I read this as an independent adversarial verification of Todo 5 r2 only - I will inspect the sealed authority, reproduce the named cases, run scoped validation, and append evidence without changing product code.


I read this as Todo 5 r2 adversarial verification - I completed the audit and recorded a FAIL verdict.

- Evidence: `task-5-reminder-independent-verification-r2.json` plus cleanup receipt.
- Confirmed: known-failure terminality and stale registry/config/route/canonical pins fail closed; 1022 profile and candidate-bound 112 gateway tests passed.
- Blocker: substituting `profile_root` constructs a different ledger path and sends once.
- Blocker: replacing raw route after reservation sends once to `unauthorized-chat/unauthorized-topic`.
- Blocker: no production `weekly_reminder_gateway_authority` owner exists; the adapter falls back without a bound authority.
- Full manifest LSP/type/no-excuse/LOC gates are not clean for modified monolith paths.

No product, tests, configuration, plan, ledger, service, or live/network state was changed.