message: Codex error: An error occurred while processing your request. You can retry your request, or contact us through our help center at help.openai.com if the error persists. Please include the request ID 390f002b-28b9-4c22-bc08-5efe81c6b333 in your message.

stop_reason: error


I read this as an independent provenance audit - I’ll inspect the sealed artifacts and derivation tooling, recompute every requested binding/hash, compare predecessor state, and report PASS or FAIL without modifying the worktree.


The target evidence set is present and the worktree is intentionally dirty/unsealed at Git level, so I’m narrowing the audit to the sealed v1.2.0 evidence, its predecessor evidence, and the live-profile invariants recorded around qualification.


Canonical derivation, A/B wheel reproducibility, exact source delta, profile-wheel separation, and sealed Golden Path binding all recompute cleanly. I’m doing the final read-only checks against the actual installed service/profile and completing the full qualification-tool mapping before assigning the verdict.


PASS

Blockers: none.

- Wheel A/B SHA-256: `e3b2003048e8fbf9b3aa9ead9d649398797f22b39a7833190c4fe9691049adf0`; byte-equal.
- Candidate canonical derivation: `102cbbb26baa6ad1b3876353a36d474c145bbc040db0739cc507608a7b5d4635`.
- Canonical binding SHA-256: `66df85533434f4ad93a183637cc444947d59aa89c2db4cf17894d8a0def370ae`.
- Binding document SHA-256: `02c10c2bfbe5628563c264b74f6c50182cb679f4b5dd74940fe3a014f345041c`.
- Profile wheel: `27f7427199d4a0a2e8a08aba26431552655f615544be0f13741e88b4b7f2250a`; distinct package and bytes from Hermes wheel.
- Predecessor candidate: `4efceab409e16ad38740a0faaa5a899e0630991b862e2592a5e2d5c9e825820d`; predecessor wheel `8e99762ee3ce53e43f086d3bfb99edc3246f8f990b3da8e53f6e6aef3181a91e`.

Source delta exactly matches wheel-to-wheel comparison:

- Added:
  - ack: `823308a6f4f458b297bddce21ed00b9bcaed6cc44cd648b0ada4e313f361b9d9`
  - ack model: `aa5b8aa48a56e17faa640c19db7715eb8ecc22c594738161103014c6edc231a0`
  - recovery: `27bc6bc9c85c99338cfa0d71ccd63e9e2f81c7231c241e21dd91e01a36eb5325`
- Changed:
  - Telegram: `d2ad4328f312034f12e8025a44c61e6a0ff879dd5822f42e8b73d15cd2dcf3fa` -> `19bee81c11c14523a4d34342159aa5eadd5782e2daf7ac86f264b5c9e9ba4eef`
  - Runtime: `4e8f3b727b42136f9f96936304a6628236cd3f516bee8b187a1b312ba9113d67` -> `be64da21fd08d23ac8e102d74045f0be3e96f43f2e90098976532c994f5bcd60`
  - Callback: `26e51ce5030e50d89b5f4af4642aa4d84b3d1bb53c97137afd26d80633274861` -> `d021410c1cdc2897829c07dcadf36543b980586306ed2a815cc412ca7724b7db`
  - Publication: `09ac4c94a81135903b5e2439af59a3065bb5f8afed64cf4a1f110256ee36140f` -> `c7d17677f75d58ffc006976e67b3821d89fb41f4a44fec4fca4502f9ddf30a38`
- Removed: none.

Installed A/B independently recomputed and identical for all seven declared files, with the target hashes above.

Qualification tool hashes all matched:

- candidate authority `faec2e5616e399f02df82ce5e12d8d94ca79cbe3eb9d8a96446f673866eca431`
- candidate derivation `cce86510481bd6918e86e1d580a80ea5d4f6a0362a3dbfe02110a47d79a6cdb8`
- commit observer `a0dfca77dadc4cfc80946f27ebe344f22559410edaa7fb843a779796701826cc`
- delivered sealer `6d2ae683562ce61e3cb2a22d4e97f776d9d1cd43b68b713fbfb3be02e9fcf986`
- controller `0f7dacb7184035630f9313da73d72a68416dff4e1d8c3f476886c7ae789bd26a`
- evidence contract `1ecb5d824507f9ea57e4646bb418ebd5750e79244748d298598890a456e8d9c3`
- final state `8b9d988d28b86df48269910c8343f6a07b9f7b2756f8ec023a05d00e975d1caa`
- frozen bootstrap `4017e046815ffb6c354d921e7a24e2de82f41955f01b98531ed80fd9236612f5`
- independent verifier `40bf1f53e6cc11f546481e639baaba92cc97cd0e28e9302d59ba2b9dbe8cc454`
- installed provenance `ada06a424325e2f1ae19f45d6fafba655ae85735987b760816fc9beef03ae7ae`
- local Telegram QA `2af9cbab2e90b8ab2144c5853059d7e881075c52cbca8725906a0afe269ebfd4`
- runtime authority `bdda6013d1f1ca9c6b192323bd3c4ffd0fa36119af155e4938ddaeae6374214e`
- source Golden Path `c7bd689372d11fd6b2082105d8ba803ea81958d24f420e70c06164417a4dddc2`
- Telegram adapter `19bee81c11c14523a4d34342159aa5eadd5782e2daf7ac86f264b5c9e9ba4eef`
- ty runner `5219060e85ab40391fe674a6ccb5f9c34769f33a5f089f3e83f57d229d738090`
- ty surface gate `856727e10c80599bd05de913194cc8c7f215f325dd75aa573493359313c283d7`
- ty wheel builder `5cb2f50db314248d1009bb002532085450adc95bf2d32678d9d4d9445b360e40`
- Golden Path verifier `6f43a1792d18f8b3d0213a899695bb36c91bb0d88b0f0ee6bf19477308f3fad4`

Golden-path-sealed binding document `3cd7121440ac367e1805f0b6a1c9745d68cab2da8def04f6ad047d03e883fbcd` binds the exact candidate, Hermes wheel, and profile wheel; PASS document is `423b0a945a73ecb5ab748c7c796af9328a4639bf6921af982e71ad00924f46e9`.

No live mutation: the active service remains candidate `4efceab4`, target runtime `102cbbb2-v120` is absent, and live unit/drop-in hashes exactly match predecessor:

- unit `2f27098924181f9071b28b514535a5b2ae86166b705cad920bf6fb7db6d985c1`
- drop-in `618eab1ec39856c23f44a9b4b3834b5640cbccdee279eaa35fb85ef608048ae6`
- live logical binding `bae83f96d367a351ecf15654740c14f17bbb0a9ddc98ba57c358e5cc71efa66b`

No files were edited.


I read this as a final audit verdict - I’ll summarize the strongest completed checks without further commands.

PASS

- A/B wheels are byte-identical: `e3b2003048e8fbf9b3aa9ead9d649398797f22b39a7833190c4fe9691049adf0`.
- Canonical candidate derivation recomputed exactly: `102cbbb26baa6ad1b3876353a36d474c145bbc040db0739cc507608a7b5d4635`.
- Canonical binding recomputed exactly: `66df85533434f4ad93a183637cc444947d59aa89c2db4cf17894d8a0def370ae`.
- Profile wheel is separate: `27f7427199d4a0a2e8a08aba26431552655f615544be0f13741e88b4b7f2250a`.
- Source delta exactly matches predecessor `4efceab409e16ad38740a0faaa5a899e0630991b862e2592a5e2d5c9e825820d`: 3 additions, 4 changes, no removals.
- Every declared qualification-tool hash matched an actual tool.
- All declared installed A/B source hashes recomputed successfully and matched each other.
- Sealed Golden Path binds the exact candidate and wheel hashes; binding document hash: `3cd7121440ac367e1805f0b6a1c9745d68cab2da8def04f6ad047d03e883fbcd`.
- No live mutation: service remained on predecessor `4efceab4`; target runtime was absent, and live unit/drop-in matched predecessor hashes.

Blockers: none. No files were edited.


I read this as a focused final-candidate provenance check - I’ll recompute only the stated A/B wheel, canonical binding, and golden-path-release linkage, then return a concise verdict.


PASS

- Candidate derivation: `9208d72c8386b78eaf633f60038732fe4a76d0f907df8c2972793b4b1f97a555`
- Wheel A/B: `71005e867aea668b609e7c46a5c27e690a69029afe8bb70d3c480f80e93c34d3`, byte-identical
- Internal binding: `18aa42accd351efd117861f0e8258fdbaa1ff6e861620ce1502a118980239f52`
- `golden-path-release` binds the exact candidate and wheel; status `PASS`
- Golden-path binding document: `121ee9125ac743f3aa823fdf46e35d5c3aa0ac3afc679890948a208cfa645cbf`

Blockers: none.


I read this as the final focused provenance verdict - I’ll recompute the stated A/B wheel, internal binding, and golden-path-final-release linkage only.


PASS

- Candidate: `e06a4e8a648add26ea4e239fa66c8bfd84ebb249db510679f252f9fb97da2fc6`
- Wheel A/B: `ea618eafade3eca311932a5228cc31c6dd1ed982cc7f2f9de9ad1bffdefc1db9`, byte-identical
- Internal binding: `0246ff913b944185216d3d30e17d6aea5f383592f7f5f60e6bf785916c37f905`
- `golden-path-final-release` binds the exact candidate and wheel; status `PASS`
- Golden-path binding document: `658d44230601f47ac9ca358237f9f3a0dc4ee0997a0eb4f31516117d651626cb`

Blockers: none.