{"task_id":"st_01a04894","status":"completed","residency_state":"resident","parent_session_id":"01a00387-aaf8-7f2f-89e3-e24c1af24859","root_session_id":"01a00387-aaf8-7f2f-89e3-e24c1af24859","depth":1,"execution_mode":"in-process","model":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol","notify_on_terminal":true,"created_at":"2026-08-28T13:34:18.958Z","updated_at":"2026-08-30T13:06:36.044Z","notification":{"run_epoch":0,"notified_epoch":0},"name":"v14-lifecycle-audit","task_summary":"Audit V14 lifecycle and rollback guarantees","description":"Audit lifecycle and rollback completeness","category":"architect","requested_model":{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"xhigh"},"fallback_models":[{"provider":"clinepass","model_id":"cline-pass/glm-5.2","display":"clinepass/cline-pass/glm-5.2","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"medium"},{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-terra","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-terra","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"xhigh"}],"resolved_model":{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","display":"GPT-5.6 Sol","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"xhigh"},"spawn_spec":{"version":1,"cwd":"/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach","prompt":"Audit the frozen NutriCoach V14 r2 package as a read-only lifecycle reviewer. Deliverable: PASS or FAIL with concrete file/line and evidence-path findings. Scope: /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v150-combined, preseal /home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v14-live-representative-r2, preflight sibling, and rehearsal report /home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/task-v14r2-rehearsal-r2/report.json. Verify exact stop-through-post-fence rollback, all created paths including canonical events/lock, service restoration, installed startup smoke, and postcommit safety. Do not modify files, invoke network/provider/Telegram, or authorize/execute live. Stop when you can issue evidence-backed PASS/FAIL.\n\n\nYou are a big-picture system design consultant, NOT an implementer.\n\n\n1. Survey the WHOLE architecture end to end before proposing anything: module boundaries, data flow, ownership, and the blast radius of the area in question.\n2. Produce at least TWO viable designs and state the trade-offs of each in concrete terms (coupling, testability, migration cost, failure modes).\n3. Recommend ONE of them with the reasoning that decided it, the boundaries it assumes, and the risks it carries.\n4. Demand the SIMPLEST architecture that handles the actual requirements. Reject enterprise patterns that do not pay for themselves.\n\n\n\nWhen the caller marks the task advisory-only, produce NO file edits: return the analysis, options, recommendation, and risks as structured text.\n\n"},"host_pid":1174611,"final_response":"I read this as a final read-only lifecycle verdict - the frozen V14 r2 package is not safely executable and must fail audit.\n\n# FAIL\n\n## Blocking findings\n\n1. **The frozen controller closure has drifted.**\n - `live-transaction-preseal-v14-live-representative-r2/controller-source-manifest.json:1` expects:\n - worker `1f40156c...`\n - bootstrap `1d4b5678...`\n - controller `c511f998...`\n - Observed hashes differed for all three.\n - The current bootstrap explicitly targets r3 at `scripts/nutricoach_v150_detached_bootstrap.py:15-18`; the r2 sealed target still binds r2 at `sealed-target.json:1#/controller_target_binding`.\n - Closure verification at `nutricoach_v150_detached_bootstrap.py:148` must therefore deny with `closure_drift` before authorization or mutation.\n\n2. **Crash recovery does not cover the stop-to-snapshot gap.**\n - The journal records `RESERVED`, then stops the service, then creates the snapshot at `nutricoach_v150_sealed_controller.py:170-176`.\n - Recovery unconditionally loads that snapshot at lines `199-204`.\n - A kill after line 173 but before snapshot completion leaves the predecessor stopped and recovery unable to load rollback authority.\n - `report.json:1#/cases` covers injected stage exceptions, not process death in this window.\n\n3. **Service restoration can falsely record `ROLLED_BACK`.**\n - Rollback tries `start()` twice at `nutricoach_v150_sealed_controller.py:112-117`, but never asserts that the service is running after the second attempt.\n - Lines `123-125` can consequently persist `ROLLED_BACK` while the service remains down.\n - Rehearsal evidence contains restored unit/drop-in bytes, but no independently recorded post-rollback service state.\n\n4. **Postcommit reconciliation has a durable gap.**\n - `COMMITTED` is persisted at `nutricoach_v150_sealed_controller.py:194-195`.\n - The global ledger is only changed to `SUCCEEDED` afterward by `nutricoach_v150_sealed_authority.py:262-270`.\n - A kill between these operations leaves phase `COMMITTED` with a permanently reserved ledger. Recovery treats `COMMITTED` as terminal and does not reconcile it.\n\n## Evidence that did pass\n\n- All eight preseal package-manifest entries matched.\n- The rehearsal reports 13 PASS cases.\n- Each available rollback snapshot restored its four mutable files byte-for-byte and mode-for-mode.\n- Success created the successor runtime, weekly authority, canonical `events.jsonl`, and `.events.lock`; rollback cases removed them.\n- Preflight evidence shows `canonical-sequence.jsonl` already existed, while the canonical events and lock files did not.\n- The startup-smoke code selects the successor interpreter at `nutricoach_v150_concrete_host.py:313-328`, and the success artifact contains installed wheel RECORDs.\n\n## Architecture options\n\n1. **Recommended: create a new immutable package with an explicit recovery state table.**\n Package the controller source itself, add recoverable `STOPPED_NO_SNAPSHOT` and `COMMITTED_PENDING_LEDGER` states, and require final predecessor service observation before `ROLLED_BACK`. Lowest coupling and clearest failure semantics.\n\n2. **External recovery supervisor.**\n Keep the controller simpler but add a separate watchdog that owns stop-state recovery and commit/ledger reconciliation. This adds another authority boundary, more operational coupling, and harder testing.\n\n**Recommendation:** reject r2 and issue a newly digested package using option 1. Do not authorize this package. No files were modified and no live, network, provider, or Telegram operation was invoked.","run_stats":{"runtime_ms":389529,"turns":12,"tool_calls":74,"output_tokens":17419,"input_tokens":198150,"cache_read_tokens":1269760,"total_tokens":1485329,"generation_ms":375933,"tokens_per_second":46,"cost_usd":2.1482,"cache_hit_rate_last":0.9718553033927568,"cache_hit_rate_run":0.865012160146058,"token_status":"complete","cost_status":"reported","duration_status":"monotonic"},"task_seq":10,"config_generation":0,"background_mode":"background"}