{
  "version": 1,
  "messageId": "8d896408-865a-49ab-b333-5af87b8d9f61",
  "from": "pre-exec-audit",
  "to": "lead",
  "kind": "message",
  "body": "FINAL FRESH PRE-EXEC VERDICT: BLOCK. Do not execute a live mutation.\n\nWhat independently passed:\n- Recomputed all 16 bound source/test/wheel/candidate/preseal/rehearsal hashes: no mismatch. Package-manifest SHA=1f3df666..., controller binding=a1a6da87..., verification=149e374f..., rehearsal evidence=5f4c9d37..., trace=2e3cf461.... The claimed content digest 62e0ad46... also recomputes exactly as newline-terminated `path SHA-256` rows.\n- The offline preseal verifier passed with 3 controller files, 2 tests, 2 wheels, Channel Inbox false, weekly pilot true, capacity 5. The frozen rehearsal root has exactly five files and no child dirs; raw trace confirms zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 `connect()` calls and the sealed network proof reports zero provider calls.\n\nCriterion-bound blockers (all must be resolved together):\n1. NO TARGET-BOUND LIVE CONTROLLER. The sealed controller is only a generic `LiveHost` Protocol and `execute(operation, host)` primitive. No concrete host adapter, executable live entrypoint, or adapter hash is frozen: only `nutricoach_v150_live_models.py`, `..._authority.py`, and `..._transaction.py` are bound. `LiveOperation` accepts caller-controlled `execution_root` and `mutable_paths` (scripts/nutricoach_v150_live_models.py:65-71); the controller-binding has neither. A caller can therefore choose a different target/snapshot set than the sealed profile/unit/drop-in. The retained tests use only `FakeHost`.\n2. V7 EQUIVALENCE / FULL-OPERATION REHEARSAL IS NOT SEALABLE FROM THESE ARTIFACTS. The controller implements the claimed ten stage names and the summary claims two successes/11 fault rollbacks, but neither controller nor binding contains a v7 reference/digest (transaction source has zero `v7` references; only the test name says v7). No v7 source-level reference is included. More importantly, no frozen concrete adapter makes those stages equivalent to real stop/install/systemd/post-fence behavior; evidence-only summaries cannot prove it.\n3. ONE-USE + EXACT ROLLBACK ARE UNSOUND. `ApprovalLedger` is rooted at caller-controlled `operation.execution_root` (scripts/nutricoach_v150_live_transaction.py:139-142), so replay with a fresh root bypasses the prior consumed record. The outer handler consumes only KeyboardInterrupt/OSError/SystemExit/TransactionError (line 165); a RuntimeError/ValueError/AssertionError rolls back through TransactionGuard but escapes before `ledger.consume`, leaving the approval reserved rather than irrevocably consumed. Snapshot paths are likewise caller supplied, so exact restoration of the actual registry/unit/drop-in is not enforced.\n4. CURRENT CLEAN BOUNDARY FAILS. A fresh no-write run of the existing package inspector denied `stale_protected_bytes`. Package/candidate/evidence integrity checks passed first; service PID/start/state exactly match the sealed values, so protected stable bytes or contract bytes differ from sealed digests (expected stable 074b4f7f..., contract 48768744...). The check aborts before `clean_boundary`; this is an immediate release blocker. Exact changed path was not probed because the sole 29.9MB single-line snapshot exceeds the read interface and the audit remained read-only.\n5. NETWORK/PRIVACY/CLEANUP PROOF DOES NOT COVER AN ACTUAL LIVE PATH. Raw rehearsal trace has no outbound connect but does contain a local AF_INET6 socket/bind(::1); it proves zero connects, not literal zero network syscalls. Channel Inbox is guarded false in the generic binding, but privacy/network/cleanup postconditions are delegated to the unsealed host. Thus retained rehearsal evidence cannot establish those properties for an eventual real adapter.\n\nNo files, profile state, service, or network were modified by this audit.",
  "timestamp": 1787838477835,
  "summary": "FINAL BLOCK: do not authorize any v1.5 live mutation"
}