{ "schema": "AdversarialVerify/v1", "task": "Todo 3 - Render the two-control confirmation-plus-next-question card", "verdict": "needs-fix", "confidence": "high", "scope": { "plan": "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/plans/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper.md", "implementation_root": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "reviewed_files": [ "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py", "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_prompts.py", "/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-card-renderer.json" ], "product_or_test_edits": false, "real_telegram_send": false, "commit": false }, "hash_verification": { "receipt": { "path": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-card-renderer.json", "sha256": "cc777e1b837f824fd60beddafb5eacd9732c8b01bbbe415e044861165fe4c00e", "declared_changed_files": [ "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py", "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py" ], "declared_source_hash_fields": [], "result": "unverifiable: the receipt has no source/content hashes, so its claimed green revision cannot be hash-matched to the current files. Its mtime is later than the two declared source/test mtimes, but that does not prove byte identity." }, "actual_files": { "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py": "c3abc25deb04f7da8fcf0119862414a016f4ed754962b0c1bbd46f1cc72a1589", "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py": "51c7d69375f0067582f14f63aa0a8f788c16a25c079ee566eb4f2e2dbf03654f", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_prompts.py": "6a72b232519335064fd1faa9bfcc7137a884c65a7d887cd3812f96fa6a448367" }, "dirty_inventory": { "result": "unverifiable", "reason": "the fixed implementation root has no .git metadata, so git status/diff cannot establish a dirty inventory or independently bind the receipt's two-file claim." } }, "evidence": [ { "kind": "dedicated_pytest", "command": "cd /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined && env PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH='/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/dualcoach/profile:/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined' uv run --directory '/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined' pytest -q tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py -q", "exit_code": 0, "result": "5 passed", "interpretation": "The dedicated test passes, but it only verifies rendered action IDs; it does not invoke u, forge l, exercise all-unknown summary progress, assert a confirmation receipt/header, or assert the requested Korean previous label." }, { "kind": "manual_zero_network_surface", "command": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined/.venv/bin/python -B /tmp/ulw-verify-task3.py", "exit_code": 1, "result_path": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-manual-surface.json", "sha256": "9cd0c31d619721a882a91bca81496fc0cf5bf279d5beaf0d49a92bd070608c28", "result": "FAIL: forged_later_rejected, machine_selected_receipt_variants_present, previous_label_is_explicit, unknown_action_advances, and unknown_completed_progress are false. Every rendered card reports value_echo=false." }, { "kind": "visual_qa_terminal", "capture_path": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-terminal-cards.txt", "capture_sha256": "552d15efb4023f06f32fa2f9f9695f24e4e223f19197e92b01005286d9441ddc", "capture_metadata": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-terminal-cards-metadata.json", "script_evidence": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-terminal-cards-visual-qa.json", "script_evidence_sha256": "75e7cb2d31e20397a15172e89a694af31ad3760f49b8e90569d2f0be9ed7c959", "result": "97 rendered lines at 80 columns; maxWidth=68, overflowLines=[], borderMisaligned=false, hasAnsi=false. Korean glyph width is preserved in the closest zero-network terminal rendering." }, { "kind": "cleanup", "path": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-temp-cleanup.txt", "sha256": "e0780fe7a4bd8cc44521c62e0c8cdc2ff9e57187cbda64685bed62b60c7fc5b5", "result": "PASS: /tmp/ulw-verify-task3.py and its temporary stdout/stderr assets are absent." } ], "findings": [ { "classification": "product", "severity": "blocker", "location": "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:333-350", "problem": "The visible u callback is accepted by the callback parser but is not routed to the domain unknown action. The navigation map handles only p, k, and l; u falls through _callback_transition, which has no u branch.", "repro_result": "Pressing the first-card 잘 모르겠어요 button returns accepted=false, notice=이 선택은 현재 질문에 맞지 않습니다., no next card, and leaves progress at 진행 1/12.", "required_fix": "For nutrition_daily unknown-capable steps, map u to the domain unknown action and persist the returned version/step exactly as other accepted transitions do; add a behavioral test that presses the actual callback." }, { "classification": "product", "severity": "blocker", "location": "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:869-885", "problem": "Summary completion counts only answers and excludes session.unknown_steps, contradicting completed-count progress for explicit unknowns.", "repro_result": "After all 11 unknown-capable fields were advanced through the real domain service and optional_note was skipped, a fresh bridge resume rendered 확인 1/12 instead of 확인 12/12.", "required_fix": "Count the union of eligible answers and unknown_steps in the summary, with each completed field counted once; add an all-unknown card regression." }, { "classification": "product", "severity": "blocker", "location": "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:310,333-340,655-663", "problem": "Although l is not rendered on ordinary nutrition-daily cards, a valid current nutrition callback with action l is accepted and invokes defer, producing the removed 나중에 계속 behavior.", "repro_result": "A current pc1 callback forged with action l returned accepted=true and notice=나중에 여기서 이어갈 수 있도록 임시 저장했습니다.", "required_fix": "Reject l for nutrition_daily before navigation dispatch while preserving it for the other flows; cover a current, correctly signed-shaped nutrition callback rather than only checking visible button rows." }, { "classification": "product", "severity": "major", "location": "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py:675,729-733; terminal cards later_known_history, edited, and resume", "problem": "Known and edited transitions render only progress plus the next question, with no value-free committed-answer receipt/header. The later valid-history button is labeled 이전 rather than the requested 이전 답 수정. There is also no machine-selected receipt variant type or selector in WizardReply/rendering code.", "repro_result": "The captured known, edited, and resumed cards start with 진행 2/12; the known/edited cards have no confirmation copy and later/edited/resume show [ 이전 | 잘 모르겠어요 ].", "required_fix": "Add an explicit machine-selected, value-free receipt variant for known, unknown, edited, previous, invalid, launch/resume, summary, and terminal states; render confirmation only after a committed answer, and label the valid history control 이전 답 수정." }, { "classification": "evidence", "severity": "major", "location": ".omo/evidence/nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper/task-3-card-renderer.json", "problem": "The implementation receipt declares only paths and command output, not the source hashes it claims to validate; its asserted PASS cannot be bound to the inspected revision. The fixed worktree has no VCS metadata for an independent dirty inventory.", "repro_result": "The receipt has no keys containing sha or hash; the fixed root has no .git entry.", "required_fix": "Regenerate the Todo 3 receipt after product fixes with SHA-256 values for every inspected source/test/prompt input and an independently checkable inventory." } ], "confirmed_good": [ "First ordinary card is unknown-only with progress 진행 1/12; a later known-history card exposes p and u.", "Sleep, digestion, condition, training, and optional-note content choices are preserved; optional_note exposes 없음/direct-input plus previous, with no rendered u or l.", "Known-input summary is value-free and renders 확인 12/12. The privacy-sentinel check found value_echo=false on every captured card.", "Launch, resume, invalid input, malformed action/overlength callback, and stale-version checks did not issue a false save confirmation; malformed and stale callbacks were rejected.", "The terminal visual surface fits within 80 columns with no overflow or border drift; Korean labels render as complete glyphs." ], "repro": [ { "case": "unknown callback", "steps": [ "Launch nutrition_daily and start the card.", "Press its visible u callback (잘 모르겠어요)." ], "expected": "The domain records unknown and renders a value-free 2/12 next-question receipt.", "actual": "Rejected as not matching the current question; no card is returned." }, { "case": "all-unknown progress", "steps": [ "Advance every unknown-capable nutrition field with the real domain unknown action and skip optional_note.", "Resume through the bridge and inspect summary." ], "expected": "확인 12/12.", "actual": "확인 1/12." }, { "case": "forged later callback", "steps": [ "Launch a current nutrition_daily bodyweight card.", "Submit a structurally valid current pc1 callback with action l." ], "expected": "Rejected because later/defer is removed for nutrition_daily.", "actual": "Accepted and deferred." } ], "adversarial_disposition": { "malformed_callback_action_and_length": "PASS: malformed action and overlength callback reject.", "stale_version": "PASS: stale callback rejects without prompt or confirmation.", "privacy_sentinel": "PASS: sentinel is absent from all rendered card text and callback data; only its SHA-256 is retained in evidence.", "misleading_success": "PARTIAL: no false save confirmation on launch/resume/invalid/stale, but known/edited committed answers lack the required confirmation receipt/header.", "leave_resume": "FAIL: normal resume preserves the cursor, but a forged current l callback still invokes the removed defer path.", "determinism": "Focused pytest passed once; the disposable driver uses isolated temporary storage and no sleeps, polling, provider, or network call. Its FAIL is deterministic from direct callback/domain outcomes.", "external_prompt_injection": "N/A: this renderer/callback scope consumes no external prompt or untrusted instruction text.", "network": "N/A for product transport: the manual surface instantiates only local bridge/domain storage and records network_events=0 and telegram_sends=0." }, "completion_gate": "Not satisfied. Fix the five findings, recapture every card/state on the resulting revision, hash-bind the replacement receipt, and obtain a fresh independent verification PASS." }