{
  "schema": "task26-objective-final-immutable-successor-v1",
  "task": 26,
  "task_id": "st_01a00432",
  "lane": "objective_constraint",
  "recorded_at_utc": "2026-08-15T06:56:59Z",
  "scope": "Read-only objective, invariant, minimum-operation, no-shortcut, owner-only, cleanup, and release-constraint review. Historical Task22-25 execution is classified only as historical compatibility/provenance and is not retargeted to the successor.",
  "verdict": "FAIL",
  "release_decision": "NO-GO",
  "task26_release_authority_claimed": false,
  "task27_or_f1_f5_authorized": false,
  "candidate": {
    "full_digest": "653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723",
    "core_digest": "a03f84f7db67afe0ace8d31541dd373852af052fbb1a23a8e70dd96c6263f5ef",
    "authority": "IMMUTABLE_SUCCESSOR_CANDIDATE_NOT_TASK26_PASS_OR_RELEASE_AUTHORITY",
    "root": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723",
    "manifest": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723/candidate-manifest.json",
      "sha256": "23b72148af7412b292555107c6b29616d9436c437871787763667c9fb62fca26"
    },
    "checkpoint_sha256": "6acc31bdf597dfb51151fb4c2cd76cb7da2ceb33579a8cd840490fbbfdbbd4be",
    "freeze_receipt": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-freeze-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723.json",
      "sha256": "07873d35557e5fc797786f6095bf7fe6bd957a0d200f034179fb129c9e0384ed"
    },
    "repository_status": {
      "entry_count": 1294,
      "sha256": "ca1ce2705c0c406f30461e5f05e8d09468dee33348960c3650b6b98758895478",
      "gate_observation": "stable before and after the candidate-bound gates"
    },
    "wheel_sha256": "af4a9d0a1ffffb6eb7551c1d6dc2b32853ca6d024332a4f8f5702bbf992f141b",
    "executable_closure": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723/bindings/executable-closure.json",
      "sha256": "c3e443f0e3a14ac7a786c15e2d5aff4d368581f3e868e12ebae356adb3354380",
      "entry_count": 2374,
      "entries_sha256": "7d7fb32d5fa89326c34b17af4ea00f8888f36571ed2d4c5a1027fc3e01d986dd"
    }
  },
  "governing_artifacts": {
    "plan": {
      "path": ".omo/plans/dualcoach-production-readiness.md",
      "sha256": "d809d7b45f6b399196331c49952e4e34347202388321d920611998db4d38f68f"
    },
    "handoff": {
      "path": ".omo/start-work/dualcoach-production-readiness-handoff.md",
      "sha256": "afa4f8a2459cf62662cd197a23d22b35fb46e01602a057dd850bcb16ca1d8470",
      "release_state": "NO-GO"
    }
  },
  "candidate_bound_gate_evidence": {
    "gate18": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate18-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723-receipt.json",
      "sha256": "589223e0d391346939dccbb79351b3d408a07351bb9218c4496e28b851814e5a",
      "status": "PASS",
      "coverage": "19 source plus 19 sealed-wheel tests; source/wheel and source-closure mismatch counts are zero"
    },
    "gate19": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate19-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723-receipt.json",
      "sha256": "00bdaf0186437e9b93ca9fe2badd3f6a4db5fd8c4cf5b69c66135bb7245fd688",
      "matrix_path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate19-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723-matrix.json",
      "matrix_sha256": "ec319ee060d942722c3bdd93b616cbe79186cd35302f78051591761227699dc6",
      "status": "PASS",
      "coverage": "120 required results: 118 pytest nodes plus 2 archive-boundary assertions; failed=0; skipped=0"
    },
    "gate20": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate20-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723-receipt.json",
      "sha256": "643970f32ef2f1e841ff2a43b28270e8ec539033026f832303955209f392d541",
      "status": "PASS",
      "coverage": "8138 passed, 0 failed, 59 skipped; candidate verifier and source/status pre/post results are identical"
    }
  },
  "historical_archive_boundary": {
    "binding": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723/bindings/historical-archive-binding.json",
      "sha256": "0f388e58385f823bee907af1d68868ed31395f1b8b8590e0fe13e21fa541752d",
      "binding_sha256": "b6f459adaad944cd61bde7feb8bebcb6faa64b49c55a087117f74b3185bd3613",
      "classification": "historical_compatibility_and_provenance_evidence_only",
      "historical_execution_retargeted_to_successor": false
    },
    "reconciliation": {
      "path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723/bindings/task22-25-reconciliation-index.json",
      "sha256": "7594fcfc41fc7f344791436f630a6b6ebc6e5fac1b6adf74126ca9845f29db2f",
      "indexes_sha256": "419511b6fadb7920e155dcd5b57d20661d750a989ef0912e9ddf1bfbc0cb0abe",
      "statement": "The Task22-25 receipts are not claimed as successor execution."
    },
    "archive": {
      "id": "2009ac177177839cefddb98f285e27fa",
      "digest": "644d74b05bc8115f9e3aeeba035188da195a7de18f1bc737648931d64bf43bcf",
      "scope_count": 23,
      "manifest_path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723/historical/archive-manifest.json",
      "manifest_sha256": "ca4811444e114a06749620b9a44e05c8bd62bc3223ec80b1b5740c832c4a84c1",
      "receipt_path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-repaired-archive-successor-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723/historical/archive-receipt.json",
      "receipt_sha256": "e81a84a8584400401f83aace36283dee18660144ede11e854758e725796e7fb3"
    },
    "task_indexes": [
      {"task": 22, "path": ".omo/evidence/dualcoach-task-22-evidence-index.json", "sha256": "cc4ac1264d947226f0e2ebfdd2f3845781d48ab298a71ae96c09517eecb26309", "credit": "HISTORICAL_ONLY"},
      {"task": 23, "path": ".omo/evidence/dualcoach-task-23-evidence-index.json", "sha256": "86b72c4c21b9f1113cb34e81b293e93ed7df7ac1388d3d1b31d9dc01dca3987a", "credit": "HISTORICAL_ONLY"},
      {"task": 24, "path": ".omo/evidence/dualcoach-task-24-evidence-index.json", "sha256": "4df0f8712887f2125e100ba8d7585914b7b8810a298c37f9a32584b31fabe04d", "credit": "HISTORICAL_ONLY"},
      {"task": 25, "path": ".omo/evidence/dualcoach-task-25-evidence-index.json", "sha256": "c3c40ff9406dbb2609ee7ef89be2fdc20fa139064b5d65e494c6efc8b2a80ed2", "credit": "HISTORICAL_ONLY"}
    ]
  },
  "objective_and_invariant_map": [
    {
      "id": "OBJECTIVE",
      "requirement": "One reproducible lifecycle through intended Telegram surfaces through cleanup, without prohibited manual shortcuts.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate18 exact source/wheel Golden Path; Gate19 120-node matrix; Gate20 full gateway PASS.",
      "historical": "Task22-25 archive records owner review, activation/check-in, one synthetic delivery, and cleanup.",
      "status": "FAIL",
      "reason": "The real-surface sequence is expressly historical-only and cannot be credited as execution on 653c. No exact-candidate real-surface receipt exists, and the cross-task no-shortcut condition is not proven."
    },
    {
      "id": "I1",
      "requirement": "Disabled before activation and no coaching delivery before activation.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate18 Golden Path PASS; Gate19 restart and authority nodes PASS.",
      "historical": "Task22 index records customer_enabled=false with zero downstream authority; Task25 index records disabled, delivery disabled, future jobs=0.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I2",
      "requirement": "Zero delivery before operator approval.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 node test_approval_receipt_is_immutable_duplicate_idempotent_and_zero_delivery PASS.",
      "historical": "Task23 index records customer_delivery_count=0 before Task24.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I3",
      "requirement": "Zero delivery after approval and before explicit send.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 approval/zero-delivery node PASS.",
      "historical": "Task24 matrix records approve=zero delivery entries before explicit send.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I4",
      "requirement": "Explicit send creates exactly one provider message and one sent_audited receipt.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 delivery restart/timeout nodes PASS; Gate20 full suite PASS.",
      "historical": "Task24 index records synthetic_customer_delivery_count=1 and sent_audited_receipt_count=1; Task25 preserves that terminal receipt in the archive.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I5",
      "requirement": "Wrong-role, wrong-chat, wrong-topic, stale, and duplicate callbacks have no mutation.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 exact wrong-user/route, stale-owner-callback, and immutable-duplicate approval nodes PASS.",
      "historical": "Task24 index records stale/repeat/wrong-role durable mutations=0.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I6",
      "requirement": "Callback acknowledgement failure does not roll back committed work or suppress publication.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 callback acknowledgement-before-stale-rejection node PASS; candidate security lane records durable acknowledgement/receipt fencing.",
      "historical": "No exact-candidate real-surface acknowledgement-failure observation exists.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I7",
      "requirement": "Provider authentication failure is detected early and leaves retryable durable state.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 auth-failure-retryable-without-receipt-deletion and provider_auth_not_ready fail-closed nodes PASS.",
      "historical": "Task23 index retains historical provider/recovery artifacts only.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I8",
      "requirement": "Every waiting-boundary restart preserves progress without duplicate delivery.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 restart-preservation, owner-review restart, generation lease, and delivery-before-receipt nodes PASS.",
      "historical": "Task22-24 indexes record owner-review and send-boundary restart evidence.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I9",
      "requirement": "Completion requires durable receipt and intended customer-surface observation, not provider 200 alone.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 durable receipt/no-resend nodes and Gate20 full suite PASS.",
      "historical": "Task24 index records one synthetic customer delivery and one sent_audited receipt; it is historical-only by the successor binding.",
      "status": "TECHNICAL_COVERAGE_PASS_HISTORICAL_SURFACE_ONLY"
    },
    {
      "id": "I10",
      "requirement": "Production release evidence comes from the exact immutable candidate under review.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gates18-20 bind 653c and report zero candidate/source/wheel drift.",
      "historical": "Binding expressly disclaims retargeting Task22-25 execution to 653c.",
      "status": "FAIL",
      "reason": "There is no 653c-bound real-surface lifecycle receipt. Historical execution cannot be promoted to production execution on the successor."
    },
    {
      "id": "I11",
      "requirement": "Owner/operator is sole nutrition authority; no trainer marker, claim, invite, card, UI, route, data access, review, readiness, activation, or safety-hold path is required.",
      "candidate_bound": "Gate19 has six trainer-free contract nodes and owner-review authority nodes PASS; .omo/evidence/task26/task26-security-final-653cc2f0.redacted.json (sha256 7c7a36a1bc8534ad3576b4f268347960ec7c94a588801b281d44efb1a5e4fca5) reports zero forbidden production matches.",
      "historical": "Task22 index reports trainer_absent=true; this is not retargeted.",
      "status": "PASS"
    }
  ],
  "minimum_operation_and_shortcut_map": [
    {
      "requirement": "Smallest change; no speculative capability, unrelated refactor, or weakened acceptance condition.",
      "status": "PASS_FOR_PID_SUCCESSOR_DELTA_ONLY",
      "evidence": "Candidate supersession records exactly one changed closure entry, gateway/status.py, 60499 bytes / 7a04d81c... to 60653 bytes / 8641bae4..., delta sha256 f3820c5f2dc5ec7170b53966bb3f84e71865f69252711128c98de92658a71355. Quality lane receipt ee55939799c5ca8e41b25600ac6e12e37078eda042234ffa20dfd27d75a2095d confirms one hunk and no candidate-caused quality regression."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "No raw listener, direct JSON mutation, manual ledger deletion, direct service replay, forced card republication, or recovery shortcut as normal-path proof.",
      "status": "FAIL",
      "evidence": "Task22 index explicitly sets global_no_recovery_shortcut_criterion=not_claimed and retains a recovery incident/replay. Task24's no-direct-mutation/service-replay evidence is disposable/historical only. No candidate-bound cross-task normal-surface no-shortcut receipt was supplied.",
      "reason": "Missing or inconclusive evidence is fail-closed; this finding does not assert an unpermitted action occurred."
    },
    {
      "requirement": "Do not retarget historical execution.",
      "status": "PASS",
      "evidence": "Candidate manifest, archive binding, reconciliation index, Gates18-20, and this review all state historical_execution_retargeted_to_successor=false; candidate non_actions records archive_restores=0, profile_or_runtime_edits=0, service_actions=0, network_or_provider_actions=0, and telegram_actions=0."
    }
  ],
  "owner_only_and_cleanup": {
    "owner_only_trainer_free": "PASS for candidate-bound technical authority controls; security-lane PASS is scoped only to security and does not override this objective lane's I10/no-shortcut findings.",
    "historical_cleanup": {
      "status": "PASS_HISTORICAL_ONLY",
      "evidence": ".omo/evidence/dualcoach-task-25-evidence.json sha256 3e4a89c954652e7bcc260e7bf7edcd993674cc02a3f49be0584bb2e7ec8f9919: customer disabled, delivery gate false, scheduled jobs=0, inactive/dead, orphan count=0, other profiles byte-identical."
    },
    "candidate_gate_cleanup_and_runtime": {
      "status": "PASS_AT_GATE20_OBSERVATION",
      "evidence": "Gate20 before/after service state is inactive/dead with MainPID=0 and actions=0; postflight .omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate20-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723-artifacts/postflight.json sha256 e7a61cd3b9bbcedfb8f3684b6bf044afe2b636d76dc4f6615241b8066902696b; cleanup artifact sha256 a2d23079bef2a8893e91570dac1e1cb84336029c1e532a9e7e8f05237e255dd5 removed only temporary pytest paths."
    },
    "current_runtime_limit": "No new runtime/service observation was made by this review, as prohibited. The latest eligible candidate-bound state is Gate20's clean pre/post observation."
  },
  "pid_finding_and_fix": {
    "predecessor": {
      "digest": "3b42723d0e8256351defdf31958f9ade795f80a7be456529740949c87875d527",
      "gate20_receipt": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate20-3b42723d0e8256351defdf31958f9ade795f80a7be456529740949c87875d527-receipt.json",
      "gate20_receipt_sha256": "0eb81aeeb2a1d49ec05bbf80e6a9073c3a16e22b9e5e9d876f6b5a76f6f6e14d",
      "finding": "PID-state coverage was blocked in the predecessor required Gate20 execution."
    },
    "successor": {
      "supersession_receipt": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-gate20-pid-supersession-3b42723d0e8256351defdf31958f9ade795f80a7be456529740949c87875d527-to-653cc2f0b47873e95f985ea3eb32b8f2c044d6de64cd9e8fe37ebcec67c7a723.json",
      "supersession_receipt_sha256": "8805062af465e95e7ceb1eaa2c1b9bea02cf8d179b9af693c9dd18dc7ad401cd",
      "fix": "gateway/status.py now requires a validated primary PID record for stale cleanup; source sha256 8641bae4540dcadec0f80a3d97b1a1013ab36f3cb1b4920027d70cae1d1d308c; unchanged focused test sha256 1976b3530484b105704fdf2bcf1c6302ec7416fcec33f675e515177ef7447c5d.",
      "verification": "Gate18 three PID regressions pass in source and wheel lanes; Gate19 PID-reuse-live-identity coverage passes; Gate20 full suite passes including test_get_running_pid_rejects_live_non_gateway_pid."
    }
  },
  "candidate_drift": {
    "verdict": "NONE_OBSERVED_WITHIN_CANDIDATE_BOUND_GATE_WINDOWS",
    "evidence": [
      "Gate18 immutable tree unchanged; source closure mismatch_count=0; source/wheel mismatch_count=0.",
      "Gate19 candidate tree before/after sha256=70684015f5a657bf611d5ce8a7151ccceb4e5932aeb91d2c1589c4cb490a6eda.",
      "Gate20 candidate pre/post verifier results identical, repository-status drift=false, source drift count=0, source/wheel mismatch count=0."
    ],
    "limit": "No fresh Git or source-worktree inspection was performed by this review; that was explicitly prohibited."
  },
  "release_constraint_result": {
    "all_task26_lanes_pass": false,
    "known_candidate_specific_lanes_at_audit": [
      {"lane": "quality", "verdict": "PASS", "receipt": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-quality-final-653cc2f0.redacted.json", "sha256": "ee55939799c5ca8e41b25600ac6e12e37078eda042234ffa20dfd27d75a2095d"},
      {"lane": "security_privacy_authority", "verdict": "PASS", "receipt": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-security-final-653cc2f0.redacted.json", "sha256": "7c7a36a1bc8534ad3576b4f268347960ec7c94a588801b281d44efb1a5e4fca5"},
      {"lane": "objective_constraint", "verdict": "FAIL", "receipt": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-objective-final-653cc2f0.redacted.json"}
    ],
    "decisive_findings": [
      "I10 exact-candidate real-surface release evidence is absent; historical Task22-25 execution is correctly non-retargeted and therefore cannot fill it.",
      "The global no-shortcut normal-path condition is explicitly not claimed by Task22 and lacks an exact-candidate cross-task receipt."
    ],
    "required_state": "NO-GO; no release, Task27, F1-F5, live invite, service/runtime action, Telegram action, provider action, customer activation, or delivery follows from this receipt."
  },
  "non_touch_and_cleanup": {
    "receipt_path": ".omo/evidence/task26/task26-objective-final-653cc2f0.redacted.json",
    "receipt_files_created": 1,
    "source_or_test_edits": 0,
    "candidate_or_archive_edits": 0,
    "profile_runtime_service_actions": 0,
    "network_telegram_provider_actions": 0,
    "git_actions": 0,
    "temporary_files_created": 0,
    "temporary_files_removed": 0,
    "cleanup_status": "PASS"
  }
}