_test_binding": "The updated receipt includes source and focused-test SHA-256 values and both match the reviewed bytes.", "parent_fsync_claim": "Accurate. Independent injection raised BindingStoreError after replace, left new state bytes visible in the live process, and left no temporary file. The receipt correctly does not claim rollback or preservation of prior bytes and calls post-error/crash durability ambiguous.", "prior_overstatement_removed": true }, "regression_checks": { "v1_compatibility": "PASS: independent manual load preserved valid v1 bytes exactly; the following real save wrote v2 while preserving the legacy binding.", "projection_contract": "PASS: focused suite covers typed identities/phases, all legal transitions, duplicates/conflicts, nonterminal uniqueness, chaining, expiry, malformed/truncated state, private modes, no-follow files, and interruption boundaries.", "related_gateway_binding_selection": "PASS: 4 passed, 87 deselected.", "no_customer_data": "PASS: the independent persisted v2 projection contained canonical synthetic metadata only and none of the sentinel, callback-shaped token, answer/raw-text markers, or customer-value-hash marker.", "network_or_customer_messages": "PASS: persistence source imports no transport/network module; verification made no network call and sent no customer message.", "timing_determinism": "PASS: the focused test contains no sleep, polling delay, or wait-for-time pattern.", "temporary_cleanup": "PASS: symlink repro targets remained empty; parent-fsync injection left no .tmp file; TemporaryDirectory roots and /tmp/task2-adversarial-r2.py were removed; py_compile outputs created by this verifier were removed.", "product_or_test_edits_by_verifier": "none" }, "commands": [ { "name": "focused_projection_suite", "command": "env PYTHONPATH=':' uv run --directory '' pytest -q tests/gateway/test_physique_checkin_projection.py", "result": "53 passed in 0.79s", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "blocker_and_parent_fsync_selection", "command": "env PYTHONPATH=':' uv run --directory '' pytest -q tests/gateway/test_physique_checkin_projection.py -k 'intermediate_directory_symlink or v2_identity_fields_reject_content or parent_fsync_failure'", "result": "29 passed, 24 deselected in 0.25s", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "related_binding_selection", "command": "env PYTHONPATH=':' uv run --extra dev --directory '' pytest -q tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin.py -k 'binding or projection or migration'", "result": "4 passed, 87 deselected in 0.50s", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "ruff", "result": "All checks passed!", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "ty", "result": "All checks passed!", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "basedpyright", "result": "0 errors, 0 warnings, 0 notes", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "py_compile", "result": "PASS", "exit": 0 }, { "name": "lsp_diagnostics", "result": "No diagnostics found for source and focused test" } ], "manual_qa": { "driver": "/tmp/task2-adversarial-r2.py (deleted and absence confirmed)", "result": { "status": "PASS", "identity_fields": 13, "tokens_per_field": 2, "constructor_rejections": 26, "decode_rejections": 26, "symlink": { "load": "rejected_before_target_mutation", "save": "rejected_before_target_mutation" }, "v1": "lazy_read_byte_preserved_then_v2_mutation_compatible", "content": "canonical_metadata_only_no_customer_content", "parent_fsync": "error_surfaced_new_bytes_visible_durability_ambiguous_no_temp" } } }, "blocking_findings": [], "scope_note": "Verdict is limited to the frozen Todo 2 blocker ledger, the corrected receipt claims, and regressions exercised by the focused and related binding checks. No product or test file was changed." }