I read this as a final read-only Task26 compliance audit of the exact frozen candidate - I’ll trace every objective and historical blocker to repository artifacts, receipts, tests, and offline replay evidence, then return a strict PASS/FAIL/INCONCLUSIVE verdict without making changes.


The evidence topology is now clear: the candidate is a 394-file immutable prefreeze, Phase 2 ran from a byte-identical cleaned copy after deleting the original runtime, and the postfreeze receipt set is separately sealed. I’m now reconciling the ledger’s exact digests and checking the behavioral claims against the bound source rather than accepting receipt labels alone.


I read this as the final Task26 objective/constraint lane verdict - I audited the immutable candidate, sealed receipts, bound source, and ledger line 167 without changes or live actions.

## Bottom line

**PASS - objective/constraint lane only.** Candidate `2a6bf1a844e1110e79bfbc59a92a1b8d7d9acc41f1614c1b2ad8f13906a92622` satisfies every amended Task26 objective and listed historical blocker. This does not complete Task26, authorize Task27, or authorize release/live actions; the other review lanes must independently pass.

## Action plan

1. **Record this lane as PASS.** Independent reconciliation produced 55/55 cryptographic checks passing:
   - Prefreeze seal: `8ceac45a84784679d2fbe9a1ed116f35045b3b282deb485dd623c912ae8ddcaa`
   - Postfreeze receipt seal: `ee6d96fe8c416995bdc1b2c9db93ab514598b72e58f2738d7c68311ba4cd7979`
   - Canonical product binding: `5c74d8596275a17d65816991762c1ba641f3f6c17d2fb340803c2b086654dbad`
   - All 394 prefreeze files and 55 postfreeze files match their sealed hashes, sizes, modes, and inventories; no symlinks or writable entries exist.

2. **Use this objective-to-evidence reconciliation:**

| Objective/blocker | Exact evidence |
|---|---|
| Installed Golden Path, 22 answers, seven clauses | `installed-verifier.json` reports `ACTUAL_INSTALLED_GOLDEN_PATH_PASS`, invocation `b9ad44d5b19f6735b104112841bed494`, seven clauses, chain head `fb23fb6d...`. `01-onboarding_22_clear.json` contains 22 fields, 22 answers, 22 sequential observations, each consumed once with `reask_count=0`. The seven receipt hashes and predecessors recompute correctly. |
| Deterministic clarification objectives | Golden artifact 02 proves stable issue ID, answer/reconciliation binding, field index 21, deterministic repeated compilation, rejection of field-zero revision, and resolution after exact-field revision. Artifacts 03-07 prove preview isolation, projection failure blocking capability issuance, unknown-outcome no-retry, lifecycle success, and forward-only cleanup. Full Gateway includes clarification-policy 14/14 and reconciliation 30/30 (`full-gateway-qualified.log:173-174`). |
| Exactly once | Source and installed bundles each contain exactly one raw customer transport call, one `telegram-customer-surface-receipt-v2`, and one `sent_audited` delivery with consumed capability; duplicate send is rejected. Installed lifecycle hash is `367bc45a...`, transport count is 1, provider message ID is `9001`. |
| Protected controller capability v2 | Bound controller hash `0f7dacb7...`; `dualcoach_tasks21_25_controller.py:736-913` creates the production coordinator with `task26_runtime_required=True`, authorizes `capability_issue`, and emits `draft-delivery-capability-issue-v2`. The installed successful lifecycle records path `dualcoach-controller-protected-v2`. |
| Eager service authority and reconnect authorization | Bound Telegram hash `5e08e9a5...`; `telegram.py:2454-2628` authorizes service activation and arms the watcher before `_connect_network`. Network reconnect and conflict restart reauthorize at lines 1720 and 1849. |
| Live revocation, inbound block, no inotify | `telegram.py:2252-2258` blocks inbound updates after revocation and registers that guard at group `-1000`; fail-closed disconnect is at 2485-2547. The watcher uses `dnotify_signalfd_v1`; `commit_observer.py:26,138,377` reports zero inotify. Source and installed local transcripts report disconnect PASS, zero post-revoke updates, and watcher cleanup. |
| All live advisory calls use `store=False` | The three nutrition advisory call paths explicitly set false at `telegram.py:9307`, `9470`, and `9516`. Tests cover cloud failure/retry behavior, direct completion, and local polish in `test_telegram_nutrition_onboarding.py:38-156`; all are within the 8,514-test qualified Gateway run. |
| Actual local PTB socket transcript | Installed transcript hash `5e994c6f...`: real loopback socket, PTB HTTPX polling, `getMe` and `getUpdates`, 3 connections, 8 requests, `mock_network=false`, `external_traffic=false`, revoke/disconnect PASS, zero post-revoke updates, and closed server/socket. Source transcript independently hashes to `6d94b024...`. |
| Cleaned-bundle standalone replay | Phase 2 copied the exact prefreeze to a private qualified root, removed the original runtime, then ran the independent verifier under `env -i`, hostile CWD, and Python `-I`. `independent.diagnostic.json` returns 0 with `runtime_source="sealed_wheelhouse_only"`; reconstructed copy-seal hash is exactly `de56718d...`. Frozen bootstrap and installed-wheel rehydration also return 0. |
| Final-state v7 and profile 749 | `sealed-expected-state.json` is schema `task26-sealed-final-state-v7`, file hash `7a63af0e...`, document hash `9e6a4656...`. The profile receipt file hashes to `0fcf2708...`, binds profile wheel `a56da241...` and source tree `b34b2a12...`, and records 749 passed. Postfreeze final state is `ACTUAL_INSTALLED_GOLDEN_PATH_PASS`. |
| Canonical direct_url and raw inequality | `direct-url-portable-projection-v2.json` binds Hermes to wheel `27a


type: cancelled

previous_status: running

reason: v33 invalidated: profile receipt is synthetically forgeable and inbound revocation has an ingress TOCTOU race