I read this as a read-only release authority review - I’ll trace every named invariant, run isolated static/targeted verification plus a disposable lifecycle, and return PASS only if no blocker remains.


The implementation surfaces are now mapped. I’m moving from contract discovery to authority tracing: migration/receipt state transitions, coordinator reload checks, and Channel Inbox ingress/egress isolation.


Authority tracing found the intended fail-closed boundaries in place, including candidate revalidation on initial configure and reload, and explicit console selection when more than one route is enabled. I’m now executing isolated verification and a separate lifecycle probe; no repository or live-state mutation is involved.


I read this as a final release verdict - I completed the authority review and am returning all blockers together.

**BLOCKED**

1. `tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py:18-25` hard-codes and prepends the live profile path `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/workspace/checkin_cli`. This violates test isolation and causes candidate tests to use stale live classes. Three targeted tests failed with `CustomerRegistry` missing `admission_policy`, including explicit multi-customer console selection and route isolation. On systems without that live path, collection can fail outright.

Verification completed:

- 32 focused profile tests passed.
- 35 gateway/Channel Inbox tests passed; 3 failed due to the blocker above.
- Disposable two-customer lifecycle passed.
- Ruff, ty, in-memory compilation, and LSP diagnostics passed.
- No source, service, Telegram, network, watcher, git, or live-state changes were made.


I read this as a final re-review after the isolation fix - I’ll verify the current test import boundary, run the mixed gateway set in both orders, repeat all prior static/profile/lifecycle gates, and check for live-path or module-cache contamination.


The fix points to the worktree-local profile and contains no live profile literal. I’m now exercising the prior mixed set in fresh interpreters in both collection orders, with post-run assertions that every loaded `checkin_cli` module resolves inside this worktree and no live profile path entered `sys.path`.


Both collection orders now use the local package, but the mixed gate still has three deterministic failures: its `_registry` fixture includes the removed `trainer` field, which the current strict `CustomerSpec` rejects. I’m completing the remaining gates to ensure there are no additional blockers before the verdict.


I read this as the final release verdict - current bytes remain blocked by one deterministic test incompatibility.

**BLOCKED**

1. `tests/gateway/test_nutrition_coaching.py:64` still adds a `trainer` field to `_registry()`. Current `CustomerSpec` uses `extra="forbid"`, so both test orders fail:
   - `test_multiple_enabled_customers_require_explicit_console_selection`
   - `test_customer_route_requires_exact_submitter_chat_and_topic`
   - `test_trainer_route_is_exactly_isolated_from_customer_and_reserved_spaces`

Both orders: **35 passed, 3 failed**.

Other gates passed:

- No live profile path in `sys.path`.
- All loaded `checkin_cli` modules resolved within this worktree.
- Both-order collection/cache-origin audit passed.
- 35 profile/authority tests passed.
- Disposable two-customer lifecycle passed.
- Ruff, ty, and in-memory compilation passed.
- No source, live-state, network, service, Telegram, git, or watcher changes made.


I read this as an interim source-authority checkpoint - I’ll verify the zero-gate/class-identity repairs on the v1.1 feature worktree, rerun only applicable feature gates, and record exact source hashes for comparison with the forthcoming v1.4 forward-port evidence.


The applicable v1.1 feature gates are clean in both orders with exclusively worktree-local module origins. I’ve recorded the 22-file authority source set and am finishing static plus disposable authority checks before freezing this interim checkpoint; no final release verdict will be issued until the v1.4 forward-port digest is available.


I read this as an interim authority checkpoint - current v1.1 feature source is clean, but final PASS remains deferred to the identical v1.4 forward-port evidence.

**Current source authority: CLEAN**

- Applicable gateway tests: 34 passed in both orders.
- Profile/authority tests: 35 passed.
- Module-origin audits: worktree-local only; no live path or cache pollution.
- Disposable multi-customer lifecycle: PASS.
- Ruff, ty, compilation, and LSP gates: PASS.
- Inherited v1.4 trainer tests were not required.

**Authority source-set checkpoint**

- SHA-256: `0330d772ee305f6e430ea8a79c640e527a5f6226dc39617e3eb73b1c17a954a1`
- Files: 22
- Bytes: 2,164,724

Key source hashes:

```text
customer_coaching.py                     e77805a81e557bf61e438d9382582811aa57e5d6817ee3bd089a90389fb11ad1
customer_admin.py                        f8b4cf84dd4f354b2e15804539a1a5411b186c77a6575672e33a6cff52f9c906
multi_customer_admission_migration.py    2a0975d2b47d8bd13152338bde18b8bff2dc63076d16d17f7a2b3b3c61e87b8d
channel_inbox_migration.py               686039bb10a15e0014cec9fc89f376b79b6a96160ad1bbd6b88d4b396a098a23
operator_console.py                      209a9bfb8906cc5a55cbf05c4e8f9734ffdfe8c088bf3ea640fa46d2385787ed
nutrition_coaching.py                    58b447519a465680661cad8804587478d4f81a525c6beeb8a92ef96d596f0342
telegram.py                              7bf64b5e21284b67b1062fd4e55640fbc490d9080a6a024bdb85a80d5b0fddff
telegram_channel_inbox.py                9595fb509000df8aa25d51f0765c88f9023f9ec9dc5dbe790be548352e3f3a68
telegram_channel_inbox_config.py         894247d47ff96cba8af65528762211f9dda4ab6deaeb9d89ce289b513d518ca7
```

Final verdict awaits the v1.4 forward-port digest and evidence.


I read this as the final evidence-bound release verdict - I’ll inspect only the supplied evidence tree, verify both declared digests and the prior source-set binding, then validate privacy/authority results, source stability, sandbox removal, and live immutability before returning PASS or all blockers.


Both supplied digests and every file covered by the evidence manifest verify exactly. Initial/final snapshots and all six phase pairs are byte-stable; I’m completing the final semantic check by mapping the passing logs to each required privacy/authority invariant and validating that the v1.4 merge preserved the checkpointed feature inputs.


I read this as the final evidence-bound release verdict - all supplied digests, authority invariants, source bindings, stability, cleanup, and immutability evidence verified.

**PASS**


I read this as a deferred bounded delta audit - I’ll review the fresh v14 evidence once its path and digests are provided.


I read this as a deferred final v15 evidence audit - I’ll verify the supplied bindings, formatting-only delta, gates, hashes, cleanup, and live immutability once the evidence arrives.


I read this as a deferred final v16 evidence audit - I’ll wait for the artifact path and digests before reviewing or issuing a verdict.


I read this as the final v16 evidence-bound verdict - I’ll inspect only the supplied artifact, independently verify all three digests and source binding, then audit authority/privacy, delta gates, behavior counts, cleanup, and live immutability.


I read this as the final v16 evidence verdict - all requested bindings, gates, behavior, cleanup, and immutability checks passed.

**PASS**


I read this as a deferred final v17 evidence audit - I’ll wait for the artifact path and digests before reviewing or issuing a verdict.


I read this as the final v17 evidence-bound verdict - I’ll inspect only the supplied artifact, verify all three digests, reconcile every duplicate zero-gate authority receipt, and validate authority/privacy, full gates, cleanup, and live immutability.


All declared hashes and 132 manifest entries verify. The duplicate based-added receipts unanimously report zero, and the canonical summary matches qualification content; I’m completing independent byte comparisons, tested-source binding, behavior-log inspection, and immutability checks.


Behavior, duplicate-receipt consistency, zero/format gates, and immutability are clean. The v17 bundle omits a full ported-tree manifest, so I’m completing the source binding through its exact source-set, merge “theirs” inputs, patch-tree manifest, sandbox diff, and stable phase hashes rather than relying on an absent artifact.


I read this as the final v17 evidence verdict - all authority, privacy, consistency, gate, hash, cleanup, and immutability checks passed.

**PASS**