{"type":"transition_applied","payload":{"type":"transition_applied","status":"running","residency_state":"resident"}}
{"type":"assistant_message","payload":{"text":"I read this as a read-only release-integrity audit - I’ll independently inspect the candidate, V14 r2 preseal evidence, and source worktree, then reproduce the relevant hashes/build comparisons and return PASS/FAIL with exact proof."}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"assistant_message","payload":{"text":"The candidate’s own contract is now clear: 309 source entries, five immutable inputs, four wheels, three receipts, exact-file-set enforcement, and a digest derived from canonical derivation inputs. I’m moving to independent closure checks against the actual `/home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent` worktree and the r2 rehearsal package, rather than relying on receipt claims."}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"assistant_message","payload":{"text":"Independent byte reconciliation shows the intended source worktree matches the candidate and the preseal’s listed hashes. Two closure defects have surfaced, however: the “controller closure” is not transitively complete, and the “verifier closure” contains only the top-level verifier despite multiple local imports. I’m completing reproducibility, package-derivation, mode, RECORD, and executable-verifier checks to determine the final verdict and quantify all unaffected guarantees."}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"read","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"tool_execution","payload":{"tool":"bash","is_error":false}}
{"type":"assistant_message","payload":{"text":"I read this as a final integrity verdict - I audited the candidate, V14 r2 preseal, and bound source worktree without writes or network access.\n\n# FAIL\n\nThe artifact hashes are internally correct, but the release cannot pass integrity audit because the sealed controller and verifier closures are incomplete. The referenced wheels are also owner-writable rather than physically read-only.\n\n## Passing proof\n\n- Candidate digest independently recomputed:\n  - claimed: `f419822577035f2f906b054b598676b06bc1d1570c31c3c8c99cce4d45758d8f`\n  - recomputed from canonical `derivation_inputs`: identical.\n- Package digest independently recomputed:\n  - claimed: `66d7ef8b46700e703ceb4dd4c8aa0e832f60e48999974fa6b6f32d6cf73d2b24`\n  - recomputed from canonical package payload: identical.\n  - package file SHA-256: `63faebb387b013be6da1d92def7cd06da0bda234296b43d116fd535ee1497f2c`\n  - sealed-target binding: identical.\n- Candidate physical inventory:\n  - expected files: `323`\n  - actual files: `323`\n  - missing: `[]`\n  - extra: `[]`\n  - symlinks: `[]`\n  - hash failures: source `[]`, inputs `[]`, wheels `[]`, evidence `[]`.\n- Source worktree reconciliation:\n  - source entries: `309`\n  - drift count: `0`\n  - source digest: `7272a74005688f6a89766bcab7a9d3ad03ffef25d75f5ca7c8ecd7b56eff8fc7`\n  - equals manifest claim.\n- Reproducible wheel pairs:\n  - Hermes build-1/build-2 byte-identical:\n    `7769edae877d4f373107ba2aa74e2d71c6b703c1382ddf3f4e21d36d2ac11825`\n  - Profile build-1/build-2 byte-identical:\n    `ca187949e6183c45057182efe7100497b4a617226515c122e6994a1107b1a55b`\n  - Hermes wheels: `1041` members, no duplicate or RECORD errors.\n  - Profile wheels: `122` members, no duplicate or RECORD errors.\n- Import ordering is correct:\n  - bootstrap constructs `Hermes wheel : profile wheel : source_root`\n  - Hermes contains `188` `gateway/` members.\n  - Profile contains `118` `checkin_cli/` members.\n  - neither wheel contains a `scripts/` package.\n- Official read-only verifiers currently report:\n  - `NUTRICOACH_V150_CANDIDATE_PASS`\n  - `V14_LIVE_REPRESENTATIVE_PRESEAL_VERIFIED`\n  - closure digest `sha256:5462ed34b9c399c9fb31f444c1ddff79c7e4bc992242f8a3f704319c21ffff90`\n- Authority remains untouched:\n  - ledger: absent\n  - execution root: absent\n  - successor runtime: absent\n\n## Failing proof\n\n### 1. Controller closure is not transitively closed\n\n`controller-source-manifest.json` has `311` entries, but recursive local-import traversal from `scripts/nutricoach_v150_controller_worker.py` reaches seven unsealed files:\n\n```text\nscripts/execute_nutricoach_v150_live_upgrade.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_live_upgrade_boundary.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_live_upgrade_common.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_live_upgrade_state.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_phase_journal.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_sealed_authority.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_sealed_target.py\n```\n\nDirect proof includes `nutricoach_v150_sealed_controller.py` importing four of these. They execute after closure verification but are not hash-bound by the controller manifest. Therefore they can drift without `verify_closure()` detecting it.\n\n### 2. Verifier closure is not closed\n\n`verifier-source.json` contains only:\n\n```text\nscripts/verify_nutricoach_v150_preseal_v14.py\n```\n\nIts reachable unsealed local imports are:\n\n```text\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_detached_bootstrap.py\nscripts/nutricoach_v150_live_upgrade_common.py\nscripts/verify_nutricoach_v140_candidate_core.py\nscripts/verify_nutricoach_v150_candidate.py\nscripts/verify_nutricoach_v150_candidate_inputs.py\n```\n\nThus the official verifier can report PASS while executing five source files outside its own verifier seal.\n\n### 3. Wheels and preseal are not physically read-only\n\nAll four candidate wheels are mode `0644`, including the two wheels referenced by `sealed-target.json`. They are owned by the executing UID and remain owner-writable.\n\nThe bootstrap check only rejects:\n\n```python\nstat.S_IMODE(info.st_mode) & 0o022\n```\n\nThat rejects group/world writes but permits owner write (`0200`). Therefore current `0644` wheels pass despite being mutable by the same authority executing the bootstrap.\n\nAdditionally, all nine V14 r2 preseal files are mode `0664`. Package hashes currently reconcile, but the “frozen” package is physically owner/group-writable and its inventory does not bind modes.\n\n## Conclusion\n\nThe candidate’s enumerated bytes, wheel reproducibility, package derivation, and listed-source no-drift checks pass. The final release fails because operational controller/verifier dependencies are outside their respective seals, and the referenced artifacts are writable rather than immutable. No files were modified and no network was used."}}
{"type":"transition_applied","payload":{"type":"transition_applied","status":"completed","residency_state":"resident"}}