I read this as an independent, non-live v1.5 transaction rehearsal - I’ll obtain the frozen preseal, clone the exact live snapshot into disposable roots, run two full successes plus rollback/security/drift cases, and stop as soon as every case passes with cleanup proof or one exact blocker is evidenced.


The repository is a document/evidence workspace rather than a Git root, and the machine contains many stale task26 artifacts; I’m narrowing by the v1.5 plan and freshest controller outputs so only the lead’s frozen inputs can qualify.


Blocked pending the lead’s frozen controller preseal path/hash. No live state, service, profile, approval, network, or candidate wheels were touched.


I read this as authorization to execute the sealed transaction only in disposable clones - I’ll bind inputs to the supplied hashes, run both success transactions and all negative matrices, remove every clone/cache, and stop when the evidence root proves all PASS with live-state invariance or exposes one exact blocker.


The frozen controller itself is only the transactional guard; its shipped test host does not perform wheel installation or real migration logic, so I’m locating the sealed concrete disposable host before claiming “full operation” rather than mistaking unit stubs for the requested rehearsal.


I found the correct precedent: v1.4 v7 used the real production business operations with only systemd isolated. I’m applying the same boundary to the frozen v1.5 controller: real wheel install/import/migration and byte writes occur inside hard-link-safe disposable clones, while stop/reload/start are deterministic isolated service transitions.


The harness is now strict-type clean and pre-execution compilation passes. I’m starting the single traced run that generates both success receipts and every negative case; no live service command exists in the harness, and all candidate subprocesses are forced `--no-index` with provider/network proxies blocked.


Rehearsal matrix is running under `strace`; awaiting its completion event.


I read this as a failed rehearsal requiring diagnosis, not a stop signal - I’ll inspect the generated receipts, fix only the disposable harness defect, rerun from clean roots, and stop when the complete evidence is PASS or the raw failure proves a sealed-controller blocker.


All transactional cases actually passed; the aggregate failed for two evidence-layer reasons: the preseal verifier emits JSON containing `status`, not a bare token, and the broad all-profiles digest changed while the live service stayed active. I’m correcting the parser and adding exact changed-path attribution so independent live activity cannot be confused with harness writes.


Corrected traced rerun is active; awaiting completion.


I read this as the corrected run still finding one aggregate failure - I’ll inspect the attributed live-drift paths and either exclude only demonstrably independent volatile activity with stronger critical-state proof or return the exact blocker immediately.


The only drift is `dualcoachtest/logs/agent.log` and `logs/errors.log` from the still-running live Gateway; every non-log stable path, unit/drop-in contract, service PID/start identity, and every transaction case is clean. I’m making that distinction explicit and adding critical registry/config/runtime-RECORD hashes before the final rerun.


Final attributed traced rerun is active; awaiting completion.


I read this as the full matrix now passing - I’ll finalize the network proof, validate evidence/hash/static gates, confirm zero clone/cache residue and live invariance, report exact receipts to the lead, then stop.


The only remaining gate is Ruff’s E402 caused by self-bootstrapping the frozen worktree path. I’m removing that ordering smell without ignores: the host will dynamically load only the runtime exception and expose a structural binding protocol, while the runner imports all typed symbols before declaring constants.


The cleanup audit found only Ruff’s own cache plus the now-unneeded rehearsal source. I’m removing both: the durable deliverable will contain only immutable receipts, their checksum, raw network trace, network proof, and a concise final verification summary.


PASS reported to lead.

- Two full-operation receipts: PASS
- Rollback boundaries: 11/11 PASS
- Approval/tamper cases: 11/11 PASS
- Current-state drift: PASS
- Network/provider calls: 0
- Live approval: unconsumed
- Cleanup: 5 evidence files, zero clone/cache directories
- Evidence SHA-256: `5f4c9d37e9a57b6ae1960f1e49c2c4f873b3921a015adb0a0b4d4153319925f8`


I read this as a replacement v2 rehearsal against the corrected concrete executor - I’ll discard the v1 harness assumptions, exercise `execute_nutricoach_v150_sealed_live.py` through exact target-bound disposable clones, and stop when every requested v2 success/security/rollback/network/cleanup gate passes or one raw blocker is proven.


The corrected concrete host has a potentially fatal live-target mismatch: before any migration it requires the literal bytes `channel_inbox: false`, while the current sealed live `config.yaml` does not contain that field. I’m running the exact concrete controller on a target-remapped clone with the real current runtime and exact wheels to determine whether this is the required raw blocker.


The concrete probe found an even earlier sealed blocker: installation copies the read-only current runtime, then failure rollback calls plain `shutil.rmtree`; removal raises `PermissionError`, masks the install exception, leaves the successor tree, and leaves the isolated service stopped. I’m preserving that raw failure and force-cleaning only the disposable clone for a truthful blocker receipt.


BLOCKED and reported to lead.

Concrete v2 rollback fails with `PermissionError` while removing the copied read-only successor runtime, leaving the disposable successor present and service stopped. Live state and approval remained untouched.

Evidence SHA-256: `8a3a05acb12ff05d09628a8cf02b6326b38cdcb15828b1fd2194a796aa4c044c`


I read this as a hold directive - I’ll preserve the accepted v2 blocker, perform no further clone or v2 execution, and wait for the immutable v3 package/seal before starting the expanded v3 matrix.


Holding. No v2 rerun, clone creation, or live changes performed.


I read this as the complete frozen v3 closure rehearsal - I’ll verify the supplied seal first, use its own concrete rehearsal/recovery surfaces against two unrelated absolute roots, execute every listed success/fault/replay/privacy/cleanup gate, and stop immediately on the first raw blocker or return the immutable PASS receipt hashes.


The v3 closure now fixes both v2 blockers: successor normalization/removal is explicit and Inbox omission is OFF. I found no packaged full-matrix runner, so I’m building a disposable evidence driver that calls only the sealed controller/host/recovery APIs and records their real outputs; production sources remain untouched.


The sealed verifier and live invariants pass. I’m starting the traced closure run now: both exact-wheel successes execute first, so any remaining target-shape blocker stops before the 66-case and durability matrices can be misreported.


The first run stopped before controller execution because `/tmp` is a different filesystem and the clone helper attempted hard links. That is a rehearsal-driver issue, not a sealed v3 blocker; I’m switching to link-or-copy fallback so the first root remains genuinely unrelated while preserving exact bytes.


`/tmp` cannot hold an exact 1.6 GB profile clone; the second attempt failed during clone materialization before controller entry. I’m cleaning those owned partial roots and moving both unrelated absolute roots onto the capacity-bearing filesystem (`/home/cube/...` and `/home/cube/.local/share/...`), where link-based exact clones remain independent paths.


The controller paths passed through both successes and the 66-case stage matrix; the driver then failed because it had not created the replay parent directory. I’m fixing that evidence-driver omission (and the analogous signal parent) and rerunning from freshly cleaned roots; no v3 receipt is being claimed from the partial pass.


The full v3 run exited 0. I’m finalizing the trace with the correct distinction: the intentional Bubblewrap probe must produce one failed `AF_INET` attempt (`ENETUNREACH`), while successful external connects must remain zero.


I read this as a cleanup-proof correction - I’ll preserve only the matrix receipt, checksum, and network trace, remove all driver/cache residue, then add a separate durable cleanup receipt containing the final inventory and retained-file hashes.


The cleanup correction is now durable and independently verified: exactly four evidence files, zero directories, matrix receipt hash unchanged, cleanup receipt PASS. I’m closing the tracked v3 phases against those receipts and handing the final hashes to the lead.


V3 rehearsal final PASS.

- Matrix receipt: `babdc8d39d54e74a4bf271881f365a7eff990ad408bca602b20c285aac0cbba9`
- Cleanup receipt: `45c9231adb75b872718349a4883313c4de5145066888fba7ae0c42243d2f5f41`
- Network trace: `26d7a680e59bf92610173593a44b277026692ee0d1ec76ffd860d8060f37c4c2`
- Stage/BaseException matrix: 66/66 PASS
- Successful external connects: 0
- Final residue: four evidence files, zero directories
- Live target unchanged; real V3 ledger absent.


I read this as a fresh V4 successor rehearsal - I’ll verify the frozen network-gate seal, build a disposable evidence harness around its actual closure, execute every requested gate/matrix without touching live approval or controller state, then retain only immutable V4 evidence.


The V4 verifier is an actual PASS with the requested closure. The seal explicitly supersedes `3fba…`, and both V4 live ledger and execution root are absent. I’m now binding the disposable controller semantics to V4 while using the sealed test-support primitives for exact clone and rollback checks.


The frozen closure contains a sealed-controller blocker before any success matrix can be honest: V4’s worker imports a controller whose approval is still `DISPOSABLE_V3` and whose sealed target is still `live-transaction-preseal-v3`. I’m executing only the safe network-gate probes now, then I’ll seal the blocker evidence and stop rather than fabricate V4 clone successes by monkeypatching the controller.


The safe probes confirm the intended gate itself works (`BWRAP_NETWORK_ISOLATED`, direct host `DENY`, zero successful external connects), but the unmodified sealed controller rejects the V4 approval as `wrong_approval`. I’m sealing that first blocker with exact source hashes and unchanged-live evidence; all mutation matrices remain intentionally unrun.


V4 stopped at the first sealed blocker.

- Network gate works:
  - Bwrap: `BWRAP_NETWORK_ISOLATED`
  - Direct host: `DENY:network_namespace`
  - Successful external connects: `0`
- Blocker: sealed controller remains bound to `DISPOSABLE_V3` and `live-transaction-preseal-v3`.
- Unmodified V4 approval result: `wrong_approval`
- No clone/fault/replay matrices were run.
- Live PID/start/hashes unchanged; V4 ledger and execution absent.
- Blocker receipt: `9429231b07dba4a44bf58e9435859e4231ee9455e86fbf2ae7143c3ae9f4a27d`
- Cleanup receipt: `3745c9808143977f9c3255ed65d1a9a954538f2c440af8e8e03cd57e9d06498a`
- Network trace: `02110d0862b480a24ed27e3cdaf8d0adcc81d14986bf0ad17e84c205ee6862b8`


I read this as a second independent blocker audit - I’ll run the complete V4 bootstrap-to-worker chain inside a fully read-only Bubblewrap namespace, so it can confirm whether any hidden derivation rebinding exists without exposing live writable paths.


Independent full-chain audit sealed:

- Actual read-only Bwrap chain reaches controller and fails `wrong_approval`.
- Confirms no hidden V4 rebinding exists.
- Audit receipt: `6f5e590b8b2701b346946cb61fcaa11251cc2f476e918e43ffe162bccb0b8fec`
- Cleanup receipt: `abb26ca5eba8b3e7d1d97a4d2bfd5eb22da411811c0aac9da6016499859daef4`
- Trace: `ddf1f895e23ef065f7d2c44001e8e6eda3cb120364a3b54a1cb764073136ddaf`
- Live remains untouched; V4 ledger/execution remain absent.


I read this as the third blocked-audit turn - I’ll revalidate the frozen controller binding and immutable evidence against current disk state, confirm no resumption channel exists, then formally block the goal if the same sealed mismatch persists.


Goal formally blocked after three independent audits.

The frozen V4 controller remains V3-bound and rejects V4 authorization with `wrong_approval`. Producing success matrices would require altering or monkeypatching the sealed closure.

Live remains untouched; V4 ledger and execution remain absent.


I read this as a hold directive - I’ll preserve V4 evidence unchanged and await the V5 bound-controller seal.

No V4 reruns or fabricated matrices. Same rehearsal role retained.


I read this as a fresh V5 implementation rehearsal - I’ll validate the bound seal, then run its unmodified bootstrap/worker/controller inside disposable absolute-path overlays, including an isolated systemd-shaped command surface, before expanding to the requested success and failure matrices.


V5’s controller is genuinely target-derived while its disposable approval remains test-only, matching the seal. I’m building the rehearsal adapter now: cloned live bytes at the exact absolute paths, clone-local V5 ledger/execution trees, and a bind-mounted systemctl state machine so the unmodified controller cannot reach host systemd.


The overlay adapter is in place. I’m starting the first real full-chain clone now; while the exact profile copy and offline wheel install run, I’ll build the independent fault/replay evidence path rather than wait idly.


The V5 authority binding reached the transaction and stopped at snapshot safety, not at approval. I’m treating this as a runtime failure: distinguish clone-induced hardlinks from a genuine sealed live blocker, repair only the disposable clone strategy if the live predecessor itself is safe, then rerun fresh because this clone’s authorization is already consumed.


The clone run exposed a real sealed blocker, not a clone artifact: the V5 protected inventory includes 26,960 live files whose current `st_nlink` is greater than 1, while sealed `capture()` rejects every source unless `st_nlink == 1`. Normalizing clone links would hide a failure the exact live predecessor will hit, so I’m stopping matrices and sealing this raw blocker after one read-only live-path capture probe.


V5 stopped at the first raw sealed blocker.

- V5 authority binding succeeded through transaction entry.
- Failure: `AuthorityError: unsafe_snapshot_source`
- Cause: protected inventory contains 26,960 live files with `st_nlink != 1`; sealed capture requires exactly one link.
- Clone authority consumed `FAILED`; phase recovered `ROLLED_BACK`.
- No success/fault/replay matrices fabricated.
- Blocker receipt: `e326d0acb1f40b3b36497125adfeabec4f1703ba7bd19e1454964e8f40e70eb2`
- Cleanup receipt: `543d8936a0d2dba7a1d2e12ca3053f1d496cb6430e2e7498e73f728ff9dc2ce8`
- Trace: `eb91aa88928433fc2ea09fa81a1f73689f3e905094bbbc931af1d3202c046d15`
- Live remained untouched; V5 live ledger/execution remain absent.


I read this as a hold instruction - preserve the five V5 evidence files, never rerun or authorize V5, and remain ready in the same rehearsal role for V6.

V5 is frozen as blocked and non-authorizable. No further action taken.


I read this as an exact V6 disposable rehearsal - verify the frozen seal, run the unmodified bound-controller transaction and all requested matrices through fresh absolute-path overlays, then preserve only immutable evidence or stop at the first raw blocker.


The first V6 chain stopped before authorization reservation with `service_state_drift`. This is a rehearsal-driver mismatch: I offset the clone’s simulated PID/start even though the sealed package binds the exact live predecessor identity. The clone ledger and execution are still absent, so I’m correcting the shim to the exact frozen PID/start and rerunning the same unused clone; this is not yet a sealed-controller blocker.


The corrected chain reached the transaction and failed at the real offline wheel install. I’m treating this as the candidate first blocker until one bounded probe distinguishes a sealed sandbox defect from a clone defect: the same frozen install command will run in the unused second overlay with stderr exposed, then its partial successor will be removed without consuming V6 authority.


The probe confirms a genuine frozen V6 sandbox blocker: exact `uv --no-cache ... --offline` exits 2 because Bubblewrap leaves `/tmp` read-only (`Read-only file system ... /tmp/.tmpE0zy0y`). Rollback then also cannot remove the partial venv because `make_writable()` follows `venv/bin/python` into the read-only root. I’m stopping V6 here, preserving the consumed-failed transaction and raw trace, and cleaning only disposable overlays.


V6 stopped at the first sealed blocker.

- Exact offline install failed: read-only `/tmp/.tmpE0zy0y`.
- Rollback also failed to remove the partial venv because chmod followed `venv/bin/python` into the read-only root.
- Clone authorization consumed `FAILED`; no full success claimed.
- Blocker receipt: `22ffce99e7f27b07083af6943fb1ee83ae05a7aa17fe129e706086e36fc7c25e`
- Cleanup receipt: `8ac13d4a7ad836fe6f36101d0acb811d7b20d811bcc86b9b23488288db4debbd`
- Raw probe: `dc0dc7fd2637c1abea0535137cd1823c69c7c11b24f2453e83197c316ad5e5e0`
- Trace: `a828e39c0d6b765a507dd9de39aefb038c65c28918abe32f508b7d5e402194c4`

Live state and V3/V4/V5 evidence remain unchanged.


I read this as a hold instruction - preserve all six V6 evidence files, never rerun or authorize V6, and remain ready in the same rehearsal role for V7.

V6 is frozen as blocked and non-authorizable. No further action taken.


I read this as an exact V7 disposable rehearsal - verify the sandbox/cleanup successor, exercise the unmodified V7 chain through two committed absolute-path overlays and every requested matrix, then preserve immutable PASS evidence or stop at the first raw blocker.


Both V7 transactions are actively hashing the protected inventory inside real Bubblewrap namespaces; the workers are CPU-active, not stalled. The completion monitors remain armed and will resume the rehearsal at the exact exit results.Both V7 transactions remain actively monitored; no blocker or completion result yet.


I read this as the first V7 chain result - stop the parallel second clone immediately, capture the exact installer stderr and rollback state, then seal the raw blocker without running anything further.


Both independent chains reached the same install failure, consumed `FAILED`, restored the service and all mutable sources, and V7’s symlink-safe cleanup removed both partial successors. I’m exposing the suppressed `uv` stderr once inside the same V7 tmpfs sandbox; no authorization path will be rerun.


The tmpfs itself is writable (`0755`, UID/GID 1000), and both the direct and venv interpreters execute successfully inside the same sandbox. The blocker is narrower than V6: `uv` alone receives `EACCES` while querying that executable. I’m taking one verbose, non-authorizing query to locate the exact denied operation before sealing evidence.


The decisive syscall is now identified: `uv` opens `/dev/null` for interpreter probing and receives `EACCES`. V7 fixed `/tmp` and symlink cleanup, but the frozen root-only sandbox still lacks a usable device bind. I’m sealing this as the first raw V7 blocker and cleaning the probe’s partial successor with the unmodified symlink-safe cleanup.


The preserved V7 evidence verifies, but the final read-only preseal verifier now reports `closure_drift` after passing both at input validation and inside both executed chains. I’m isolating the concurrently changed closure files before delivery; no V7 evidence or live state will be altered.


V7 stopped at the first sealed blocker.

- Writable `/tmp` and symlink-safe cleanup passed.
- `uv` failed because `/dev/null` returned `EACCES`; sandbox lacks a usable device bind.
- Both concurrent clones consumed `FAILED` and rolled back cleanly.
- Blocker receipt: `fc54ac3ef542ceeb62bc9df20447ce93e6dfcc1929016c45fd242e597a852942`
- Cleanup receipt: `140e1ba974027fe4d2cd326c933dbaf649a23897445598811e1b91230ab34662`
- Syscall trace: `72824f7e42369a7bba71402270ec2d78ff5c5dec6787381f221ff6566574d329`

Live remained untouched. Afterward, two externally modified closure files caused additional `closure_drift`; this rehearsal did not edit them.


I read this as a hold instruction - preserve all eight V7 evidence files, never rerun or authorize V7, and remain ready in the same rehearsal role for V8.

V7 is frozen as blocked and non-authorizable. No further action taken.


I read this as an exact V8 disposable rehearsal - verify the device-sandbox seal, run the unmodified chain through two fresh committed overlays and every requested matrix, then preserve immutable PASS evidence or stop at the first raw blocker.


Both V8 transactions are actively progressing through protected-inventory hashing under real `--dev /dev` and `--tmpfs /tmp` sandboxes. Completion monitors remain armed.


I read this as both required V8 commits succeeding - audit their exact installed identities and protected/snapshot contracts, then exercise replay denial, seal the full matrix receipt, and clean every disposable artifact.


Both V8 transactions committed successfully. One audit subprocess inherited the harness `PYTHONPATH`, so its `hermes_cli` import resolved to the source worktree instead of proving installed identity; I’m rerunning only that read-only audit with a cleared environment before sealing PASS.


V8 full rehearsal PASS.

- Matrix receipt: `a0066988edecd637ad75f1f37dc7f61d2256bf6c0915a17f08b9febc06fbc9df`
- Cleanup receipt: `88838fc1992275e67a9761c906aa829b632e15cb73ab00d260c32a8b2ac9952a`
- Success A trace: `1b6ceede40cc0e8f87e655f289b476b89925595a28987e295cfdb6488402920d`
- Success B trace: `80f22f293866077b1aa28851934ffd101d47c15302d94330acd02c475c1af003`
- Replay trace: `9729472719112d2482757261ebf8fc0564216398e0f3a8e73546c14245d78760`

Both unrelated transactions committed successfully. All 66 fault cases, durable faults, signals, replay, protected inventory, exact install identities, privacy, and cleanup checks passed. Live remained untouched.


I read this as a full V9 exact-seal rehearsal - verify the live-log classification successor, run two committed device-sandbox overlays plus all requested fault/replay/privacy matrices, then preserve immutable V9 PASS and cleanup receipts without touching live authority.


Both V9 transaction workers are active inside the exact isolated sandbox; completion monitors remain armed.


I read this as a resume of the existing V9 run - inspect the two already-armed transactions and current scaffold, continue only from their exact state, and never launch duplicate chains.


Existing V9 processes are confirmed active; no duplicate was spawned. Both original monitors remain armed, and the completed matrix scaffold is preserved pending their transaction results.


I read this as both original V9 transactions completing successfully - audit their exact installs and live-log classification now, then seal replay, receipts, and cleanup without rerunning either chain.


V9 full rehearsal PASS.

- Rehearsal receipt: `1ba9230695d13d7fad62699f466b675dcc61b5b757eb7185ed9639ca5e460e5d`
- Cleanup receipt: `8b3af58b9d1ef9cf7ce7f12bc496f3f5f3ddc9be3d81eaf0df798345bae99f1a`
- Success A trace: `f590436798cb424aebf536344dcebb8c62d8a3f040c3f9c88cedd7607c7bc1be`
- Success B trace: `fe4b318c331fd77cf97612322c49c333145c09e77bad0440d4e7252477b62f67`
- Replay trace: `068a9f72e418e6d8510bde118be36bbe99333bdce1d5bcc8b463080d90f73638`

Both transactions committed. All live-log classification, 66 fault cases, durable faults, signals, replay, privacy, exact-install, and cleanup gates passed. Live remained untouched.


I read this as a completion-gate resume - verify the already-finished V9 immutable receipts, traces, cleanup inventory, and live invariants in place; do not recreate cleaned clones or rerun successful chains.


V9 completion gate verified without rerunning any chain.

- Workers `3150078` and `3150080`: exited
- Rehearsal receipt: `1ba9230695d13d7fad62699f466b675dcc61b5b757eb7185ed9639ca5e460e5d`
- Cleanup receipt: `8b3af58b9d1ef9cf7ce7f12bc496f3f5f3ddc9be3d81eaf0df798345bae99f1a`
- Final inventory: exactly seven mode-`0444` evidence files
- V9 verifier: PASS
- Live PID/start and critical hashes: unchanged
- Live V9 ledger/execution roots: absent
- No live authorization or duplicate success-chain use occurred.


I read this as a full V10 owner-free rehearsal - verify the exact user-bus seal, run two unrelated committed successes through the real sealed entrypoint with only `XDG_RUNTIME_DIR`, complete every fault/replay/privacy gate, then preserve immutable V10 PASS and cleanup receipts.


Both real-entrypoint clones exited before commit; I’m capturing the exact existing stderr, ledger, and namespace state now. No chain will be rerun unless the failure is proven to be only a contained outer-wrapper defect.


This failure is confined to the rehearsal wrapper: the outer Bubblewrap left UID 1000 without namespace capabilities, so the real entrypoint could not create its required inner namespace; no authority was reserved. I’m testing one non-authorizing capability-preserving outer namespace (`--unshare-user --uid 0 --gid 0`) before deciding whether V10 is blocked.


V10 hit a contained environment blocker before authorization: the real sealed entrypoint cannot create its mandatory inner Bubblewrap namespace from any permitted outer exact-path overlay namespace. Immutable blocker receipt is sealed as `fbb47f38cf6a23873d704ee7ea498f7b1459a9354e42316b44cba866519e6623`; cleanup is still monitored.


I read this as V10 cleanup completion - hash and freeze the cleanup receipt, reconfirm live/V10 absence, reconcile blocked matrices, and deliver the exact blocker evidence.


V10 stopped before authority at a host namespace blocker.

- Blocker receipt: `fbb47f38cf6a23873d704ee7ea498f7b1459a9354e42316b44cba866519e6623`
- Cleanup receipt: `c8f2f2184ea479cab0c301269c7d6c16439f0537619ae2a6dada6a17420ee24d`
- Cause: exact-path outer namespace prevents the real entrypoint from creating its mandatory inner Bubblewrap namespace.
- Three contained namespace strategies failed.
- No controller, ledger, approval, service, or live mutation occurred.
- V10 verifier remains PASS; live PID/start and hashes remain exact.


I read this as a fourth, single-namespace V10 rehearsal - derive argv from the sealed `sandbox_command`, project only three bind sources, run two unrelated commits, then complete all matrices and immutable successor cleanup. I'll stop right away when either the first exact projected-chain blocker is preserved or all successor PASS hashes are verified.


The single-namespace projection itself is byte-derivable, but the safety premise is false: its unchanged `/usr/bin/systemctl` reaches the live user manager through `/run/user/1000/bus`, so `stop/start/daemon-reload` would mutate the live service. I will preserve this as the distinct fourth-approach blocker rather than execute an owner action.


Fourth approach stopped safely before authorization.

- New blocker SHA: `3f11001a9026326823208ffaf0b237b5694e31ae257a9336fcd71e271ea10472`
- Cleanup SHA: `215139fb05876e1f500d9f75fecb456192acde41a7bf64da0bbb4f2c45661bd4`
- Projection assertions SHA: `822a6ef330790f0300e0cd59abebdc2f7f5139f459b6f93c7b389da588830103`
- Live-bus probe SHA: `97b48e0e3f5bd54ad9dc2f0680342cf777ff038609bc995af2da2ca54e025899`

Exact projected argv assertions passed. However, unchanged `systemctl` connected directly to:

```text
/run/user/1000/systemd/private
```

Therefore executing the transaction would stop/restart the live service, violating the no-live-use constraint. The projected transaction was not invoked.

Live remains PID `571685`, start `2234547821498`, active/running, with all four hashes unchanged and V10 authority roots absent. Prior blocker `fbb47…` and cleanup `c8f2…` remain immutable and verified.


I read this as a V11 compositional assurance rehearsal - verify the frozen lifecycle seal, inherit V9/V10 evidence, exercise lifecycle volatility and transaction semantics without any live manager or approval, then freeze PASS/BLOCK and cleanup receipts. I'll stop right away when the first exact compositional blocker is sealed or every V11 check and immutable hash passes.


The frozen delta and 71-test closure are clean. I’m now exercising the missing compositional seam directly: a disposable service mutates all six lifecycle files on stop/start while the unchanged controller runs success, rollback, stopped-probe, and replay behavior.


The live V11 snapshot is exact across all 124,660 stable rows. A direct whole-snapshot V10→V11 equality assertion is invalid because the predecessor snapshot predates unrelated profile growth; I’m narrowing the delta proof to the six named dualcoachtest classifications while retaining the exhaustive current stable-row hash check.


A Python bytecode cache remained outside the declared five-file inventory; I’m removing that disposable cache and re-running the exact inventory check before accepting the cleanup receipt.


V11 compositional lifecycle rehearsal PASS.

- Rehearsal SHA: `3770a51abcc72f4da4aeda0a7bf407baac664a7e035dd95b44b094ae434e203f`
- Cleanup SHA: `42ba251443f80f5f40ecdfe57317afda3ad9fc5123d286a02351d92e81dbb961`
- Compositional evidence SHA: `60f3bf6a77ac1f8f54f3c83ce4a5b73b1918c7f6148548b9b0cd9e305c54e0f1`

Verified:

- Exact six lifecycle files moved from stable to volatile.
- All remaining `124660` live stable rows matched exactly.
- Stop/start deletion, rotation, and append behavior passed stopped-probe, success, rollback, and replay cases.
- Related suite: `71 passed`.
- Targeted lifecycle suite: `4 passed`.
- V9 transaction, installed identities, capacity 5, Inbox OFF, V10 argv/XDG probe, and terminal audit revalidated.
- Live remains PID `3415172`, start `2431627836475`, active/running.
- V11 roots remain absent; zero live, service, network, or approval use.


I read this as a V12 runtime-state compositional rehearsal - verify the frozen delta, exercise SQLite lifecycle churn against the unchanged transaction model, inherit prior assurances, and freeze PASS/BLOCK receipts without touching live authority or service. I'll stop right away when the first exact blocker is sealed or every V12 receipt hash verifies.


The exact V12 delta is clean: 13 target rows left stable inventory—ten archived curator logs plus the root SQLite trio—while six archived database artifacts remain stable and all 86,756 current target rows hash exactly. I’m exercising real SQLite WAL/checkpoint transitions through the disposable transaction seam now.


V12 runtime-state compositional rehearsal PASS.

- Rehearsal SHA: `48ce0e8ee0f9ad2ba3fb9ee8acc9b0d92e12962f854efb7de0df9f081552a4f0`
- Compositional evidence SHA: `e3d5e5e47204b704a399569bb16441fe344a00cae3a444fa1f9077d661fa7687`
- Cleanup SHA: `f7b99160e352457b9470a2b24942027adb2b45d4ec69e3e65532f6abf6d22343`

Verified:

- Root SQLite trio and every `logs/` file are volatile.
- Six archived database artifacts remain stable.
- All `86,756` target stable rows match exactly.
- Real WAL checkpoint, truncation, close deletion, and restart recreation semantics passed.
- Stopped-probe, success, rollback, and replay tolerate runtime DB churn.
- Archived database tampering still fails with `protected_drift`.
- Related suite: `71 passed`; targeted suite: `4 passed`.
- Live remains PID `3453597`, start `2435551563432`, active/running.
- V12 roots remain absent; zero live/service/network/approval use.