{ "schema": "AdversarialVerify/v1", "task_id": "st_01a058cc", "todo": 3, "title": "Render the two-control confirmation-plus-next-question card", "verdict": "needs-fix", "confidence": "high", "scope": { "frozen_blockers": [ "actual u callback domain transition", "all-unknown summary 12/12", "nutrition_daily l rejection while other flows preserve l", "machine-selected receipt variants and value-free confirmation", "exact 이전 답 수정 label", "relevant customer nutrition and gateway regressions", "changed-file hash binding" ], "implementation_root": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "evidence_root": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper", "product_or_test_edits": false, "commit": false, "real_telegram_send": false, "customer_messages": false }, "hash_binding": { "implementation_receipt": { "path": "task-3-card-renderer.json", "sha256": "eeaa7b1098713bce5c42f0bed8d0780637880586e7e374834d74222928536453" }, "changed_files": { "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py": { "declared_sha256": "1880634e0a5c5e04d359f79d943f86f96e1f004be7ddde1c2cdad57f9fa87326", "observed_sha256": "1880634e0a5c5e04d359f79d943f86f96e1f004be7ddde1c2cdad57f9fa87326", "match": true }, "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py": { "declared_sha256": "cd2679283d2cc8a7b3765e6e8ec6d207bb06694cb500c15882c71fa0c9bc9495", "observed_sha256": "cd2679283d2cc8a7b3765e6e8ec6d207bb06694cb500c15882c71fa0c9bc9495", "match": true } }, "freshness": { "latest_changed_source_epoch": 1788195964, "manual_capture_epoch": 1788196626, "final_visual_capture_epoch": 1788197291, "source_unchanged_after_capture": true } }, "test_execution": { "isolation": "Each pytest command ran in bwrap with --unshare-net, a read-only source root, tmpfs /tmp, and PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1.", "command_template": "cd /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined && env PYTHONPATH=$PWD/dualcoach/profile:$PWD .venv/bin/python -m pytest -q -p no:cacheprovider ", "dedicated_card": { "target": "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py", "exit_code": 0, "result": "5 passed in 0.58s" }, "customer_nutrition": { "target": "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_ux.py", "exit_code": 0, "result": "28 passed in 1.01s" }, "gateway_bridge": { "target": "tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin.py", "exit_code": 0, "result": "91 passed in 1.83s" }, "customer_gateway_regression": { "target": "tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py", "exit_code": 1, "result": "34 passed, 41 failed in 8.70s", "first_failure_class": "BindingStore.save rejects a nutrition launcher binding before any customer callback because open_launcher supplies message_id='' while WizardBinding.from_dict requires a nonempty message_id.", "repro": "env PYTHONPATH=$PWD/dualcoach/profile:$PWD .venv/bin/python -m pytest -q -p no:cacheprovider tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py", "locations": [ "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:215-219", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_bindings.py:324,334,400", "gateway/platforms/nutrition_coaching.py:3838" ] }, "static": { "ruff": "PASS: .venv/bin/ruff check gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py", "basedpyright_test": "PASS: uv run --offline basedpyright tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py (0 errors, 0 warnings, 0 notes)", "compile": "PASS: python -m py_compile gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py", "lsp_test": "PASS: no diagnostics", "lsp_product": "Existing basedpyright diagnostics remain in physique_checkin.py; they were not suppressed or altered by this verifier." } }, "manual_real_wizard_service": { "evidence": { "transcript": { "path": "task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-transcript.txt", "sha256": "c8e82316ffcb0cb523cbb95c4cf53167dabe4160a6b676244e9e591acdb7f596" }, "machine_result": { "path": "task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-manual.json", "sha256": "20a1650b61046f6d9c75a02f4188a42e0aad4bb037ffd9fd194033b91adc52f6" } }, "execution": "A disposable standalone WizardService and PhysiqueCheckinBridge were run in a bwrap network namespace; no Telegram transport was constructed. The synthetic submitted value is absent from rendered text and callback data; only its SHA-256 is retained in the machine result.", "confirmed": { "actual_u_callback": "PASS: the rendered u callback was invoked; it advanced exactly once from bodyweight to calories and persisted unknown_steps=['bodyweight'].", "all_unknown_summary": "PASS: eleven actual u callbacks plus optional-note skip rendered 확인 12/12 with actions [a0, a1, a2].", "nutrition_l": "PASS: a structurally valid current nutrition_daily l callback was rejected and did not change the wizard version.", "other_flow_l": "PASS: an equivalent current morning l callback was accepted, deferred, and advanced once.", "history_label": "PASS: later question action row is [p, u] and the p label is exactly 이전 답 수정.", "daily_action_rows": "PASS: all captured nutrition_daily card rows omit l; optional_note is [a0, a1, p].", "privacy": "PASS: all captured cards are value-free; no submitted value appeared in prompt text or callback data.", "precommit_claims": "PASS: launch, resume, invalid, and stale states display no confirmation receipt." }, "failed": { "visible_postcommit_confirmation": { "actual": "Known, unknown, edited, and previous accepted cards start with a progress line and their next question; they contain neither a confirmation header nor a nonempty confirmation notice.", "expected": "Every committed answer must render a value-free confirmation header before the next question; no such header may appear before a commit.", "locations": [ "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:697-702", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:778-784" ] }, "machine_variant_distinctness": { "actual": { "known": "selected", "unknown": "unknown", "edited": "edited", "previous": "selected", "launch": "launch", "resume": "resume", "invalid": "invalid", "stale": "stale", "terminal": "terminal" }, "expected": "The listed states use distinct machine-selected receipt variants.", "failure": "known and previous both resolve to selected.", "location": "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:697-702" } }, "repro": [ "Start a standalone nutrition_daily session, invoke the rendered u callback, then invoke the rendered p callback. Both the subsequent known-input reply and previous reply have receipt_variant='selected'; neither card has a visible value-free confirmation header.", "Run tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py with the command above. The registered customer launcher fails before callback binding because its initial empty message_id is rejected by BindingStore.save." ] }, "visual_qa": { "surface": "Closest zero-network Korean Telegram-shaped terminal transcript from the fresh disposable WizardService flow; not a real Telegram send.", "transcript": { "path": "task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-web-terminal/terminal.txt", "sha256": "c8e82316ffcb0cb523cbb95c4cf53167dabe4160a6b676244e9e591acdb7f596" }, "metadata": { "path": "task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-web-terminal/metadata.json", "sha256": "14c859aa5ff7c008a1435d3c5222b03840c0df63074e91c00bee15ff167f670c", "connector": "file-replay", "cleanup": "cleanup: file replay; no live process" }, "tui_check": { "path": "task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-web-terminal/tui-check.json", "sha256": "16ad5c808442197db5635299e7897c43764976bec1ce90b3f2b4f82853c9c7e2", "expected_columns": 80, "max_width": 73, "overflow_lines": [], "border_misaligned": false, "has_ansi": false, "result": "PASS for text-grid Korean width and wrapping." }, "evidence_gap": "The standard helper recorded browserCapture=skipped because this host's Chrome has no usable sandbox. A local Chrome fallback was not retained after it attempted background GCM registration; therefore there is no final PNG claim. This is an evidence limitation, not a product visual pass." }, "findings": [ { "classification": "product", "severity": "blocker", "problem": "Committed known and previous transitions share selected and render only progress plus the next question. They do not provide the required distinct machine-selected receipt or visible value-free confirmation header.", "locations": [ "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:697-702", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:778-784" ], "fix": "Select a distinct receipt variant for known and previous transitions and pass that selected receipt into card rendering so accepted domain commits prepend a value-free confirmation header; keep launch/resume/invalid/stale confirmation-free. Add behavioral assertions for unique variants and rendered receipt presence." }, { "classification": "product", "severity": "blocker", "problem": "Relevant registered customer nutrition/gateway regression suite is non-green: 41 tests cannot open a launcher before callback message binding.", "locations": [ "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:215-219", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_bindings.py:324,334,400" ], "fix": "Make the initial unbound launcher state acceptable to the binding persistence schema, or postpone persistence until a real message id is bound, without weakening post-bind validation. Re-run the full customer nutrition gateway suite." }, { "classification": "evidence", "severity": "major", "problem": "The text-grid visual capture is fresh and passes width checks, but the required browser PNG was not retained because the host Chrome sandbox is unusable and the fallback made an external background registration attempt.", "location": "task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-web-terminal/metadata.json", "fix": "Use an already-isolated browser/xterm environment that cannot make background requests, recapture terminal.png from the current transcript, verify its PNG signature/compositing/dimensions, and rerun tui-check." } ], "cleanup": { "result": "PASS", "removed": [ "/tmp/task-3-adversarial-verify-r2-driver.py", "/tmp/task-3-chrome-local-only.sh", "/tmp/task-3-chrome-networkless.sh", "/tmp/task-3-chrome-direct-profile", "/tmp/task-3-chrome-local-profile", "/tmp/task-3-chrome-sandbox" ], "temporary_assets_remaining": 0, "owned_capture_processes_remaining": 0 }, "completion_gate": "Not satisfied. File hashes match and the u/all-unknown/l/label/privacy controls are confirmed, but receipt rendering and variant distinctness fail, the registered customer regression suite is red, and the final browser visual capture is absent." }