I read this as a surgical Task22 recovery implementation - I’ll trace and authenticate the immutable lineage first, then add a test-first one-record compatibility path and verify it entirely on disposable state without touching the live process or Telegram.


Lineage authentication is now the deciding gate: the existing implementation deliberately rejects any captured callback in its historical PREPARED compatibility path, so I’m tracing the clicked token’s embedded hash through the committed card payload, session projections, original 22-answer source, and ingress receipt before adding a terminal-only consumer.


message: Codex error: Our servers are currently overloaded. Please try again later.

stop_reason: error


The immutable lineage is sufficient: `f04089…19d6` is the bootstrap invite-secret digest stored beside session `rb_…88g`, while `259312…8b46` is SHA-256 of that session ID; the renderer intentionally encoded the former and the recovery verifier incorrectly reconstructed the latter. I’m adding the exact-record exception at that verifier boundary, with the committed render, 22-answer digest, ingress failure, authority, and callback HMAC all still mandatory.


The compatibility branch is in place and the exact negative matrix is green. I’m moving through full focused verification now, including the existing crash/replay and generation-28 tests, Ruff/type diagnostics, compileall, and a disposable callback-to-terminal recovery that uses a mocked transport only.


I read this as implementation and proof - report the completed fail-closed recovery path and the safe operational blocker.

Implemented the exact Task22 compatibility path.

- Proven lineage: callback hash `f04089…19d6` is the bootstrap `sid_hash` for session `rb_Ar-NuKG3LH8CqHPXUgc88g`, whose SHA-256 is pinned as `259312…8b46`.
- Root cause: the generation-27 renderer encoded bootstrap `sid_hash`; the supplemental verifier expected SHA-256(session ID).
- Compatibility is restricted to the authenticated historical callback and exact session, owner, route, message `122`, update, HMAC, generation-27 render/dispatch, 22-answer digest, bootstrap lineage, ingress failure, and PREPARED journal.
- Every mismatch and replay fails closed.
- Disposable verification proves review recovery, generation 28 publication, terminal commit, and idempotent replay exactly once.

Verification:

- `79 passed`
- Ruff and compileall passed.
- Direct and canonical artifact verification passed.
- Candidate: `8b01961925be9f6f570377572018070b27e1af25e9498232b7192d8c5b8d4024`
- Manifest: `87262f09c8211043429915cc6f7bfb3323780048a0f94def4c5c101dea5a11fa`
- Freeze: `d24b0587ebf161fc1ff0d9758dbda715b8485ec48bd7074d1abc2d46e8e6b868`
- Read-only live preflight remains ready at generation 27/message 122.
- Gateway PID `646713` remained unchanged.

**Precise blocker:** no safe no-reclick mutation command currently exists. The authorized launcher is intentionally read-only, and the running gateway has not loaded the new compatibility code. Completing recovery requires a service reload and live journal/publication mutation, both explicitly excluded. Do not click Approve again.

Safe read-only confirmation command:

```bash
cd /home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent &&
./scripts/task22-supplemental-owner-review
```

No Telegram, service, or live-state action was performed.


I read this as an offline implementation request - I’ll add a pin-locked recovery CLI, exhaustive disposable tests, reseal and verify artifacts, without touching the live service or profile.


The existing state machine already provides receipt-backed generation-28 transport semantics; I’m wiring the launcher directly to that path while holding the gateway runtime lock, so generation 27 cannot be resent and uncertain provider outcomes remain fail-closed.


`apply_patch` is not installed in this workspace; no files were changed by that attempt. I’ll use the available exact-replacement patch tool and keep the same narrow three-leaf scope.


I read this as completed offline recovery implementation - report sealed pins, verification, and the exact future execution procedure.

Implemented an exact, non-generic recovery mode:

```text
--recover-exact task22-terminal-recovery-v1:629525051:987cdde4e245b1d316ab5000271a755db148153b5207156b8082f97c2a1f5c18
```

Properties:

- Requires the target gateway process and runtime lock to be quiescent.
- Consumes only callback event `987cdde4…f5c18`, update `629525051`, message `122`.
- Advances `PREPARED -> REVIEW_COMMITTED -> PUBLICATION_COMMITTED`.
- Uses the existing receipt-backed runtime transport to publish generation 28 once.
- Cannot publish or resend generation 27.
- Replays terminal state without sending generation 28 again.
- Provider-uncertain and mismatched states fail closed.
- Default no-argument mode remains read-only and can verify terminal state.

Exact pins:

- Profile: `dualcoachtest`
- Customer: `task22_dm_rehearsal`
- Session: `rb_Ar-NuKG3LH8CqHPXUgc88g`
- Session SHA-256: `259312739d9f8d31c42e56d5741fc00b419f2ad927de09095461406bd6628b46`
- Embedded callback hash: `f04089a3d333cfb35c6fdff8f9201b0a021a7fd0efa53925a9af195546f619d6`
- Callback integrity: `987cdde4e245b1d316ab5000271a755db148153b5207156b8082f97c2a1f5c18`
- Update/message: `629525051` / `122`
- Owner authority: `(8693203710, 8693203710, 0)`
- Generation-27 render: `e8755dd5f864bfead5c1fc0de8ff0f0cbd43af70a80a78c655cfc4b9c4f162cd`
- Generation-27 dispatch: `c6e06b11125e4ea6e17c30d8b372a382ba6cff4dadb19d9ff0de3bfab844c239`
- Answers digest: `f1aced0350c473a01aa4e1382bc810e072fccfe84ccd3ea8780ee83c324dfe55`

Sealed artifacts:

- Candidate: `0741fb00c447e819fbd472f9ab88ba5fc7b45dad438a224a41c5ef2b000b7d8f`
- Manifest: `df2e1d2ce9e10831abb4df8d365e77cb4c64b910c9316d6d5cf9a020de628f4e`
- Freeze: `87b992529f177fbaa14a11c2d7ff6efa7fdce20e5cdb5ff55e494bfdc72bef04`
- Wheel: `f592abefa3deca172c9d0b8dcb8013e0e8a1fc97ff03db4054adb3f0b6f3abf2`
- Wheel receipt: `1e62e72e0c57d26882bab4634ed5843cf5e2305ac441d70a5c5a14da6103f00f`

Verification passed:

- `88 passed`
- Ruff passed.
- Compile checks passed.
- Basedpyright: `0 errors, 0 warnings`
- Direct and canonical artifact verification passed.
- Deterministic two-epoch wheel reproduction passed.
- Temporary build artifacts cleaned.
- Live gateway PID `646713` remains running and unchanged; no live state or service mutation occurred.

Safe future procedure:

```bash
set -euo pipefail
cd /home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent
PY=.venv/bin/python

$PY -m hermes_cli.main --profile dualcoachtest gateway stop

./scripts/task22-supplemental-owner-review \
  --recover-exact \
  'task22-terminal-recovery-v1:629525051:987cdde4e245b1d316ab5000271a755db148153b5207156b8082f97c2a1f5c18'

$PY -m hermes_cli.main --profile dualcoachtest gateway start

$PY -I -B - <<'PY'
import sys
sys.path.insert(0, "/home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent")
from gateway.platforms.telegram_nutrition_onboarding_supplemental_review import (
    require_task22_supplemental_for_activation,
)
assert require_task22_supplemental_for_activation(
    "/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest",
    customer_key="task22_dm_rehearsal",
    session_id="rb_Ar-NuKG3LH8CqHPXUgc88g",
)
print("Task22 terminal approval verified")
PY
```

With `set -e`, any failed pin, active-service detection, uncertain publication, or nonterminal result leaves the gateway stopped rather than continuing.


I read this as a focused import-closure fix - I’ll inspect the active gateway’s exact package origin and launcher import order, bind that installation by path/hash/API version before Bot construction, test under clean isolated execution, then reseal without touching live state or service.


I read this as a focused import-closure fix - the launcher now binds and verifies the active profile package before importing runtime code.

Fixed `ModuleNotFoundError: checkin_cli` without copying the package or using ambient `PYTHONPATH`.

Import closure now:

- Uses `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/workspace/checkin_cli`.
- Verifies every sealed `profile_package` manifest leaf by size and SHA-256.
- Recomputes package digest before modifying `sys.path`.
- Requires package name `physique-checkin-cli`, version `0.1.0`, and API version `2.0`.
- Verifies the imported module resolves to the exact profile path.
- Fails closed on path, hash, version, source, or API drift.
- Completes all imports before constructing `telegram.Bot`.

Exact package pins:

- Package root: `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/workspace/checkin_cli`
- Package digest: `3090dc7ca9e93236394dd4da88647b100ea70b22f00080950a24e1d254f575e6`
- Package version: `0.1.0`
- API version: `2.0`
- `pyproject.toml`: `7c48641ec198f539aa4af1f2000254b76a2915fd1b8f143f5b118ad662e4fb1e`
- `checkin_cli/__init__.py`: `03ca6eaec37e7dc6c92d8d6794159c5c363a824e1849e14137dda0e10f818a65`
- `nutrition_onboarding.py`: `6180e0c82cb7ed8b7f229c2005f643349621a2deeecddfdef25ed3ed05a06d25`
- `nutrition_onboarding_contract.py`: `327267e12c2e6250218652811cca403a80c1704753f2caace7d8b1e446d21417`

New artifact pins:

- Candidate: `3ce5b95637211b0289529c35b452cf1771fe868a34777140388a8caa75e183cc`
- Manifest: `e456cfc6c93d97989319818879a38237cd70c0d516ae5d2e33543a59962658e8`
- Freeze: `5c98ffeb84961eb91ae33e184094f2382ceff14ad6110263ffdb6ca860f23b48`
- Wheel: `f592abefa3deca172c9d0b8dcb8013e0e8a1fc97ff03db4054adb3f0b6f3abf2`
- Wheel receipt: `188a2e0451ddc52ef583d232d53f6ae51ba6db7ae4d078e50c9fe0f9df4a8663`

Verification:

- `93 passed`
- Clean-env `-I -B` import closure passed.
- Disposable recovery, crash boundaries, terminal replay, seal drift, and Bot-construction ordering passed.
- Ruff passed.
- Basedpyright strict errors: `0 errors, 0 warnings`.
- Compileall passed.
- Direct and canonical verification passed.
- Temporary artifacts cleaned.
- Gateway remains running as PID `675692`; no service, live-state, or Telegram action occurred.

Direct recovery argv, after stopping the target gateway:

```bash
/home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent/.venv/bin/python \
  -I -B \
  /home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent/scripts/task22-supplemental-owner-review \
  --recover-exact \
  'task22-terminal-recovery-v1:629525051:987cdde4e245b1d316ab5000271a755db148153b5207156b8082f97c2a1f5c18'
```