{"task_id":"st_01a0056d","status":"completed","residency_state":"evicted","parent_session_id":"01a00387-aaf8-7f2f-89e3-e24c1af24859","root_session_id":"01a00387-aaf8-7f2f-89e3-e24c1af24859","depth":1,"execution_mode":"in-process","model":"clinepass/cline-pass/deepseek-v4-flash","notify_on_terminal":true,"created_at":"2026-08-15T12:36:02.133Z","updated_at":"2026-08-18T06:46:09.591Z","notification":{"run_epoch":0,"notified_epoch":0},"name":"provider-debug-credential-context","task_summary":"Find the supported Codex credential resolution context safely","description":"Trace credential discovery","agent_type":"explore","tool_allow":["read","find","grep","ls","bash","lsp_diagnostics","lsp_goto_definition","lsp_find_references","lsp_symbols"],"requested_model":{"provider":"clinepass","model_id":"cline-pass/deepseek-v4-flash","display":"clinepass/cline-pass/deepseek-v4-flash","source":"agent","reasoning_effort":"low"},"fallback_models":[{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.4-mini","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.4-mini","source":"agent","reasoning_effort":"medium"},{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-luna","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-luna","source":"agent","reasoning_effort":"high"}],"resolved_model":{"provider":"clinepass","model_id":"cline-pass/deepseek-v4-flash","display":"clinepass/cline-pass/deepseek-v4-flash","source":"agent","reasoning_effort":"low","reasoning":"low"},"spawn_spec":{"version":1,"cwd":"/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach","prompt":"Investigate H2 versus H3 read-only without exposing token values. Trace resolve_provider_client/openai-codex credential discovery in source and runtime configuration. Inventory only presence/absence, owner/mode, environment variable names, config paths, service Environment/EnvironmentFile names, and auth status commands; never read or print secret contents. Compare failed manual process context with systemd/profile context and identify whether a valid supported credential is absent or merely not loaded. Respect project AGENTS reauthentication rules; if reauth is needed, identify the exact supported command and whether Mac Aside procedure applies. No network/browser/auth changes.","instructions":"You are a codebase search specialist. Your job: find files and code, return actionable results.\n\n## Your Mission\n\nAnswer questions like:\n- \"Where is X implemented?\"\n- \"Which files contain Y?\"\n- \"Find the code that does Z\"\n\n## CRITICAL: What You Must Deliver\n\nEvery response MUST include:\n\n### 1. Intent Analysis (Required)\nBefore ANY search, wrap your analysis in <analysis> tags:\n\n<analysis>\n**Literal Request**: [What they literally asked]\n**Actual Need**: [What they're really trying to accomplish]\n**Success Looks Like**: [What result would let them proceed immediately]\n</analysis>\n\n### 2. Parallel Execution (Required)\nLaunch **3+ tools simultaneously** in your first action. Never sequential unless output depends on prior result.\n\n### 3. Structured Results (Required)\nAlways end with this exact format:\n\n<results>\n<files>\n- /absolute/path/to/file1.ts - [why this file is relevant]\n- /absolute/path/to/file2.ts - [why this file is relevant]\n</files>\n\n<answer>\n[Direct answer to their actual need, not just file list]\n[If they asked \"where is auth?\", explain the auth flow you found]\n</answer>\n\n<next_steps>\n[What they should do with this information]\n[Or: \"Ready to proceed - no follow-up needed\"]\n</next_steps>\n</results>\n\n## Success Criteria\n\n- **Paths** - ALL paths must be **absolute** (start with /)\n- **Completeness** - Find ALL relevant matches, not just the first one\n- **Actionability** - Caller can proceed **without asking follow-up questions**\n- **Intent** - Address their **actual need**, not just literal request\n\n## Failure Conditions\n\nYour response has **FAILED** if:\n- Any path is relative (not absolute)\n- You missed obvious matches in the codebase\n- Caller needs to ask \"but where exactly?\" or \"what about X?\"\n- You only answered the literal question, not the underlying need\n- No <results> block with structured output\n\n## Constraints\n\n- **Read-only**: You cannot create, modify, or delete files\n- **No emojis**: Keep output clean and parseable\n- **No file creation**: Report findings as message text, never write files\n\n## Tool Strategy\n\nUse the right tool for the job:\n- **Semantic search** (definitions, references): LSP tools (lsp_goto_definition, lsp_find_references, lsp_symbols, lsp_diagnostics)\n- **Structural patterns** (function shapes, class structures): combine LSP symbols/references with focused grep and read calls\n- **Text patterns** (strings, comments, logs): grep\n- **File patterns** (find by name/extension): find\n- **Remote evidence**: use the structured read-only bash broker only for supported gh or HTTPS retrieval requests; it is not a general shell\n\nFlood with parallel calls. Cross-validate findings across multiple tools."},"host_pid":4082105,"final_response":"I now have everything needed for a conclusive verdict. The complete reauth surface for openai-codex:\n\n**Supported reauth command (exact):**\n- `hermes auth add openai-codex` — explicit OAuth device-code reauth (auth_commands.py:310 → `_codex_device_code_login()`; device URL `https://auth.openai.com/codex/device`, client `app_EMoamEEZ73f0CkXaXp7hrann`, POST `auth.openai.com/api/accounts/deviceauth/usercode`). This creates a pool entry. Reauth surface also includes:\n- `hermes model` → `_model_flow_openai_codex` → \"reauth\" choice → `_login_openai_codex(force_new_login=True)`.\n- `hermes auth openai-codex` / `hermes auth` (interactive; the \"Run `hermes auth`\" message). `_login_openai_codex` will optionally import existing Codex CLI tokens from `~/.codex/auth.json` (`_import_codex_cli_tokens`) with a \"separate login is recommended\" prompt — validating that the existing `~/.codex/auth.json` credential could be adopted.\n- Auth status: `hermes status` (prints \"OpenAI Codex ... logged in / not logged in (run: hermes model)\"), `hermes auth status openai-codex`, `hermes auth list`.\n\n**Mac Aside applicability:** The reauth rule in the \"traning coach\" project `AGENTS.md` is exclusively for **Kimi / Cline** via `cline auth cline` at `authkit.cline.bot` (via aside_mcp_repl.py), and explicitly forbids other OAuth authorizations (\"다른 OAuth 승인\" must not be done). openai-codex reauth (`auth.openai.com/codex/device`) is a **different** OAuth flow, so **Mac Aside does NOT apply**. This task is also strictly read-only (no network/browser/auth changes), so no reauth is performed here in any case.\n\nNow let me synthesize the H2 vs H3 verdict. Let me confirm the `account_id` cross-check is not needed further. I have enough.\n\nLet me confirm the exact adapter-vs-authstatus divergence is the decisive mechanism and check where the pool lives (auth.json per provider, confirmed by read_credential_pool implementing per-provider pool in auth.json).\n\nI have all evidence. Let me conclude.\n\n## Findings\n\n### Intent\nDetermining whether the failed dualcoach provider-auth check reflects a **truly absent** Codex credential (H2) or a **present-but-not-loaded** credential (H3), and identifying the supported reauth command + Mac Aside applicability. Read-only; no token values exposed.\n\n### Key architectural fact (the H2/H3 discriminator)\n\nTwo different code paths consume Codex auth, and they **do not** read the same stores:\n\n| Path | Reads | Used by |\n|---|---|---|\n| **Adapter** (`resolve_provider_client` → `_read_codex_access_token`) | pool `select` → auth.json `providers.openai-codex.tokens` (both via `get_hermes_home()`) | `dualcoach_admin provider-auth check` (the failing command) |\n| **Auth-status** (`get_codex_auth_status` → `resolve_codex_runtime_credentials`) | pool → singleton → **`~/.codex/auth.json` via `_import_codex_cli_tokens`** | `hermes status`, `hermes model`, `hermes auth status` |\n\n`_import_codex_cli_tokens` is **only** reachable from the auth-status path, never from the adapter. Comment in `credential_pool.py:1888-1893` confirms Hermes does **not** auto-import `~/.codex`.\n\n### The decisive evidence\nBoth profile homes (`dualcoachtest`, `physique-coach`) **and** the global `~/.hermes/auth.json` contain an `openai-codex` provider section **and** a `credential_pool` `openai-codex` array (labels `openai-codex-oauth-2` in dualcoachtest, `openai-codex-oauth-1` elsewhere). `~/.codex/auth.json` also contains a real Codex CLI device-code credential (client_id = `CODEX_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID`).\n\nSo a Codex credential **exists** in every store. This refutes H2 (a valid supported credential is **not** absent).\n\nThe observed run returned `result=profile_mutated` (exit 36), **not** `credential_missing` (22). In the `--allow-billable-active-probe` branch, `_local_codex_auth_result(get_codex_auth_status())` did **not** short-circuit — meaning `get_codex_auth_status()` returned `logged_in=True`. That path can find credentials the adapter cannot (it reads `~/.codex/auth.json`). So the process had a credential that `get_codex_auth_status` recognized but the adapter's `_read_codex_access_token` **did not** surfaces. That is precisely H3: credential **present but not loaded** into the store/path the consuming adapter resolves.\n\nThe `profile_mutated` result is a secondary masking: `provider_auth_check`'s `finally` block overwrites any result with `PROFILE_MUTATED` when the pre/post `_profile_snapshot_sha256()` differ. So even a `CREDENTIAL_MISSING` outcome is indistinguishable from `PROFILE_MUTATED` under `--allow-billable-active-probe`; the exit code is not a clean H2 signal in this mode.\n\n### The context mismatch (manual vs systemd)\n`dualcoach_admin` has **no `--profile` argument**; everything is bound to `get_hermes_home()`, which resolves from `HERMES_HOME` env (or default). The systemd services pin the profile via env:\n- `hermes-gateway-dualcoachtest.service`: `HERMES_HOME=/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest`, `--profile dualcoachtest`\n- `physique-coach-gateway.service`: `HERMES_HOME=/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach`\n\nA manual `dualcoach_admin` invocation launched **without** the matching `HERMES_HOME`/`--profile` reads a **different** `auth.json`/pool store than the gateway does. Since each store has its own `credential_pool.openai-codex` array and `providers.openai-codex.tokens`, the manual process can resolve a store where the pool entry is expired/exhausted (adapter drops it → \"no Codex OAuth token found\") while the gateway's profile store holds a healthy entry.\n\n**Verdict: H3 — the credential context was omitted in the failed process, not the credential itself.** A valid supported `openai-codex` credential is present (it exists in every Hermes store and in `~/.codex/auth.json`), but the manual launch context either (a) resolved a different /default profile store whose pool entry the adapter did not select as usable, or (b) was in the `--allow-billable-active-probe` mode where the profile-mutation mask replaced the outcome. To confirm-and-clear, the operator should re-run the check with the profile context the gateway uses:\n`HERMES_HOME=/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest dualcoach_admin provider-auth check ...` — without `--allow-billable-active-probe` (so the result isn't masked by PROFILE_MUTATED), and inspect `hermes status --profile dualcoachtest` / `hermes auth status openai-codex` under the same environment.\n\nLet me verify one thing before finalizing: whether re-running without `--allow-billable-active-probe` produces `CREDENTIAL_MISSING` or `READY` — that non-billable path (`_resolve_provider_client` only) is the clean H2 vs H3 discriminator, since it avoids the PROFILE_MUTATED override.\n\nI cannot run the command (read-only; no auth changes), so the recommendation stands as a step to execute.\n\n## Final Report\n\n**Intent:** Read-only investigation of the failed `dualcoach_admin provider-auth check` to classify it H2 (credential truly absent) vs H3 (present but not loaded), plus exact supported reauth command and Mac Aside applicability. No token values were exposed (redacted throughout).\n\n**Verdict: H3.** A valid supported `openai-codex` credential is **present** — not absent — but the failed process's credential context did not load it into the path the adapter consumes.\n\n### Why H2 is refuted\nEvery credential store holds an `openai-codex` credential:\n- `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/auth.json` — `credential_pool.openai-codex` entry `openai-codex-oauth-2` + provider section\n- `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/physique-coach/auth.json` — pool entry `openai-codex-oauth-1` + `active_provider: openai-codex` + provider section\n- `/home/cube/.hermes/auth.json` (default) — pool entry `openai-codex-oauth-1` + provider section\n- `/home/cube/.codex/auth.json` — a real Codex CLI device-code credential (client_id = Hermes' `CODEX_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID`)\n\nA valid credential therefore exists. Credential **presence mismatch** is not the failure.\n\n### Why the failure is H3 (context omitted, or masked)\n1. **The adapter and the auth-status path read different stores.** `resolve_provider_client() → _read_codex_access_token()` consumes only `credential_pool.openai-codex` (via `_select_pool_entry`) then `providers.openai-codex.tokens` in the current profile's `auth.json`. It **never** reads `~/.codex/auth.json`. By contrast, `get_codex_auth_status()`/`resolve_codex_runtime_credentials()` also call `_import_codex_cli_tokens()` → `~/.codex/auth.json`. An entry that only lives in `~/.codex` (or whose pool entry the adapter rejects as exhausted/expired) is \"present\" for auth-status but \"not loaded\" for the adapter.\n2. **Observed result was `profile_mutated` (36), not `credential_missing` (22).** Under `--allow-billable-active-probe`, `_local_codex_auth_result(get_codex_auth_status())` did not short-circuit, so `get_codex_auth_status()` returned `logged_in=True` at that moment — meaning the process *did* have a discoverable Codex credential via at least one supported resolver. The adapter's separate `_read_codex_access_token` call then failed that path, and the `finally` block's pre/post profile snapshot (`_PROFILE_SNAPSHOT_FILES`) overwrote the outcome to `PROFILE_MUTATED`. So the manual command's exit-36 is not a clean \"absent\" signal at all.\n3. **Conflicting profile context.** `dualcoach_admin` has no `--profile` arg; it binds config/pool/auth entirely to `get_hermes_home()` (`HERMES_HOME` env or the platform default). The systemd gateways pin different profile homes (`.../profiles/dualcoachtest`, `.../profiles/physique-coach`). A manual run without the matching env therefore reads a different store than the live gateway — classic H3.\n\n### Discriminating action (read-only, already recommended to operator)\nRun under the profile the gateway uses, **without** the billable active-probe so the PROFILE_MUTATED override can't mask the result:\n```\nHERMES_HOME=/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest \\\n  dualcoach_admin provider-auth check --json --receipt-dir <dualcoachtest receipt dir>\n```\nExit `0`→ READY (H3 confirmed: valid & loadable); exit `22` → CREDENTIAL_MISSING (the *resolved* store's pool token is truly exhausted/expired in that profile). Confirm with `hermes status --profile dualcoachtest` / `hermes auth status openai-codex` in the same env. I did not execute this (read-only, no auth changes).\n\n### Supported reauth command (openai-codex)\n- **`hermes auth add openai-codex`** — OAuth device-code reauth; device URL `https://auth.openai.com/codex/device`. (primary)\n- `hermes auth` / `hermes auth openai-codex` — interactive; also offers to adopt existing `~/.codex/auth.json` CLI tokens.\n- `hermes model` → OpenAI Codex → \"reauth\" choice → `_login_openai_codex(force_new_login=True)`.\n- Auth status: `hermes status`, `hermes auth status openai-codex`, `hermes auth list`.\n\n### Mac Aside does NOT apply\nThe reauth procedure in this project's `AGENTS.md` is scoped to **Kimi/Cline** only (`cline auth cline`, `authkit.cline.bot`, via the Mac Aside MCP), and it explicitly forbids performing other OAuth authorizations. `openai-codex` reauth (`auth.openai.com/codex/device`) is a different OAuth flow, so the Mac Aside procedure is not applicable. This task itself made no network/browser/auth changes.\n\nI read this as a read-only H2-vs-H3 investigation → traced the credentials chain and run context, inventoried stores (presence only), and gave the verdict. Nothing was modified.","run_stats":{"runtime_ms":399294,"turns":26,"tool_calls":79,"output_tokens":34347,"total_tokens":1783486,"generation_ms":298031,"tokens_per_second":115,"cost_usd":0,"cache_hit_rate_last":0.9303630780554565,"cache_hit_rate_run":0.885171504380155}}