{"task_id":"st_01a04b1c","status":"completed","residency_state":"persisted_only","parent_session_id":"01a04ad7-eaa9-790c-83f7-57410e6370d1","root_session_id":"01a04ad7-eaa9-790c-83f7-57410e6370d1","depth":1,"execution_mode":"in-process","model":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol","notify_on_terminal":true,"created_at":"2026-08-29T01:22:16.780Z","updated_at":"2026-08-29T15:18:51.148Z","notification":{"run_epoch":0,"notified_epoch":0},"name":"st_01a04b1c","task_summary":"Audit r16 candidate and sealed authority closure","description":"r16-closure-audit","category":"architect","requested_model":{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-sol","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"xhigh"},"fallback_models":[{"provider":"clinepass","model_id":"cline-pass/glm-5.2","display":"clinepass/cline-pass/glm-5.2","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"medium"},{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-terra","display":"openai-codex/gpt-5.6-terra","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"xhigh"}],"resolved_model":{"provider":"openai-codex","model_id":"gpt-5.6-sol","display":"GPT-5.6 Sol","source":"category","variant":"xhigh","reasoning_effort":"xhigh"},"spawn_spec":{"version":1,"cwd":"/home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach","prompt":"Perform a decisive read-only release audit of NutriCoach V14 r16. Candidate: bf7dfa0a5ef4104033cb1a191d4ffe437c1d03fc7d6323d4dd1d7c7cc383cfcb. Preseal: /home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-transaction-preseal-v14-live-representative-r16. Rehearsal: /home/cube/projects/richard/traning coach/.omo/evidence/nutricoach-v150-combined/task-v14r16-rehearsal. Verify immutable candidate/preseal/controller/verifier closure, explicit successor overlay binding, profile wheel reproducibility and RECORD, one-use authority and supersession of r13/r14, exact target paths, and untouched live authority/execution/successor roots. Return PASS/FAIL with exact hashes and blockers. Do not edit files or invoke authorization, service, network, Telegram, provider, customer, commit, or push actions.\n\n<Category_Context>\nYou are a big-picture system design consultant, NOT an implementer.\n\n<Method>\n1. Survey the WHOLE architecture end to end before proposing anything: module boundaries, data flow, ownership, and the blast radius of the area in question.\n2. Produce at least TWO viable designs and state the trade-offs of each in concrete terms (coupling, testability, migration cost, failure modes).\n3. Recommend ONE of them with the reasoning that decided it, the boundaries it assumes, and the risks it carries.\n4. Demand the SIMPLEST architecture that handles the actual requirements. Reject enterprise patterns that do not pay for themselves.\n</Method>\n\n<Advisory_Mode>\nWhen the caller marks the task advisory-only, produce NO file edits: return the analysis, options, recommendation, and risks as structured text.\n</Advisory_Mode>\n</Category_Context>"},"final_response":"I read this as a read-only release-gate audit - I traced the sealed architecture and verified hashes, authority state, rehearsal evidence, and live-root invariants without mutation.\n\n# FAIL\n\n## Decisive blockers\n\n1. **Candidate physical closure is invalid**\n   - Manifest expects **327 files**; candidate currently contains **329**.\n   - The read-only r16 verifier exits `1` with:\n     `CandidateContractError: candidate physical inventory mismatch`\n   - Unsealed writable additions:\n     - `.../checkin_cli/__pycache__/__init__.cpython-312.pyc`\n       - SHA-256: `39b1c2ba31a683791fb6cacfd9907b99c21029ec79126aa7b3e736852fa6bee7`\n     - `.../checkin_cli/__pycache__/customer_admin.cpython-312.pyc`\n       - SHA-256: `56631ecf1e46687ad806a1494b7be21c34f0bc4e767719304a384dfad3915a9a`\n   - Both are mode `0644`, timestamped `2026-08-29 10:24:51 +0900`.\n   - Root cause: all sealed files are read-only, but **22 candidate directories** and **16 preseal directories** remain owner-writable, so rename, deletion, replacement, and bytecode injection remain possible.\n\n2. **The sealed r16 live launcher targets r14**\n   - Sealed file SHA-256:\n     `c70fe6b72a02b921a1a88877e4246af331284247c8ae4d5c094d004d5f25c41d`\n   - `scripts/execute_nutricoach_v150_sealed_live.py:21` hardcodes:\n     `live-transaction-preseal-v14-live-representative-r14`\n   - Therefore the actual network-isolated public execution surface does not launch the r16 bootstrap. Existing tests only assert bwrap shape, not the exact preseal path.\n\n3. **r14 is documented as superseded but remains executable**\n   - r14 package digest:\n     `7a60506ffd66f76bfe51e1864f180a3bc597a2d67ffbc39fcf8fb247e90eaeea`\n   - r14 package SHA-256:\n     `00da161e007810254bfa851ef923d20e80832407abafbbdfaa4c4be29e121584`\n   - r14 still records `FROZEN_AWAITING_AUDIT`, `approval_consumed=false`.\n   - Its authority, execution, and successor roots are absent.\n   - Its independent read-only preseal verifier currently **passes**, returning closure:\n     `sha256:9bf331437dfd0017c7560d619ab4288dec77e6c10dfe985a564f8ed5ab7eceb8`\n   - Thus the r16 supersession document does not revoke the historical r14 controller. The stale r16 launcher exposes that old package directly.\n\n## Hash and gate results\n\n### Candidate and sealed closure\n\n- Candidate digest, independently recomputed from canonical derivation inputs:\n  `bf7dfa0a5ef4104033cb1a191d4ffe437c1d03fc7d6323d4dd1d7c7cc383cfcb`\n- Candidate manifest:\n  `371c8d96de8aea95b84b15f43640b4c74356e975068b9fa6d0604e0555dfeed9`\n- Permission package digest:\n  `734f9d34f6375a797f821230777d3467a8428696c08ab53bf5d04171a07897e2`\n- Permission package SHA-256:\n  `951e6c8b463f33e025963d1ecbe1125beb3b3ea6d673b4342c38087031765b23`\n- Preseal package manifest:\n  `d143b29b6adc213c6708431fbc27fb27b23e235a03de5ff4f48ef13024b62d57`\n- Controller source manifest:\n  `8c1797e3ac527addb1660dd1cee55e1559ec507155eca33305909c44c342a598`\n- Controller derivation:\n  `4f3b4f167e6b07fd59c393a7836874baaf8ff6f19d9e1b51d6f00b408ebb9e20`\n- Controller closure digest:\n  `sha256:31553f3c294b1b34e3f79c4f39b7a6eb15cd70c0afec0120ab9e444d77f87c4c`\n- Verifier-source manifest:\n  `491283be22ba172e350dce4f1f9ecbd0f682fc8f088ced98ff1cd34254f489c9`\n- Sealed target:\n  `a016d731ae4f980e59dcf31e17e50eda92ad4d67d85e91b68ff625a80289e53a`\n- Supersession document:\n  `21662bf30aa64b131a824172d4f0ea0ed6fc2efc61104cf3fa64e860f9664308`\n\nThe preseal itself has the expected 327 files, zero symlinks, zero writable files, and no content drift. Its writable directories still prevent filesystem-level immutability.\n\n### Successor overlay: PASS\n\nOverlay file SHA-256:\n`3e158635835fbf37b0c0728d179703a1756bedb6dc94b22eace432a0014715ad`\n\nExact bindings:\n\n- `dualcoach/profile/checkin_cli/customer_admin.py`\n  - `027c03b4ebf7e7f911f3b538b7c9608de8fbfd049eee139e80bf16868875cd86`\n- `dualcoach/profile/tests/test_multi_customer_migration.py`\n  - `76b1b7a980f91cbf834faefd1c6161f02bf7af09d3dd3e03868b15e7949ee7dc`\n\nThe source inventory and profile-wheel `customer_admin.py` member match the overlay.\n\n### Wheel reproducibility and RECORD: PASS\n\nBoth build pairs are byte-identical.\n\n- Hermes wheel:\n  `7769edae877d4f373107ba2aa74e2d71c6b703c1382ddf3f4e21d36d2ac11825`\n- Hermes RECORD:\n  `bec67407a4a31221f2c5d16c1770418ab5c012516bff79dbd098938d1bd3121e`\n  - 1,041 rows; all recorded hashes and sizes validate.\n\n- Profile wheel:\n  `7651bc8bc939268274dc5b0231a09208ed6bf646d22e97e81f4a29e9d1c9d9af`\n- Profile RECORD:\n  `21165d7e7a520c4724e0b9bd0d58394c0319c3ad890b334957d3539ee0cb6fbc`\n  - 122 rows; all recorded hashes and sizes validate.\n\n### Rehearsal core: PASS, but incomplete release coverage\n\nRehearsal report SHA-256:\n`5036e21e294184bf26c4376b7814bdc66777cc8214d9734d98006ef379129074`\n\n- 13/13 cases pass.\n- Success: `COMMITTED`, authority `CONSUMED/SUCCEEDED`.\n- Twelve fault cases: `ROLLED_BACK`, authority `CONSUMED/FAILED`.\n- Bound candidate and package are correct.\n- Success receipt:\n  `sha256:03cf3eae0459b34aa87d2a9ae5a988d4b62be922d48af4ba17d59f0ed11d74e6`\n- Network namespace recorded as loopback-only.\n- The successful unit/drop-in binds `bf7dfa0a-v150`.\n\nThe rehearsal exercises the disposable host/controller transaction, not the stale public launcher or historical-r14 revocation path, explaining the false-positive release result.\n\n## Authority and live-state findings\n\n### r16 exact target paths\n\n- Authority ID:\n  `nutricoach-v150-v14-live-representative-55-bf7dfa0a`\n- Ledger:\n  `/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-authorization-v14/nutricoach-v150-v14-live-representative-55-bf7dfa0a`\n- Execution:\n  `/home/cube/.hermes/migrations/nutricoach-v1.5.0-combined/live-executions-v14/nutricoach-v150-v14-live-representative-55-bf7dfa0a`\n- Successor:\n  `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/.strict-runtime/bf7dfa0a-v150/venv`\n- Current runtime:\n  `/home/cube/.hermes/profiles/dualcoachtest/.strict-runtime/6c9c4394-v132/venv`\n- Unit:\n  `/home/cube/.config/systemd/user/hermes-gateway-dualcoachtest.service`\n- Drop-in:\n  `/home/cube/.config/systemd/user/hermes-gateway-dualcoachtest.service.d/task26-authority.conf`\n\nAll r16 ledger, execution, successor, weekly-authority, activation-receipt, and pilot-created paths remain absent. The r16 one-use authority is untouched.\n\n### Live critical bytes remain untouched\n\n- Registry:\n  `bd61ed95f80737ba8013db262fd0242a600e540f43f6627f5b9708a599660b29`\n- Config:\n  `e9ee8f1c3a4913bcde64f4832dcbec6620173ca0de39ffd1a32c4b0c55c6a162`\n- Unit:\n  `90fbab66354811448427286b87f0305955a25df8f08a202a15b5ac3541700af7`\n- Drop-in:\n  `33bc59bdaf6a4261abc7ce43ae7faf452f724353ee24f6a54b2a92ed5b1ca0d8`\n- Protected inventory:\n  `d2c084be0865f8e9844452a7b683f97800e31af9bc7e1a113241109a283aada5`\n\n### r13: correctly consumed and rolled back\n\n- Package:\n  `14f80dbe8977fbac1ec641f8f3bed287c3ba88072f31187ad852c2a2bee5dda5`\n- Consumed-ledger SHA-256:\n  `2a333710f1617d237709cce70780fec24f875f7011bc31750a8ff4e1d0ea3506`\n- Outcome: `SUCCEEDED`, status `CONSUMED`\n- Final phase: `ROLLED_BACK`\n- Rollback receipt:\n  `d51529071495b5066705905a87b703d475f49a78a898685ee7b8309ef504fc6e`\n- r13 successor is absent.\n\n## Architecture disposition\n\nCurrent flow is:\n\n`overlay/source evidence -> candidate snapshot and reproducible wheels -> permission package -> preseal closure -> bwrap launcher -> detached bootstrap -> worker/preseal verifier -> one-use ledger -> live host stages`\n\nThe transaction core is sound enough to rehearse, but the release boundary breaks at candidate filesystem immutability, launcher binding, and cross-generation supersession.\n\n### Viable recovery designs\n\n1. **Minimal fresh reseal — recommended**\n   - Produce a new candidate/preseal generation; do not repair r16 in place.\n   - Bind the launcher to that exact generation.\n   - Revoke r14 using a durable historical-authority tombstone that its existing verifier recognizes as `authority_touched`.\n   - Seal all candidate/preseal directories non-writable, suppress bytecode creation, and assert exact launcher path plus historical revocation in tests.\n   - Lowest migration cost and preserves the proven controller/rollback core.\n\n2. **Central active-package registry**\n   - Use one stable launcher resolving a single append-only active package and require every controller to consult it before reservation.\n   - Stronger global supersession and easier auditing, but adds mutable central coupling, migration work for historical controllers, and a new failure domain.\n\n**Recommendation:** reject r16 and use design 1. The central registry does not pay for itself for this release; a fresh sealed generation plus explicit r14 tombstone is the smallest architecture that closes the actual failures.","run_stats":{"runtime_ms":440605,"turns":11,"tool_calls":69,"output_tokens":22705,"input_tokens":241713,"cache_read_tokens":1538048,"total_tokens":1802466,"generation_ms":433053,"tokens_per_second":52,"cost_usd":2.658739,"cache_hit_rate_last":0.9802558126700712,"cache_hit_rate_run":0.8641879443363463,"token_status":"complete","cost_status":"reported","duration_status":"monotonic"},"task_seq":0,"config_generation":0,"background_mode":"background"}