I read this as an independent read-only F2 privacy/authority audit - I’ll verify the exact candidate and receipt, distinguish active state from protected archives, trace authority and role evidence, and return a strict PASS/FAIL with blockers.


The supplemental receipt is byte-exact and terminally committed. I’m now validating its claims directly against the live profile and the prior F2 failure criteria, rather than relying on the receipt’s self-report.


The live privacy cleanup itself now satisfies the operational-state checks, including archive immutability and active-token isolation. A separate evidence-integrity blocker remains: the Task27 receipt manifest is stale, omits the supplemental chain, and fails its own checksum check; I’m confirming whether any second blocker exists before issuing the lane verdict.


I read this as the final read-only F2 determination - the cleanup state passes, but the stale receipt manifest keeps the lane open.

# F2 verdict: FAIL

**F2 may not be checked.**

## Verified PASS findings

- Candidate: `d1109d8f78aaccf949ec4f664d9e62584c3cca33032030518bc3e2d712239112`
- Supplemental receipt SHA256: `13b28b5745cf1fb6e8aa9457f14ad86dbf972c3c203394e2fd919d99b7bf659d`
- Operation: `005a3c3f9897e2d298a9a7409759509e`
- Receipt status: `COMMITTED`
- Target operational roots:
  - publication outbox: absent
  - staff membership: absent
  - customer bootstrap: absent
  - room bootstrap: absent
- Supplemental archive:
  - manifest: `636acca796ef627cc488c85d5cbc79894eaaa1ee68bbd8660aaf7692d4b9b7e2`
  - outbox digest: `29f118abddb5b569939822b5e29c38830587d762371108dfe2bc661a267bd104`, 8 entries
  - membership digest: `ff57a22a122a083a87020a8802cace1c7ee68eaeaafd90d84a242ab76dfee367`, 3 entries
  - independently reconstructed inventory digests match
  - archive receipt is byte-identical to the submitted receipt
  - archive has zero writable entries and zero symlinks
  - authorization consumption status is `CONSUMED_ON_COMMIT` and exactly matches the embedded receipt object
- Active target scan:
  - zero target customer/session/user values outside the disabled registry, logs/terminal cleanup journal, and defined historical archives
  - the customer key remains only in the terminal canonical cleanup-journal filename outside those roots; its contents contain no target identifier and grant no authority
- Registry SHA256: `dd8520d46770ea512c57864b091bcf6494986bed9c08d9fb89cd05e4569f1e89`
  - customer `enabled=false`
  - AI consent `granted=false`
- No active customer state tree, bootstrap ledger, activation journal/audit, scheduled delivery, draft delivery, or customer service state.
- Config has `adaptive_nutrition.activation=false`, `delivery=false`, and `delivery_enabled=false`. Enabled bootstrap/coaching feature configuration has no matching operational authority graph.
- Service:
  - `ActiveState=inactive`
  - `SubState=dead`
  - `MainPID=0`
  - no matching profile process, FD, or socket
- No active trainer-named path or role-bearing state. Trainer-named paths occur only under rehearsal-reset archive payloads and are historical.
- Legacy `gate_d` artifacts are inert:
  - neither customer exists in the registry
  - neither customer data root exists
  - no matching activation/journal/audit/delivery graph exists
  - legacy authority SHA256: `10463f38e7e1c1977a83bc9a7a3ee0b033053cdacccaa692243f80eb20b2c064`
  - clean checklist: `a9a1a2f90eee8b01757cd875641e00f17fbda7eb74b3270c75e91fed7ebd6e9e`
  - delivery checklist: `e7d0d8c86839197de0a29bdd64e0c88d768f35b9040d108ea3717bbcffe5a21b`
- Wrong-role fail-closed evidence remains intact:
  - exact-candidate initial F2 evidence SHA256: `138806a22606f55c5bea67c46c139ad89605165596886a69e1c27d207672f70c`
  - recorded zero extra customer sends and zero durable mutations for stale/repeat/wrong-role attempts
  - exact-candidate six-lane review SHA256: `b063e92d5c8e60de3067794edd68412c676ebbaf2b0f942793d6ee41dc15ddf6`

## Remaining blocker

`.omo/evidence/task27/receipt-hashes.sha256` is stale:

- manifest SHA256: `6bfe464739fd2651d7acc8554f3db28173a990243ad82cea5381e94d2dc0f9c7`
- it expects controller hash `d57c85640ce8d30a8196b2f75d1d6ff2ed4058687db9376f2e79e43a5212aa29`
- actual controller hash is `8aee38ea920cbaa2b18d7ebe0104aa1baeabcaeb49152f25819ee1380ebbc443`
- `sha256sum -c receipt-hashes.sha256` fails
- it omits the live cleanup receipt and the complete supplemental authorization/preview/controller/receipt chain

This was an explicit blocker in the initial F2 review and remains unresolved. Operational privacy and authority cleanup passes, but evidence-manifest integrity does not; therefore **F2 remains unchecked**.


I read this as a fresh read-only F2 rerun after the manifest repair - I’ll verify all 33 bindings, confirm the supplemental lane receipts and live privacy/authority state remain unchanged, then provide a durable receipt-ready verdict.


I read this as the repaired final F2 decision - all privacy, authority, archive, and manifest checks now pass.

# F2 verdict: PASS

**F2 may be checked. Remaining blockers: none.**

## Receipt-ready evidence

```json
{
  "schema": "task27-final-verification-f2-supplemental-v1",
  "status": "PASS",
  "verdict": "PASS_PRIVACY_AUTHORITY_AND_MANIFEST_INTEGRITY",
  "candidate_digest": "d1109d8f78aaccf949ec4f664d9e62584c3cca33032030518bc3e2d712239112",
  "operation_id": "005a3c3f9897e2d298a9a7409759509e",
  "evidence": {
    "receipt_manifest_sha256": "1bf20114085f086e29691e60318000414c648db169c270808029312c5818aa16",
    "receipt_manifest_entries": 33,
    "receipt_manifest_check": "PASS_ALL_33",
    "supplemental_cleanup_receipt_sha256": "13b28b5745cf1fb6e8aa9457f14ad86dbf972c3c203394e2fd919d99b7bf659d",
    "supplemental_archive_manifest_sha256": "636acca796ef627cc488c85d5cbc79894eaaa1ee68bbd8660aaf7692d4b9b7e2",
    "authorization_consumption_sha256": "8e6b7d0bb30fc891d20b6fdf9a02edaf879546dce8c8328598ab98e9fb689d75",
    "final_supplemental_verification_sha256": "aef6115be0675495b9a39eaa06ed0e89818b38e8ffd14638acb3025aca258185",
    "f1_supplemental_sha256": "2bb6a2485962f0f0904980545375c884aba4561e5dec5db74bbb86532acc55d3",
    "f3_supplemental_sha256": "38ed248cd69e037be71eb3aa0a8f4575e3d760608f5a031490c079747a32a1dd",
    "f4_supplemental_sha256": "e6359443ff0c7905dd44bdad5453ad366d7459eda30642d1153a713d3c0f9109",
    "f5_supplemental_sha256": "55ab5d65a9653db8d2ac19e121038d104218ac21d2df36e1a9d0b5c57f52aedd",
    "registry_sha256": "dd8520d46770ea512c57864b091bcf6494986bed9c08d9fb89cd05e4569f1e89",
    "wrong_role_evidence_sha256": "138806a22606f55c5bea67c46c139ad89605165596886a69e1c27d207672f70c",
    "exact_candidate_six_lane_review_sha256": "b063e92d5c8e60de3067794edd68412c676ebbaf2b0f942793d6ee41dc15ddf6"
  },
  "archive": {
    "outbox_entry_count": 8,
    "outbox_digest": "29f118abddb5b569939822b5e29c38830587d762371108dfe2bc661a267bd104",
    "membership_entry_count": 3,
    "membership_digest": "ff57a22a122a083a87020a8802cace1c7ee68eaeaafd90d84a242ab76dfee367",
    "receipt_archive_byte_equal": true,
    "authorization_consumed": true,
    "root_mode": "0500",
    "file_mode": "0400",
    "writable_entries": 0,
    "symlinks": 0
  },
  "terminal": {
    "outbox_absent": true,
    "membership_absent": true,
    "customer_bootstrap_absent": true,
    "room_bootstrap_absent": true,
    "customer_state_absent": true,
    "customer_enabled": false,
    "customer_consent": false,
    "active_target_matches_outside_allowed_history": 0,
    "activation_authority_absent": true,
    "customer_authority_absent": true,
    "owner_delivery_authority_absent": true,
    "scheduled_delivery_absent": true,
    "active_role_leaks": 0,
    "service": "inactive/dead",
    "service_main_pid": 0
  },
  "false_positive_exclusions": {
    "legacy_gate_d": "Inert migration/checklist evidence: no matching registry entries, customer roots, activation journal, audit, or delivery graph.",
    "trainer_named_paths": "Sixteen paths occur only in rehearsal-reset archive payloads; zero active trainer-named or role-bearing path exists.",
    "historical_archives": "Classified as frozen historical evidence, not active operational state.",
    "cleanup_journal": "Terminal canonical cleanup log, not customer or delivery authority."
  },
  "remaining_blockers": []
}
```

Additional inert legacy hashes:

- Legacy activation authority: `10463f38e7e1c1977a83bc9a7a3ee0b033053cdacccaa692243f80eb20b2c064`
- `gate_d_clean` checklist: `a9a1a2f90eee8b01757cd875641e00f17fbda7eb74b3270c75e91fed7ebd6e9e`
- `gate_d_delivery` checklist: `e7d0d8c86839197de0a29bdd64e0c88d768f35b9040d108ea3717bbcffe5a21b`

The former sole blocker is repaired: `sha256sum -c receipt-hashes.sha256` passed all 33 entries, including both controllers, tests, cleanup chain, supplemental lanes, and final supplemental verification receipt.


I read this as a narrow final confirmation - I’ll check only the refreshed manifest and four supplemental lane bindings, then issue the final F2 verdict.


I read this as the final narrow F2 determination - the refreshed bindings pass.

# Final F2: PASS

- Manifest SHA256: `1bf20114085f086e29691e60318000414c648db169c270808029312c5818aa16`
- Manifest validation: **PASS**, all 33 entries
- F1: `2bb6a2485962f0f0904980545375c884aba4561e5dec5db74bbb86532acc55d3`
- F3: `38ed248cd69e037be71eb3aa0a8f4575e3d760608f5a031490c079747a32a1dd`
- F4: `e6359443ff0c7905dd44bdad5453ad366d7459eda30642d1153a713d3c0f9109`
- F5: `55ab5d65a9653db8d2ac19e121038d104218ac21d2df36e1a9d0b5c57f52aedd`

Operational privacy/authority findings remain PASS. No blockers remain. **F2 may be checked.**