{"task_id":"st_01a0159c","status":"completed","residency_state":"evicted","parent_session_id":"01a00387-aaf8-7f2f-89e3-e24c1af24859","root_session_id":"01a00387-aaf8-7f2f-89e3-e24c1af24859","depth":1,"execution_mode":"in-process","model":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol","notify_on_terminal":true,"created_at":"2026-08-18T15:58:05.208Z","updated_at":"2026-08-20T09:51:58.755Z","notification":{"run_epoch":0,"notified_epoch":0},"name":"review-provenance-cbbfc12","task_summary":"Audit corrected candidate provenance","description":"Provenance rereview","category":"deep","requested_model":{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol","source":"category","variant":"medium","reasoning_effort":"medium"},"fallback_models":[{"provider":"clinepass","model_id":"cline-pass/deepseek-v4-pro","display":"clinepass/cline-pass/deepseek-v4-pro","source":"category","variant":"medium","reasoning_effort":"medium"},{"provider":"clinepass","model_id":"cline-pass/glm-5.2","display":"clinepass/cline-pass/glm-5.2","source":"category","variant":"medium","reasoning_effort":"medium"}],"resolved_model":{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","display":"GPT-5.6 Sol","source":"category","variant":"medium","reasoning_effort":"medium"},"spawn_spec":{"version":1,"cwd":"/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach","prompt":"Independently audit RELEASE PROVENANCE for exactly candidate cbbfc12d1e61c65e5620e4a56b850b0b3d945035a1ab4041c330e50b06fdfe17 in /home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/task26/task26-closed-choice-copula-installed-st_01a01574-v2. Recompute and cross-check hashes, wheels/install/import origins, source-wheel-installed parity, RECORD integrity, candidate/product/runtime/seal digests, test counts, immutable inventory, dirty-tree preservation, invalidation of 2efe939..., and cleanup. Read-only only. Return one cryptographically grounded PASS/FAIL/INCONCLUSIVE report with exact commands, discrepancies, blockers, and residual risks.\n\n<Category_Context name=\"deep\">\nYou are operating in DEEP mode. This is the category reserved for goal-oriented autonomous work on hairy problems that reward thorough exploration and comprehensive solutions.\n\nThe orchestrator chose this category because the task benefits from depth over speed. You should feel empowered to spend the time needed: five to fifteen minutes of silent exploration before the first edit is normal and correct. Rushing to implementation on a deep task is a failure mode, not a feature.\n\n# How deep mode adjusts the base behavior\n\n**Exploration budget: generous.** Read the files you need, trace dependencies both directions, fire 2-5 explore/librarian sub-agents in parallel for broader questions. Build a complete mental model before the first `apply_patch`. Exploration here is an investment, not overhead.\n\n**Goal, not plan.** You receive a GOAL describing the desired outcome. You figure out HOW to achieve it. The orchestrator deliberately did not hand you a step-by-step plan; producing one and asking for approval is not what was asked. Execute.\n\n**Atomic task treatment.** When the goal contains numbered steps or phases, treat them as sub-steps of ONE task and execute them all in this turn. Splitting them across turns is wrong unless they reveal an architectural blocker that requires the user's input. If the \"steps\" turn out to be genuinely independent tasks that should have been separate delegations, flag that in your final message and refuse the ones beyond scope.\n\n**Root cause bias.** Prefer root-cause fixes over symptom fixes. A null check around `foo()` is a symptom fix; fixing whatever causes `foo()` to return unexpected values is the root fix. Trace at least two levels up before settling on an answer. In deep mode, you have permission (and the expectation) to do the deeper fix.\n\n**Ambition scaled to context.** For brand-new greenfield work, be ambitious. Choose strong defaults, avoid AI-slop aesthetics, produce something you would be proud to hand to another senior engineer. For changes in an existing codebase, be surgical and respect the existing patterns; depth does not mean invasiveness.\n\n**Completion bar: full delivery.** \"Simplified version\", \"proof of concept\", and \"you can extend this later\" are not acceptable deliveries for a deep task. The orchestrator routed here specifically for a complete solution. If you hit a genuine blocker (missing secret, design decision only the user can make, three materially different attempts all failed), document it and return; otherwise, finish the task.\n\n**Status cadence: sparse.** The user is not on the other side of this conversation; the orchestrator is, and they will synthesize your progress. Send commentary only at meaningful phase transitions (starting exploration, starting implementation, starting verification, hitting a genuine blocker). Do not narrate every tool call; silence during focused work is expected.\n</Category_Context>"},"host_pid":1761519,"final_response":"I read this as a completed read-only forensic provenance audit - I independently recomputed the candidate’s cryptographic bindings, package parity, evidence integrity, source preservation, and cleanup state.\n\n# Verdict: PASS\n\nCandidate audited:\n\n`cbbfc12d1e61c65e5620e4a56b850b0b3d945035a1ab4041c330e50b06fdfe17`\n\nThe candidate is internally consistent and cryptographically bound to the supplied products, wheels, runtime, receipts, immutable inventory, and seal.\n\n## Cryptographic results\n\n| Item | Recomputed SHA-256 | Result |\n|---|---|---|\n| Candidate canonical binding | `cbbfc12d1e61c65e5620e4a56b850b0b3d945035a1ab4041c330e50b06fdfe17` | PASS |\n| Product canonical binding | `68d7ddb2b4fb1770c0da485d69357148e8eb935ca9abd610aa99806464daf330` | PASS |\n| Golden runtime binding | `b982333604de2aca2cda27150f59420c82f8c28a845fc0ce7f707e803788df97` | PASS |\n| Source tree binding | `b34b2a12fd0ad3d4c95a58c847a2411e81272a646f5a4f5ec568d0d3640a3747` | PASS |\n| Hermes wheel | `1f334e9f0ba33dda814ef4477630e2fb5c0f2980654574d170a071c0c9d01f66` | PASS |\n| Profile wheel | `62c508d3548ed5f5fe28c1a137bbc1b6af286d48419dc9e66fa4c7c8422b4121` | PASS |\n| Interpreter | `d9bc96d1ad0161db7ebdc8fdbc690530a9c29299feb2001cba6b29072e2a9051` | PASS |\n| Evidence inventory | `7d32e57ea40a170517c26dba0c72ea6a3247a4012b23f74a38838e1bc82a618a` | PASS |\n| `SEAL.json` | `bc7b202c072cfc440d2bb970dc005f62c0f4d883501125ff63bb459d47500928` | PASS |\n| Candidate manifest | `a68176bce2052d31e3d1db565ad9998313f3ef20813edadb18881430baf64f15` | PASS |\n\nThe `SEAL.json.sha256` sidecar matches the seal exactly.\n\n## Wheels, installation, and origins\n\nFresh runtime recomputation produced byte-identical installed provenance:\n\n`ce4e635ea11784300d1da35950f541e47cf4c38732f70853d57be342ee6d2038`\n\nThis matched `installed-runtime-record-parity-final.json`.\n\nRECORD checks passed for every entry, including wheel ZIP payload hash/size, installed payload hash/size, inventory cardinality, and RECORD self-row:\n\n- Hermes: 995 installed RECORD entries\n  - Installed inventory: `519d921de81988c486764a03f59b603621aa6b32ac3b678aaa1fb594c5952b52`\n  - Installed RECORD: `7f137496663575076235c15a9ff4bc83b729f23d476ac393e6e14c4b0c431181`\n- Profile: 61 installed RECORD entries\n  - Installed inventory: `8fc4dd658cb69c77f2c9ed298e1bf58bff05fa36d7c41fc16c642cd87e7dbf01`\n  - Installed RECORD: `3f524f6ecd8f620746274bbb0b84665e8ff07ee510cb08930a0b51f24583a75c`\n\nProduct payload parity:\n\n- Profile: 54 source = wheel = installed files; inventory digest `33997b8e...5254`.\n- Hermes: 963 wheel files all exist byte-identically in source and installation; inventory digest `4cd1f261...f45`.\n- Hermes has 8,873 additional non-wheel source files. None conflict with wheel members; this is not a parity failure.\n\nWith `PYTHONPATH` unset and bytecode disabled, all five audited imports resolved inside the private candidate runtime’s `site-packages`. No alternate import authority preceded it.\n\n## Evidence inventory and immutability\n\n- Declared files: 133\n- Actual inventoried files: 133\n- Missing: 0\n- Extra: 0\n- Hash/size/mode mismatches: 0\n- Symlinks inside evidence: 0\n- Root/directories: private frozen mode `0500`\n- Files: frozen mode `0400`\n\nThe candidate manifest binds 121 pre-sealing artifacts. Final receipts and duplicated final parity files are bound through the 133-file evidence inventory, whose digest is bound by `SEAL.json`.\n\n## Source and dirty-tree preservation\n\nCaptured Hermes status:\n\n- 150 dirty records were intentionally present.\n- `hermes-status-pre.nul` and `hermes-status-post.nul` are byte-identical.\n- Both hash to `c82fa92d8e15f17bd62f24657892d219afb83329853bbcb8959832a481ffaa9e`.\n\nSource inventories remain intact now:\n\n- Profile: 89/89 paths present and hash-correct.\n- Hermes: 28,350/28,350 paths present and hash-correct.\n- Missing or changed inventoried source files: 0.\n\nCurrent Hermes Git status is no longer byte-identical to the captured post-status: it contains 1,321 expanded records, primarily later untracked `.gjc` and `.task26-evidence` files. This does not contradict the captured pre/post preservation, and no enumerated source byte changed, but it means present-day whole-tree status cannot independently reproduce the historical status snapshot.\n\n## Tests and cleanup\n\nReceipt counts cross-check to 9,426 declared passes:\n\n- Profile: 749\n- Gateway: 8,286 passed, 0 failed\n- Parser: 13 source + 13 installed\n- Policy: 14 source + 14 installed\n- Focused: 106 source + 106 installed\n- Provenance/verifier: 49\n- Related lifecycle: 76\n\nEvery pass count and exit status is present in its bound log. The 59 Gateway skips are declared consistently by the manifest/seal but are not itemized in `full-gateway.log`; the runner summary only records 8,286 passed and 0 failed.\n\nCleanup cross-checks:\n\n- Cleanup phase committed\n- Service paused\n- Active/pending/orphan/unknown: all zero\n- One verified archive\n- Zero current deliveries\n- One synthetic audited surface/transport delivery recorded\n- No candidate-related process remains\n- Runtime and evidence roots remain private\n- No live service, Telegram action, or real-customer mutation is evidenced\n\n## Invalidated candidate\n\n`2efe939a9775dccb71c680d6ce8513c919721dc0dba5535f0f64905e34d3bd82` is explicitly named as invalidated in the new manifest, seal, report, command results, and environment receipt.\n\nIt is distinct from the new canonical binding and belonged to different bindings:\n\n- Old product: `9745c852...3010`\n- Old runtime: `7f1331d8...465e`\n- New product: `68d7ddb2...f330`\n- New runtime: `b9823336...df97`\n\nThe old evidence directory remains available as historical evidence; it is not silently rewritten as the new candidate.\n\n## Exact principal commands\n\n```bash\nsha256sum \"$E\"/artifacts/*.whl \"$E/SEAL.json\" \"$E/evidence-inventory.json\"\n```\n\n```bash\npython - <<'PY'\nbinding = manifest[\"binding\"]\nsha256(canonical_json(binding))\nsha256(canonical_json(binding[\"product\"]))\nsha256(canonical_json(installed_provenance[\"binding\"]))\nPY\n```\n\n```bash\nenv -u PYTHONPATH PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 \\\n  \"$R/venv/bin/python\" -c \\\n  '... collect_installed_runtime(...); print(canonical(out).decode())' |\nsha256sum\n```\n\n```bash\nenv -u PYTHONPATH PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 \\\n  \"$R/venv/bin/python\" \\\n  \"$E/tools/independent_verify_candidate.py\" \"$E\" |\nsha256sum\n```\n\n```bash\ngit -C /home/cube/projects/richard/hermes-agent \\\n  status --porcelain=v1 -z --untracked-files=all |\ncmp - \"$E/seals/hermes-status-post.nul\"\n```\n\nCustom read-only Python checks additionally recomputed every inventory entry, source inventory line, wheel member hash/size, installed payload, product inventory, import origin, and seal cross-reference.\n\n## Discrepancies and residual risks\n\n1. The full Golden verifier cannot be rerun after freezing because it calls `private(root, directory=True)` without `frozen=True` and rejects the evidence root’s correct `0500` sealed mode. Its pre-freeze outputs are byte-identical and inventory-bound; lower-level runtime, RECORD, source, and candidate verification reran successfully.\n2. Gateway’s declared 59 skips are not individually evidenced in the full-run log.\n3. The seal is a self-contained SHA-256 closure, not an externally signed or trusted-timestamped attestation.\n4. Present-day Git status has evolved due to later untracked workspace artifacts, although all 28,439 enumerated source files remain hash-correct.\n\nNo blocker changes the PASS verdict. No files were modified.","run_stats":{"runtime_ms":290516,"turns":19,"tool_calls":45,"output_tokens":13739,"total_tokens":1638042,"generation_ms":275100,"tokens_per_second":50,"cost_usd":1.739189,"cache_hit_rate_last":0.9712469908521907,"cache_hit_rate_run":0.9295605561277668}}