I read this as a read-only/offline release gate for message146 - I’ll trace the live inputs, reproduce the complete callback-to-replay path in a disposable copy with HTTP-boundary fixtures, and return one binary verdict with every blocker and proof gap consolidated.


I read this as a continuation of the offline release gate - I’ll finish the source trace, run the real path against an isolated profile/repository copy with only HTTP mocked, then return the strict verdict and evidence.


message: WebSocket error

stop_reason: error


I read this as a release-gate verdict - report the consolidated offline execution, blockers, minimal fixes, and remaining proof gaps.

# BLOCK

Do **not** click Telegram message 146.

## Blockers

1. **Task23 replacement lineage cannot reach draft persistence.**
   - Child lineage is created at `gateway/platforms/task23_coach_schema_repair.py:605-620`.
   - Draft persistence defaults expected lineage to `None` at `gateway/platforms/nutrition_coaching.py:3721-3722`, then rejects the real child lineage at `:3751-3753`.
   - The worker path at `:5027-5037` passes only the claim, not lineage.
   - Proof: valid strict output passed extraction and semantic validation, but child `350b93eb6dae05af` transitioned:
     `generation_pending -> generating -> generation_failed(draft_persistence_failed)`.
     Draft delta was **0**, canonical event delta **0**, delivery delta **0**.
   - Minimal fix: derive and preserve both lineage fields from the validated claimed history when completing an existing generation. Do not weaken lineage validation.

2. **The resulting draft projection would still be malformed after blocker 1 is fixed.**
   - New draft rows at `gateway/platforms/nutrition_coaching.py:5057` omit `parent_draft_id`.
   - The generation reader requires that field for lineage children at `:7902-7905`.
   - Minimal fix: when the completed generation has `lineage_parent_token`, persist that value as the draft’s `parent_draft_id`.

3. **The consume launcher is not replay-safe.**
   - `scripts/task23-coach-schema-repair:536` unconditionally calls `store.preflight()` before branching to consume at `:540`.
   - Once the child exists, preflight reaches `gateway/platforms/task23_coach_schema_repair.py:1291-1307`, which deliberately rejects any child of the terminal parent.
   - Proof: restarted launcher replay returned exit 1, `Task23 compatibility terminal parent is stale`; direct `consume_authorization` replay returned `already_consumed: true` with the original child digest.
   - Minimal fix: handle `consume` before the unconditional current-parent preflight. Let `consume_authorization` validate the journal seal and resume state; retain preflight for publish/preflight/verify commands.

## Consolidated execution evidence

Success-response path, on an initially byte-identical profile copy:

- Real Telegram callback routing recorded `owner_authorized`.
- Consume CAS appended exactly one request and generation child.
- Registry loaded through committed activation journal **version 2**; registry, activation journal/audit and delivery ledger remained byte-identical.
- One mocked provider HTTP response traversed the real OpenAI SDK and Codex adapter:
  - URL: `https://chatgpt.com/backend-api/codex/responses`
  - `text.format.type=json_schema`
  - `strict=true`
  - schema digest `28a712ef...03407b`
  - no unsupported `max_output_tokens`
  - completed terminal metadata and usage were extracted.
- Semantic validation succeeded; failure occurred only at draft persistence.
- Exactly one mocked Owner-DM `sendMessage` occurred, but it ended as a **generation-failed card**, not a draft review card.
- Restart startup recovery made no automatic provider request or new card. Explicit retry made a second provider request and failed identically.
- Customer delivery remained zero throughout.

HTTP-400 matrix:

- Persisted `provider_bad_request`, non-retryable, with redacted request audit.
- Produced no draft or customer delivery.
- Fresh-process recovery made zero provider calls and zero card sends.

## Why earlier audits missed this

- `tests/gateway/test_task23_coach_schema_repair.py:486-494` replays the store directly using a minimal coordinator and stops after child append.
- Worker tests such as `tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py:2392` use root generations whose lineage fields are `None`.
- The launcher test at `tests/gateway/test_task23_coach_schema_repair.py:624-668` checks package binding, not two real consume invocations.
- No prior test chained the Task23 replacement child into the real worker, draft projection, card update, and fresh-process replay.

## Proof gaps requiring a post-fix rerun

Because persistence is blocked, this gate could not prove:

- exactly one durable draft and canonical draft event;
- a final Owner **review** card with created-state controls;
- clean restart behavior from a `draft_created` terminal state.

No live mutation occurred: service PID remained `3395620`, `NRestarts=0`, message 146 stayed published/unconsumed, and all recorded live authority hashes remained unchanged. No provider or live Telegram call was made; networking was namespace-disabled and only HTTP responses were mocked.


I read this as an implementation plus final release gate - I’ll add failing integrated regressions first, make the smallest lineage/launcher fixes, then rerun the offline full-path matrix and validators without touching the live service, provider, Telegram, or message 146.


I read this as implementation plus final release gate - the blockers are fixed and the offline full-path evidence passes.

`SAFE_TO_CLICK_146`

- Success path: exactly 1 draft, 1 canonical event, 1 Owner card, 0 deliveries.
- HTTP 400 path: terminal redacted failure, 0 drafts/events/deliveries.
- Fresh launcher/direct replay: same child, `already_consumed=true`, 0 repeated provider/card effects.
- Validation: 401 related tests passed; Ruff, focused Ty, compile, direct verifier, and offline wheel build passed.
- Nutrition monolith retains the same 799 pre-existing Ty diagnostics before and after; no new Ty diagnostics.
- Live message 146 remains `published`, authorization `null`, child append count 0, delivery count 0.
- Live service remains PID `3395620`, active, `NRestarts=0`.
- No live provider/Telegram call, click, consume, restart, republish, or profile mutation occurred.