I read this as a read-only pre-execution audit - I’ll inspect the frozen controller and rehearsal evidence, recompute every requested invariant, and stop right away when I have sent the lead an unconditional PASS or criterion-bound blockers.


The supplied workspace is an audit bundle rather than the repository root; I found the v1.5 verification tree and am locating its frozen controller, receipt, and source boundary before judging it.


The v1.5 plan distinguishes the required live controller from the earlier validator; the archived Task27 cleanup receipts are not that controller, so I’m tracing the currently frozen v1.5 implementation and its binding files rather than accepting historical PASS evidence.


The candidate and read-only package are internally consistent, and the live boundary still validates without mutation; the release gate remains blocked because the required live transaction controller and full v7-equivalent rehearsal do not exist in the frozen v1.5 evidence.


BLOCK sent to lead. No files or live state were modified.


I read this as a dependency wait - I’ll preserve read-only scope and await the injected frozen controller/rehearsal bindings. I’ll stop right away when the lead has my acknowledgement.


Acknowledged; awaiting the sealed controller and rehearsal bindings.


I read this as a fresh final pre-execution audit - I’ll independently verify the sealed controller, all rehearsal evidence, and the unchanged live boundary without writes. I’ll stop right away when I have sent the lead an unconditional PASS or all remaining criterion-bound blockers.


The offline seal gate passes and all bound hash material is intact, but a fresh read-only current-boundary check now denies `stale_protected_bytes`; I’m treating that as a live-release blocker until the protected-state drift is identified without touching it.


A second, independent issue is structural: the sealed source is a generic `LiveHost` protocol, not a target-bound live adapter; the invocation can supply arbitrary mutation paths and an arbitrary authority-root, so the stated one-use and exact-rollback properties are not cryptographically bound to the actual profile.


The fresh audit has reached a definitive block: the preseal’s cryptographic inputs and rehearsal summaries are intact, but the controller is not bound to a concrete live target or durable global authority, and the real current profile no longer matches its sealed protected snapshot.


BLOCK sent to lead. No files, profile state, service, or network were modified.


I read this as a dependency hold - I’ll remain read-only and idle until the immutable V3 bundle and complete rehearsal receipt are injected. I’ll stop right away when the lead has my acknowledgement.


Acknowledged; holding for the immutable V3 evidence.


I read this as the final immutable V3 pre-execution audit - I’ll independently verify the complete source/package/target closure and rehearsal evidence without touching live state or approval. I’ll stop right away when I have sent the lead an unconditional PASS or exact blockers.


I read this as a status correction during the active V3 audit - I’m continuing the new sealed V3 review and will not reuse the obsolete pre-controller finding.


I read this as the finalization instruction for the V3 audit - I’m running the one required read-only current-boundary gate, then I’ll issue the terminal criterion-by-criterion verdict and receipt without further exploration.


The V3 seal, detached verifier, complete rehearsal receipt, cleanup receipt, and fresh read-only live-boundary gate all pass. I’m issuing the terminal audit receipt and unconditional verdict now.


PASS sent to lead. Independent V3 audit receipt written; no live state or approval was touched.


I read this as a fresh terminal V8 pre-execution audit - I’ll independently verify only the V8 seal, controller closure, rehearsal, and current live immutability without exposing approval or mutating bound state. I’ll stop right away when I have written the V8 audit receipt and sent an unconditional PASS or exact BLOCK.


The V8 verifier and supplied evidence hashes are intact, but the fresh read-only live-boundary gate denied `stale_protected_bytes`; I’m treating that as a V8-specific release blocker unless the sealed protected-state check can be reconciled without mutation.


The terminal V8 verdict is BLOCK: all sealed-source, authority, crash-recovery, rehearsal, privacy, network, and cleanup checks pass, but the actual current protected boundary does not match the immutable V8 snapshot.


BLOCK sent to lead. V8 audit receipt written; no live state or approval was touched.


I read this as a hold instruction for the forthcoming V9 audit - preserve V8 evidence and make no changes. I'll stop right away when that hold is acknowledged.

Acknowledged. The V8 audit JSON remains untouched; I’ll retain the independent audit role for V9.


I read this as a fresh, independent V9 pre-execution audit - verify every sealed and live criterion read-only, write the audit receipt, and issue only the evidence-supported verdict. I'll stop right away when the V9 JSON is written, the terminal PASS/BLOCK is sent, and no bound/live state has changed.


The fresh V9 live-boundary gate passed read-only. The raw success traces do contain one AF_INET6 socket each, so I’m checking its actual use before treating the “zero external events” criterion as satisfied or blocked.


All fresh V9 gates now pass. The two AF_INET6 sockets in rehearsal only bound `::1` and made no non-UNIX connection, which is compatible with the sealed loopback-only namespace rather than an external event.


PASS - V9 satisfies the sealed pre-execution criteria.

- Fresh no-write boundary gate passed; current stable/contract/critical bytes, service PID/start, and absent V9 authority roots match.
- 78 sealed hashes and the V9 verifier passed with no mismatch.
- Durable one-use authority passes: stale same-root replay is fail-closed before mutation; alternate copied-ledger replay proves durable spent-ledger denial.
- 66/66 fault cases, two committed exact installs, capacity 5, Inbox OFF, log classification, privacy/network, and seven-file cleanup passed.
- Audit receipt: `.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/live-transaction-v9-independent-audit.json`
- Terminal PASS sent to lead. No live, approval, service, or network mutation occurred.


I read this as a terminal independent V10 assurance audit - validate the exact seal, compositional delta, inherited V9 evidence, and current no-write boundary without executing a rehearsal or authorization. I'll stop right away when the V10 JSON and evidence-supported terminal PASS/BLOCK are delivered with no bound/live mutation.


The V9 full rehearsal receipt and cleanup verify cleanly, but the archived V9 independent-audit record is BLOCK; I’m distinguishing whether that is a transaction-body failure or the expected later live/authority supersession before deciding V10’s compositional sufficiency.


The compositional evidence supports PASS: the V9 transaction body is byte-identical, the only operational change is the XDG runtime binding, and the real read-only probe proves that binding while the topology receipts show why a full clone cannot be run safely.


PASS - V10 compositional assurance is sufficient.

- 84 sealed/inherited/probe/topology hashes recomputed with zero mismatch; V10 verifier passed.
- V9 transaction `_execute` body is byte-identical; V10 only adds the XDG runtime environment operationally.
- XDG-only user-bus probe and exact sandbox assertions passed; DBUS remains unset.
- Topology blockers stop before controller, authority, or mutation, explaining why no full V10 clone was run.
- Fresh no-write boundary passed: stable/contract/critical bytes, PID/start, and absent V10 roots match.
- Receipt: `.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/live-transaction-v10-independent-audit.json`
- PASS sent to lead. No live, approval, network, service, or new rehearsal action occurred.


I read this as a final independent V10 live-attempt outcome audit - verify the consumed authority, rollback closure, exact live-state restoration, and terminal evidence entirely read-only. I'll stop right away when the terminal audit JSON and evidence-backed PASS/BLOCK are delivered without any live, service, network, or approval mutation.


The terminal state passes the outcome criteria: the consumed failed authorization is durable, recovery restored the target boundary, and a fresh read-only all-row verifier reproduced the hashed recovery receipt.


PASS - the V10 live attempt failed safely and rolled back completely.

- Ledger is `CONSUMED/FAILED`; phase is `ROLLED_BACK`; replay denied `authorization_already_used` with no ledger change.
- Fresh all-row read-only verification confirmed 86,775 stable rows with only the six allowed lifecycle drifts, exact contract/mutable restoration, valid JSON/PID identities, and intact append-only paths.
- Predecessor runtime is active; successor absent; service is active/running at PID `3415172` and expected start time.
- Controller isolation/events and 71-test strict-gate evidence passed. Post-rollback dry-run denial is expected after single-use recovery completion.

Receipt: `.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/v10-live-attempt-1-independent-terminal-outcome-audit.json`
SHA-256: `fb2eee4d604a93425d8a7a2cc6da17f4fecfe2fa4adfcc4b69e21875fd4d2cef`

PASS sent to lead. No live, service, network, approval, or recovery mutation was performed.


I read this as a terminal independent V11 pre-execution audit - recompute the seal, validate the lifecycle-only inventory change and inherited evidence, then verify the current no-write boundary. I'll stop right away when the immutable V11 audit JSON and evidence-backed PASS/BLOCK are delivered with no live, service, network, or approval action.


All V11 criteria now pass, including the fresh no-write boundary and the lifecycle-only inventory delta.


PASS - V11 is authorized by the independent read-only audit.

- 86 bound hashes, package payload, closure, snapshot, and verifier all matched.
- Exactly six lifecycle files moved to volatile; all 124,660 V11 stable rows remain exact with no unrelated inventory changes.
- V11 lifecycle cases, inherited V9 assurance, V10 XDG/terminal lineage, and all V3-V10 supersessions passed.
- Fresh no-write boundary passed: service is active/running at PID `3415172`, critical/contract bytes match, predecessor runtime is active, successor absent, and V11 roots are absent.

Receipt: `.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/live-transaction-v11-independent-audit.json`
SHA-256: `06ac2cb73425e2477901b50fc1a8e1615ef3ba638d1acce91129ba43984f4d5e`

PASS sent to lead. No live, service, network, approval, or V11 authority mutation occurred.


I read this as a terminal independent V12 pre-execution audit - recompute the V12 seal, prove the runtime-state delta and inherited evidence, then check the fresh no-write boundary. I'll stop right away when the immutable V12 audit JSON and evidence-backed PASS/BLOCK are delivered with no live, service, network, or approval action.


All V12 criteria now pass, including the fresh no-write boundary and the SQLite/runtime-state delta.


PASS - V12 is authorized by the independent read-only audit.

- 90 evidence inputs hashed; 86 explicit bound hashes matched with zero mismatch.
- Exactly 13 stable rows were reclassified: SQLite trio plus ten curator logs. All root logs/state DB files are volatile; six archived DB artifacts remain protected/stable.
- WAL checkpoint/truncate/delete/recreate, archive tamper denial, replay protection, and 71+4 tests passed.
- V3-V11 authorities are non-reusable; V12 roots are absent.
- Fresh no-write boundary passed: service active/running at PID `3453597`, critical/contract bytes exact, predecessor active, successor absent.

Receipt: `.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/live-transaction-v12-independent-audit.json`
SHA-256: `a17f11e83d72a7fd4cce6bbb6caa7a15ec160dc0d5d35702e8b90a982a40e956`

PASS sent to lead. No live, service, network, approval, or V12 authority mutation occurred.