I read this as an independent adversarial verification of Todo 1 - I’ll inspect every authority and receipt, reproduce all builds/tests/tamper cases, preserve protected state, and return only the required verdict object.


I’ve completed the provenance audit. The split is explicit and the profile snapshot is exact, but the verifier’s Hermes side currently validates only the 48 reconstructed delta paths rather than an exact full build-input inventory; I’m now testing whether that gap permits undeclared build bytes and independently reproducing every required output and failure mode.


The independent runs reproduced both intended wheel hashes twice, the target-only profile hash, and exactly 87 tests. The decisive failure is adversarial: the verifier accepted an empty Hermes manifest and still printed `TASK_1_PRODUCT_PASS`; it also let tampering of an undeclared packaged Hermes file proceed through both builds. That makes the current PASS receipt non-transparent and non-candidate-bound despite correct current outputs.


verdict: false-positive

split_source: Two explicit authorities exist with no temporal substitution: 48-file v1.3.3 source/test lineage and exact 56-file v1.3.2 profile snapshot.

fresh_builds: Two runs reproduced Hermes cf4ccf4872ecd064c9878a11f5e2389262a7e05d561a3df6c004efff3b393f92 and profile a099b3e1da62d8291fb3442de64e9de9b12e6f67aa63fa8fdf62abccbcabfa29.

direct_target_profile: 09c5bbde703dde7454a1b844397e661717c805c8d050886a2d924f7731d25a30; correctly distinct from the sealed profile.

focused_tests: Exactly 87 passed under Python SHA d9bc96d1ad0161db7ebdc8fdbc690530a9c29299feb2001cba6b29072e2a9051.

blocking_failure: verify-task-1-product.sh accepts an empty Hermes manifest and still exits 0 with TASK_1_PRODUCT_PASS. It does not pin the manifest, base HEAD, or complete Hermes build-input inventory.

undeclared_tamper: Tampering undeclared packaged input agent/__init__.py was detected only after both wheels built, violating fail-before-build.

erratum: The claimed erratum SHA has no declared or independently discoverable artifact path.

command: printf '{"file_count":0,"files":[]}\n' >/tmp/empty.json; E=.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v140-weekly-operations; UV_OFFLINE=1 $E/verify-task-1-product.sh . $E/task-1-product-inputs/profile-v132 /tmp/empty.json $E/task-1-profile-v132-source-authority.json /tmp/task1-empty

expected: Nonzero before build because Hermes authority is absent.

actual: Exit 0 and TASK_1_PRODUCT_PASS after both builds.

stale_state: FAIL

dirty_worktree: PASS

generated_artifacts: PASS

misleading_success_output: FAIL

flaky_tests: PASS

long_commands: PASS

repeated_interruption_or_tamper: PASS

malformed_input: FAIL

prompt_injection: NOT_APPLICABLE: no model boundary

cancel_resume: PASS

status: PASS

risks: Todo 2 remains blocked because Todo 1 is not candidate-bound at the Hermes input boundary.

risks: Correct wheel hashes do not compensate for missing pre-build source authority.

risks: The erratum is not independently reviewable without an immutable artifact path.