{ "schema": "nutricoach-telegram-checkin-stepper-task-7-audit-state-quality-v1", "task_id": "st_01a05a99", "recorded_at": "2026-09-01T10:34:34+09:00", "status": "PASS", "blocker_count": 0, "blockers": [], "worktree": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "cwd_binding": { "required_absolute_cwd": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "confirmed_pwd_P": "/home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined", "source_tests_diagnostics_location": "target worktree only", "plan_workspace_use": "evidence reads and this evidence write only", "confirmed_before_verdict": true, "status": "PASS" }, "audit_mode": "independent read-only source/state/code-quality audit; only this evidence file was written", "receipt_hashes_sha256": { "task-1-domain-unknown.json": "2622252bac43f8c3cf93781dc3e667ce9dbce405761132bfaf102a1df89c6150", "task-2-binding-projection.json": "437c21fe662c428d96d43301bb6b353f4e0a629d5be072e54c32fc031190facd", "task-3-card-renderer.json": "b26ecd259b4aa797cd65bfe29f2cf36cdc8d242efc2f0ead90f55f481f520383", "task-4-stepper-orchestrator.json": "7e0d363dbda02a5524a5a7c9fa381cd0e0a67099e8d87ca0d5368f835ab2632c", "task-5-telegram-integration.json": "45c213b6cc311cffa418adf76864d43c8974008945e5c6aca53ba5804842bc19", "task-6-legacy-installed.json": "da59efbc306a1b965eb9c5f3113bc168dfbcadd7a3f57aa2d85d9533396041bb" }, "changed_or_new_files_sha256": { "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard_models.py": "97cf03d068038ac3fc641806ae366c0a7762c72576910412fa61bfdd37819db0", "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard.py": "9ad1549953df5401bb5fe94f3636c0e433abd05d7e4ca2a9ff657529e7d16586", "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py": "593e3eb1ff201f62141fbf1aeeaf779149ff830a566b0e93edd2b557c4d49dc5", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_bindings.py": "f766bfacc45ed76d0f07c13745c761019317272cd570aa734204de10d3a54312", "tests/gateway/test_physique_checkin_projection.py": "b28107aab3f5c394204cedf205eb0169866a99173ae985c6d8a0b083af7909b7", "tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py": "be7b3afa566a4d326ee8cf123070977d59b36f0570f67447368f5a9f83870ab4", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py": "2a9d9dd79c52834e0cd941b4bac90dd8d137571e0377fa507350c29c890af93b", "tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py": "d12865a2ecbf6744f7d97121c77b23d0f05c717eda59caf2f656a37a8b8d8aa7", "gateway/platforms/telegram_physique_checkin_stepper.py": "45e480a6b48b68a94261a4969b81043e846edf36b5263e511c62ec2fea36b3ce", "tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin_stepper.py": "40e2b89424b62f39bc127291b35eb8ee387ef05f8dd4edf64bc778126c878e50", "gateway/platforms/telegram.py": "91fc4c4f163ece7bc59f6a75bd7e901255b515a2de4d59756858f5ba4841e52b", "gateway/platforms/telegram_checkin_stepper_transport.py": "d2184bd038f8cc7e0bb738897404c70d63445fe32b5ae0a72d52721120c93157", "tests/gateway/test_telegram_stepper_integration.py": "82b6ef9c07856ae6d6d2a7991c75bee024feaf3b1f4e2474c8a4a9044b07562d", "scripts/run_nutricoach_v150_telegram_stepper_qa.py": "d2fddeced484a5d207a5febff5f77fc8b3108392c5b8802c2929d3a735b1aacb", "tests/gateway/test_nutricoach_stepper_legacy_compat.py": "e401e1f19e1ca1655be6a371346ba4e81438c0f263a530e86acaf3a6f3765016", "scripts/nutricoach_v150_customer_ux_smoke.py": "e5a8f05273ff066ebbd67b4f1d6a60ba685c0b15007cbd1c9f8b73d81a0a3328" }, "required_hash_gate": { "path": "tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py", "required_sha256": "be7b3afa566a4d326ee8cf123070977d59b36f0570f67447368f5a9f83870ab4", "actual_sha256": "be7b3afa566a4d326ee8cf123070977d59b36f0570f67447368f5a9f83870ab4", "status": "PASS" }, "end_to_end_state_audit": { "status": "PASS", "files_read": [ "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard_models.py", "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard.py", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin_bindings.py", "gateway/platforms/physique_checkin.py", "gateway/platforms/telegram_physique_checkin_stepper.py", "gateway/platforms/telegram_checkin_stepper_transport.py", "gateway/platforms/telegram.py", "focused projection/state/integration/legacy tests" ], "findings": { "typed_six_phases": "ProjectionPhase is a closed enum with prepared, domain_committed, send_started, delivered, delivery_failed, delivery_uncertain; persisted phase transitions are allowlisted.", "ordering": "PREPARED is atomically recorded before transition.commit; DOMAIN_COMMITTED is recorded after the accepted domain CAS and before transport prepare/send; SEND_STARTED is recorded before the sole awaited provider call.", "one_accepted_send": "Fresh ingress can invoke transport.send once; duplicate update identity and any observed prior session uncertainty/recovery path perform zero sends. No automatic resend path exists.", "failure_semantics": "Local preflight failure is delivery_failed with zero provider calls; explicit definitive provider rejection is delivery_failed after one call; cancellation, unclassified post-call failure, invalid receipt, binding failure, and delivered-state persistence failure are delivery_uncertain and never replayed.", "restart_replay_expiry_corruption": "All six restart phases are observation-only; duplicate/stale/conflicting ingress fails closed; expired rows do not mutate/send; malformed/truncated/symlinked projection state fails closed.", "poll_terminality": "Every StepperResult is poll_terminal=true; integration coverage confirms uncertainty permits the polling offset to advance without resend.", "explicit_resume": "resume and observe_ingress only read durable state and return a UI decision; neither commits the domain nor calls transport.", "message_binding": "Telegram response message_id is validated positive before bind_message_id is called; binding failure after provider acceptance becomes uncertainty.", "unknown_projection": "Explicit unknown markers remain disjoint from answers and project to None/omitted canonical values, including all three macro fields; no sentinel value is fabricated.", "previous_navigation": "previous_cursor_identity reads persisted step_history[-1]; WizardService._previous truncates actual history and retained state rather than deriving a fabricated future/completion step.", "lock_boundary": "BindingStore locks are scoped to individual load/record operations. Domain commit, transport preflight, and awaited Telegram send occur after those calls return, so no file lock spans transport I/O." } }, "tests": { "focused_gateway_state_projection_integration_legacy_card": { "command": "PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=: .venv/bin/python -m pytest -q -p no:cacheprovider --basetemp=/tmp/st_01a05a99-pytest-gateway tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin_stepper.py tests/gateway/test_physique_checkin_projection.py tests/gateway/test_telegram_stepper_integration.py tests/gateway/test_nutricoach_stepper_legacy_compat.py tests/gateway/test_customer_nutrition_stepper_card.py", "result": "103 passed in 0.88s", "exit_code": 0 }, "focused_profile_unknown_state": { "command": "UV_OFFLINE=1 TMPDIR=/tmp PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 uv run pytest -q -p no:cacheprovider --basetemp=/tmp/st_01a05a99-pytest-profile tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py", "result": "19 passed in 0.13s", "exit_code": 0 }, "bridge_and_coaching_integration": { "command": "PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=: .venv/bin/python -m pytest -q -p no:cacheprovider tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin.py tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py", "result": "168 passed in 2.94s", "exit_code": 0 }, "collection_boundary_note": "A preliminary single-process mix of root tests and dualcoach/profile/tests hit the repository's known duplicate top-level tests-package import boundary. The same scopes were immediately run in their authoritative separate working/package contexts and passed; this is not a runtime or product failure." }, "diagnostics": { "ruff_all_16_changed_new_files": { "status": "PASS", "result": "All checks passed!" }, "new_typed_test_qa_scope": [ "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard_models.py", "dualcoach/profile/tests/test_nutrition_daily_unknown.py", "gateway/platforms/telegram_physique_checkin_stepper.py", "tests/gateway/test_telegram_physique_checkin_stepper.py", "gateway/platforms/telegram_checkin_stepper_transport.py", "tests/gateway/test_telegram_stepper_integration.py", "scripts/run_nutricoach_v150_telegram_stepper_qa.py", "tests/gateway/test_nutricoach_stepper_legacy_compat.py", "scripts/nutricoach_v150_customer_ux_smoke.py" ], "ty_new_typed_test_qa": { "status": "PASS", "result": "All checks passed!" }, "basedpyright_new_typed_test_qa": { "status": "PASS", "result": "0 errors, 0 warnings, 0 notes" }, "basedpyright_task5_changed_region_json": { "status": "PASS", "file": "tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py", "region": "lines 2236-2260", "whole_file_error_count": 1367, "recorded_legacy_baseline": 1367, "changed_region_error_count": 0, "outside_region_error_count": 1367, "new_diagnostics_outside_region": 0, "command_exit_classification": "expected nonzero solely for unchanged legacy diagnostics" }, "compileall_all_16": { "status": "PASS", "artifact_policy": "PYTHONPYCACHEPREFIX used a disposable task directory, then removed" }, "outside_source_import": { "status": "PASS", "cwd": "/tmp/st_01a05a99-import", "pythonpath_environment": "unset, then exact source roots inserted by the isolated interpreter", "modules": 6 } }, "manual_zero_network_qa": { "status": "PASS", "output": { "automatic_recovery_sends0": true, "customer_messages": 0, "duplicate_advances0": true, "known_sends1": true, "network_events": 0, "polling_unknown_terminal": true, "resume_target": "nutrition_daily", "status": "PASS", "unknown_sends1": true } }, "code_quality_review": { "status": "PASS", "new_typed_test_qa_shortcut_scan": { "Any": 0, "cast_calls": 0, "type_ignore": 0, "noqa": 0, "sleep_calls": 0, "wait_for_time_patterns": 0 }, "assertions": "Focused tests retain exact phase, cursor, send/commit count, receipt, mutation, privacy, polling, and replay assertions; no skip/xfail or assertion weakening was found.", "broad_exception_review": "Broad catches in the orchestrator and transport are deliberate external-boundary classifiers: each returns or persists an explicit failure/uncertainty disposition and none silently swallows success, retries, or bypasses diagnostics. BaseException handlers in BindingStore are descriptor-cleanup guards that re-raise. No test broad catch was added.", "legacy_cast_review": "Casts outside the strict new typed surfaces are confined to existing legacy adapter/projection JSON narrowing and protocol integration. They do not suppress diagnostics; no type-ignore/noqa was introduced.", "nondeterminism": "Focused state tests use fixed epochs, explicit phase installation, direct awaited operations, and temporary directories; no fixed sleeps, polling delays, or timing-luck assertions were found." }, "legacy_classification": { "status": "NON_BLOCKING", "dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/wizard.py": "1392-line pre-existing domain module; recorded 30 unrelated strict diagnostics remain outside the Todo 1 typed model/test surface. No suppression or broad refactor was performed.", "gateway/platforms/telegram.py": "16379-line pre-existing adapter with substantial whole-file strict legacy debt outside the Todo 5 ingress region. Required new typed transport/test/QA surfaces are zero-diagnostic; Ruff on the changed file passes. No broad refactor was performed.", "tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py": "Large legacy test file remains at the exact recorded 1367-error baseline; the Task 5 changed region is zero-diagnostic after the required hash-pinned typed fix.", "oversized_files": "Reviewed only through the changed integration seams and focused behavior, consistent with the no-broad-refactor requirement." }, "cleanup_and_side_effects": { "task_temp_paths_remaining": 0, "temporary_basedpyright_json_removed": true, "pytest_basetemps_removed": true, "compile_cache_removed": true, "outside_import_directory_removed": true, "preexisting_shared_caches_retained": true, "source_or_test_edits": 0, "network_events": 0, "customer_messages": 0, "git_commands": 0, "commits": 0 }, "DoneClaim": "PASS: runtime/state-machine semantics and changed-line/new-surface quality are blocker-free; blocker_count=0." }