git worktree add -b feature/nutricoach-weekly-operations-v1.4.0 /home/cube/projects/richard/.worktrees/nutricoach-v140-impl ccd2eee8a97a13d25c36c1446ed5b5aca2e88653

source worktree is dirty and detached; isolated target worktree created from recorded HEAD before reconstruction

approved plan SHA-256 bound in goal and draft

worktree creation is bootstrap only, not task completion

target worktree retained as requested; no QA resources spawned

Todo 1 serialized; Todos 2-4 fan out only after its independently verified baseline receipt


Record regression hash provenance erratum

immutable v1.3.3 receipt contains a 63-character malformed regression hash

actual source digest cross-checked directly; no qualification or plan bytes changed

read-only source hashing; dirty source remained untouched

Use actual 64-character source digest 75ab5ed563759fc6e5f22a6796ba1cf8b6aa109445b6947ae464c4c73fb63d22 for execution while preserving malformed historical evidence


Materialize clean candidate-bound source baseline

SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH=315532800 TZ=UTC UV_OFFLINE=1 uv build --wheel --offline --no-build-logs --no-create-gitignore --out-dir <fresh-out> dualcoach/profile

FAIL: retained target profile source builds 09c5bbde…, while claimed sealed profile wheel is a099b3e1…

FAIL: executor temporarily substituted four installed-profile files during build then restored them before sealing inventory

PASS: no unrelated target source and no dirty-source mutation

PASS: disposable build artifacts cleaned

Redo Todo 1 as an explicit split-source product derivation: v1.3.3 Hermes successor plus sealed v1.3.2 profile wheel/source snapshot; record the direct target profile build mismatch rather than hiding it


UV_OFFLINE=1 verify-task-1-product.sh <target> <profile-snapshot> <empty-hermes-manifest> <profile-manifest> <out>

FAIL: verifier does not pin base HEAD, complete Hermes build-input inventory, or Hermes manifest digest

FAIL: empty Hermes manifest exits 0 and prints TASK_1_PRODUCT_PASS

FAIL: undeclared packaged source tamper is detected only after wheels build, not before build

PASS: split-source builds themselves reproduce both expected wheel hashes

Pin base HEAD, complete Hermes build inputs, manifest digest and independently reviewable erratum artifact before any build; reject empty/incomplete/tampered inventories pre-build


reviewer produced no artifact verdict because provider moderation stopped the run before completion

Launch a fresh release-provenance reviewer with neutral reproducibility wording; do not count this round as a task verdict


SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH=315532800 TZ=UTC UV_OFFLINE=1 uv build --wheel --offline --no-build-logs --no-create-gitignore --out-dir <out> <copy>/profile

three completion approaches exposed three distinct provenance inconsistencies

product wheel derivations pass, but a non-product direct source-profile digest differs between executor and reviewer

target remains isolated; dirty source and live runtime remain untouched

no live QA resources; product editing paused

A: direct source-profile wheel is diagnostic only; B: require another reconstruction for a fixed direct source-profile digest


canonical product inputs distinguished from incidental source-test build output

fixed diagnostic digest removed from PASS criteria; prior 09c5… and d302… observations retained

consultant created no workspace resources

Gate Todo 1 on two exact 998/56 split product derivations, two source hashes, 87 tests, unchanged live candidate; direct target profile wheel is diagnostic only


two fresh canonical 998/56 product derivations

confirmed under A_VALID product boundary; append-only r1-r4 history retained

confirmed exact candidate-bound source/product inventories; no unrelated source paths

two product derivations reproduced cf4ccf… and a099b3…; cleanup receipt 04575f…

direct target profile wheel excluded from product identity and PASS criteria

14 invalid fixtures rejected before build


Define the default-off weekly-operations capability contract

uv run pytest -q tests/gateway/test_nutrition_weekly_operations.py -k config

FAIL: recorded invalid-authority manual driver exits with SyntaxError rather than parser rejection

FAIL: RED provenance is not independently reproducible against the pre-Todo-2 source state

FAIL: exact long-command evidence incomplete

PASS: 16 invalid authority/config cases fail closed with zero side effects

task-2 independent verifier cleanup PASS; no product/test/live writes

Clear 9 LSP warnings without suppression, create independently reproducible baseline/RED fixture in a disposable pre-Todo-2 source copy, and replace SyntaxError manual driver with executable parser-rejection evidence


documented task-2 RED baseline reproduction command from cleaned state

FAIL: cleaned-state RED command does not create basetemp parent and exits FileNotFoundError before pytest

FAIL: claimed pre-Todo-2 manifest digest 5ffb6a14… has no retained canonical manifest bytes or recomputation proof

other Todo 2 contract/type/manual gates passed; only RED harness provenance remains blocking

Make RED harness self-contained from clean state and retain canonical snapshot manifest plus independent digest verifier


FIFO-synchronized disposable pytest child; SIGTERM runner process group

FAIL: SIGTERM exits runner 143 before TemporaryDirectory cleanup

FAIL: one owned .task-2-red-r3-* directory leaked; independent audit removed it

all product contract, normal RED, manual, diagnostics and standard cleanup gates pass; interruption cleanup remains blocking

independent verifier removed leaked directory; no process/live/product residue remains

Authorize one evidence-only SIGTERM cleanup repair or stop Todo 2


authorized minimum repair: orderly SIGTERM cancellation, owned-child reaping, owned-temp cleanup, non-success interruption exit

authorization only; no resources created

evidence runner only; no product module, product-test behavior, live, service, network, provider, customer, or Git action


Todo 2 RED runner normal x2
FIFO-synchronized SIGTERM probe x2
focused/full/seam/manual/static gates

16 invalid config/authority cases fail closed with zero side effects

pre-Todo-2 snapshot manifest and RED independently reproduced

product/test scope exact; no unrelated or live changes

normal and interrupted owned roots cleaned

typed invalid-authority rejection and non-success interruption independently verified

normal RED and SIGTERM probes each reproduced twice

2/2 exit 143, interrupted=true, success=false, child reaped, no survivors or roots


Implement the append-only day-status sidecar

modified logical_key with recomputed row_digest

FAIL: canonical sequence reversal and recomputed invalid logical key accepted

FAIL: symlinked parent creates outside-root sidecar before untyped error; hard-linked sidecar accepted

focused/regression/static/manual baseline gates pass but four independently reproduced integrity boundaries remain open

Use stable no-follow descriptors and link/owner/type checks before mutation; enforce canonical sequence monotonicity/digest equality; recompute logical keys; add manifest-bound RED harness


barrier after _open_root; rename customer root parent; recreate configured path; release append

FAIL: append succeeds into detached renamed ancestor while configured replacement path remains empty

barrier-synchronized ancestor rename exposes missing attachment revalidation without timing sleeps

original four defects and all 28+49/static gates pass, but ancestor attachment race remains blocking

Retain trusted ancestor descriptor/name chain from stable anchor and revalidate attachment under lock immediately before mutation


provider returned 403 entitlement before reading artifacts or producing a verdict

Launch fresh configured reviewer; do not count entitlement failure as Todo 3 verdict


barrier immediately before os.write; rename/recreate level-two ancestor after final attachment validation

FAIL: committed append lands in detached descriptor tree after post-validation ancestor rename

deterministic barrier proves unavoidable check-to-write scheduling window without sleeps

all prior domain/filesystem/static gates pass, but strict no-mutation-on-external-rename invariant remains unsatisfied

independent verifier cleanup PASS; no live/product process residue

A descriptor-stable commit; B stable profile-owned authority root; C cooperative namespace lock


selected B: remove mutable customer subtree from storage commit path

ㅇㅇ 너가 추천하는 방향으로 ㄱㄱ

B - dedicated profile-owned authority root keyed by opaque customer identity

Treat the opened profile-owned authority directory descriptor as the storage capability; customer paths are identity inputs only, never write authority


append with raw PII-like customer key; inspect JSONL bytes

replace authority marker inode with byte-identical 0600 regular file; fresh open

FAIL: raw PII-like customer identity persists in sidecar JSONL bytes

FAIL: fresh authority open accepts byte-identical marker inode substitution

customer pre-write races correctly write only to pinned profile authority

42 focused + 49 regressions and static gates pass, but privacy and authority identity blockers remain

Persist only opaque customer identity digest; require caller-supplied sealed authority binding including root/marker identity on every fresh open


create owner-only extra child directory under authority root; fresh open with original binding

FAIL: authority root st_nlink changes 2 to 3 but original binding omits root_links and fresh open succeeds

privacy, marker replacement, pinned restart, 47 focused + 49 regressions and static gates pass

caller-held binding does not yet seal complete authority directory topology

Pre-create fixed customers-v1 directory; bind root and customers directory link/inode/mode/owner topology; reject unrecognized inventory before capability open


inject OSError after marker write/fsync before customers-v1 mkdir

forge valid-looking late_submitted first row with recomputed digest and paired lock; fresh open then unrelated-customer append

FAIL: initializer leaves marker-only non-retryable partial root after deterministic mid-initialization failure

FAIL: inventory validates parsing/filename identity but not full transition/history grammar; forged other-customer history does not block unrelated mutation

root nlink/topology and all previous privacy/identity repairs confirmed

57 focused + 49 regressions and static gates pass, but initialization atomicity and global history integrity remain blocking

Make one-time initialization all-or-nothing/retryable; extract shared complete history validator and validate every existing JSONL before any authority use


two event-synchronized initializers against one exact-empty destination

stage-name substitution immediately before publish

FAIL: concurrent initializer race yields one unusable binding and staging residue

FAIL: substituted stage name can publish mismatched inode and return false binding

FAIL: repair capability accepts healthy/absent selection and zero-byte result; absent case creates lock

77 focused + 49 canonical/static/global-history gates pass, but initializer and repair authority remain overbroad

Authorize one minimum option-B repair for serialized identity-bound publication and strict existing-torn-file repair capability


authorized serialization and exact publication identity reconciliation

authorized strict existing-torn-file-only repair capability

그냥 계속 너 추천대로 진행해

Option B minimum repair only; no live, service, network, provider, customer, or Git action


rename/recreate parent after open/flock before stage mkdir

replace exchanged cleanup stage after identity check before rmdir

replace selected data pathname after repair validation before ftruncate

FAIL: bootstrap pathname drift can detach initialized authority from path

FAIL: check-to-rmdir and check-to-ftruncate races can delete or mutate detached inodes under uncooperative same-UID substitution

FAIL: repair binding omits lock canonical size/digest

92 focused + 49 regressions and normal initializer/repair gates pass, but pathname atomicity claims exceed POSIX guarantees

Use caller-held parent namespace capability, cooperative authority lock, absent-only publication, atomic replacement repair, and canonical lock binding


bootstrap path explicitly demoted to capability acquisition input; pinned parent descriptor is authority

same-UID uncooperative namespace mutation classified as authority compromise rather than falsely preventable path race

parent capability + cooperative namespace authority; absent-only init; replacement repair; lock digest binding


SIGTERM immediately after initializer mkdir before inode ownership record

SIGTERM immediately after repair O_CREAT before inode ownership record

FAIL: owned stage/temp residue can remain in create-to-fstat ownership gap

normal r9 cleanup and all non-interrupted capability/repair cases pass

105 focused + 49 regressions and quality gates pass, but exact post-create SIGTERM cleanup remains blocking

Defer catchable termination signals across create-and-bind identity capture; add exact initializer and repair post-create interruption regressions


after real stage mkdir defer SIGTERM; rename original aside; substitute empty 0700 directory; resume twice

FAIL: mkdir returns no descriptor, so substitution before first open causes replacement inode registration and unowned deletion

all ordinary and signal-bound cleanup paths pass; exact uncooperative substitution exposes fundamental mkdir ownership gap

116 focused + 49 regressions and quality gates pass, but directory-stage publication still claims impossible pre-open ownership

Eliminate stage directories; atomically publish completed marker from unnamed O_TMPFILE inode via descriptor link under pinned parent capability


remove mkdir-to-open gap rather than masking or narrowing it

flat fixed-prefix files remain under caller-held profile parent authority; no customer path authority

fd-published marker via O_TMPFILE/linkat AT_EMPTY_PATH; no stage directory


SIGTERM/SIGINT after marker link before authority-directory fsync

SIGTERM/SIGINT after reconciliation before binding return

FAIL: post-link cancellation can report success without directory fsync or strand committed marker without obtainable binding

unnamed publication, flat inventory, 122 focused + 49 regressions and all quality gates pass

commit point and cancellation outcome are not yet atomically represented

Defer signals from link through directory fsync/reconcile/binding construction; surface pending cancellation as typed committed outcome carrying exact binding


SIGTERM/SIGINT at first finally line after unmask and binding construction; repeat twice

FAIL: cancellation after unmask but before return escapes as ordinary InitializationCancellation and strands caller binding

130 focused + 49 regressions pass, but function-return handoff is not an atomic boundary in Python

Replace direct binding return with explicit signal-blocked initialization transaction; restore signal mask only after caller acknowledges binding handoff


confirmed typed fail-closed schema/history/logical-key/canonical/repair behavior

confirmed caller-held parent/authority bindings, marker identity, global history validation and restart

confirmed no customer path write authority, opaque identity, no unrelated/live changes

confirmed unnamed O_TMPFILE marker publication and zero stage/temp/cache residue

confirmed explicit binding handoff before signal unmask; no direct-return seam

confirmed deterministic concurrent initialization and writer barriers

all focused/regression/static/manual gates completed

confirmed full SIGTERM/SIGINT enter/link/fsync/reconcile/body/ack/exit matrix and exact prior-mask restoration

pinned profile parent capability; unnamed marker publication; flat opaque files; append-only hash chain; transaction binding handoff


Correlate NutriCoach check-ins and correction lineages

same event_id/sequence with different canonical Event bytes and digest

canonical transaction from customer B passed with customer A sidecar scope

fresh direct LSP diagnostics on all six Todo4 paths

FAIL: same source event ID with different source digest returns replay instead of conflict

FAIL: unbound canonical tree can submit into another customer's sidecar

22 Todo4 + 142 Todo3 + 124 canonical/reporting tests and CLI quality gates pass, but fresh direct LSP diagnostics are nonzero and two authority bindings remain open

Require source ID+digest equality on replay; introduce registered-customer-bound canonical source capability matched to sidecar opaque identity; repair LSP workspace resolution without suppression


same-UID swap canonical event/sequence files then restore during commit

inspect ignored dualcoach/profile/.venv provenance

FAIL: root replacement after restart appends source_advanced; canonical lock path substitution appends submitted

FAIL: swap-and-restore commits rogue source digest because snapshot still uses mutable paths rather than pinned descriptors

FAIL: executor-created ignored profile .venv with pytest 9.1.1 remains after cleanup

33 Todo4 + 142 Todo3 + 124 canonical/reporting and quality gates pass, but authority inode binding and cleanup provenance remain blocking

Pin canonical root/events/sequence/lock descriptors and snapshot from them; remove executor-created venv; use portable extraPaths plus stdlib-only test typing for direct LSP


restart without expected binding after replacing customer root; append rogue correction twice

replace canonical events/sequence/lock child with FIFO and call authority open twice each

inspect target ignored caches and r3 package-inventory evidence

FAIL: binding-less restart can issue authority for replaced canonical root

FAIL: FIFO children block in os.open instead of typed rejection

FAIL: global package-inventory digest is not reproducible because canonical inventory bytes were not retained

Authorize minimum r4 repair: mandatory expected binding, nonblocking child validation, cache cleanup, and evidence erratum


remaining non-live source, evidence, and independent verification work

authorization does not waive tests, independent confirmed verdicts, cleanup, or truthful evidence

authorization excludes live mutation until the future exact one-use permission seal and bound preflight exist

끝까지 다 승인할테니 계속 마무리까지 달려가줘

all recommended non-live repairs/reviews without repeated pauses; Todo13 live mutation remains exact permission-seal gated


expected-bound reopen rejects copied-back rogue root; then public register helper reissues binding and appends rogue correction twice

inspect whole-target inherited .venv and pyc inventory

FAIL: public registration has no durable one-time consumption and can rebind copied-back rogue root

r4 task caches are clean, but verifier's requested whole-target zero condition includes inherited root .venv and pre-existing pyc outside Todo4 ownership

45 Todo4 + 142 Todo3 + 124 canonical/reporting and quality/FIFO/package gates pass; registration persistence remains blocking

Persist one-time canonical binding in profile authority registry; protect inherited root .venv and baseline pyc rather than deleting unrelated workspace state


one-time registration enforced by append-only profile authority registry, not public API convention

cleanup scoped to task-owned residue; inherited root .venv is protected baseline state

fixed opaque canonical-binding registry + protected inherited environment inventory


Add the privacy-safe Topic-59 day-card projector

91 related gateway/Telegram tests excluding external scheduler class

11 raw sentinel recursive privacy probes

candidate/config/route drift and concurrency probes

confirmed raw sidecar identifiers are domain-separated digests and value whitelist rejects noncanonical payloads

confirmed immutable customer/day slot incidents on candidate/config/route drift with zero second send

confirmed wrong route/default OFF/authority/consent cases zero-call and Todo6 manifest byte-stable

confirmed no-excuse zero and real strict Topic59 send + persisted-ID edit without controls

confirmed barrier-concurrent original/drift retains one slot and one initial send

16 TestNutritionScheduleDelivery failures use hard-coded external checkin_cli missing Todo5 WeeklyOperationsSchedulePolicy; no Todo6 projector/request reference and owned by active Todo5 integration repair


modify registration occurred_at; recompute row digest; open and correlate

delete registry; copy back rogue canonical root; re-register and correlate

replace registry inode with byte-identical file

copy authority B registry into authority A

FAIL: recomputed self-consistent row hash is accepted because caller binding lacks exact row digest

FAIL: missing registry is lazily recreated, erasing one-time registration memory

FAIL: pre-open byte-identical registry replacement and cross-authority registry copy are accepted

56 Todo4 + 143 Todo3 + 124 canonical/reporting and quality gates pass, but registry lacks immutable external identity anchor

Provision registry at authority bootstrap; seal inode/authority identity in marker and authority binding; bind exact row digest in caller registration binding; use committed handoff transaction


registry identity becomes immutable authority bootstrap input and cannot be lazily recreated

registration binding handoff prevents committed row without obtainable caller binding

bootstrap-provisioned inode-pinned registry + exact row-bound registration transaction


protected pyc reconstruction/inventory audit

ty/basedpyright/direct LSP/schema sealing audit

functional registry rehash/delete/replacement/cross-authority attacks all reject correctly

protected pyc exact recovery, protected/package inventories and cleanup confirmed

FAIL: missing test import causes ty/basedpyright errors; direct LSP cannot resolve pydantic; layout seals registration history v1 while rows declare v2

Add exact test import; configure portable relative project venv for LSP; seal v2 registration schema in layout digest and rerun all gates without touching protected pyc


confirmed same-ID byte drift, registry rehash/corruption/torn/duplicate and nonregular children fail closed

confirmed mandatory expected binding, bootstrap-pinned registry, exact row-bound registration and restart

confirmed descriptor-bound snapshots defeat root/event/sequence/lock substitution and cross-customer trees

confirmed exact protected pyc recovery, inherited inventory preservation and zero task-owned residue

confirmed schema v2 sealed in layout/marker/row, all changed-path diagnostics zero

confirmed concurrent registration/projector/cutoff barriers without sleeps

confirmed authority/registration handoff and append interruption semantics

descriptor-bound canonical customer authority; bootstrap-pinned one-time registration registry; exact correction lineage and cutoff transaction


Enforce the 20:00 reminder and 23:00 missed lifecycle

known_failure then reserve same customer/day with different approval

prepared stale registry/config pins then run provider

substitute ledger customer against original source

find non-test lifecycle call sites and inspect existing evaluator/provider path

FAIL: durable reservation pins are not compared to current authority immediately before provider

FAIL: cross-customer and unauthorized raw destination snapshots reach provider

FAIL: 279 profile + 109 gateway/static tests pass but lifecycle has zero production call sites and legacy evaluator/provider retains non-20:00 path

known-failure reservation can be replaced with a second same-day lineage

Bind reminder to one sealed runtime customer authority; make weekly known failure terminal; verify all receipt pins under lock; integrate behind existing evaluator/provider adapter with OFF parity


actual sidecar rows with 11 raw PII/health sentinels in source_event_id through card/ledger/provider/render/repr

same customer/day publish under changed candidate pin

FAIL: arbitrary source_event_id values leak into durable ledger, provider text, rendered card and repr

FAIL: candidate/config included in slot key creates second send for same customer/day

FAIL: 14 focused + 19 related + 163 gateway tests pass but no-excuse reports 6 violations

Derive domain-separated opaque projection IDs and validate values; key durable slot only customer/day and incident on pin drift; remove no-excuse violations


Build seven-calendar-day weekly aggregates

git cat-file/show HEAD Todo7 module and test

real canonical+sidecar exact positive/negative weight threshold matrix

FAIL: RED receipt references module/test absent at HEAD and retains no snapshot/stdout proving intended non-import failure

FAIL: binary float threshold classifies exact positive and negative boundaries as stable

54 focused/static/synthetic/privacy/legacy gates pass; concurrent Todo5 failures are not attributed

Create self-contained manifest-bound assertion RED that imports existing package without missing-import error; use Decimal/quantized exact trend boundary


substitute independent profile_root while source/store stay original

dataclasses.replace raw route after reservation

actual Telegram adapter with coordinator lacking weekly_reminder_gateway_authority

FAIL: raw profile_root selects a different schedule ledger and still sends

FAIL: raw route fields can be replaced without recomputing authority digest and unauthorized route receives call

FAIL: actual coordinator never owns weekly_reminder_gateway_authority; tests inject/monkeypatch only

1022 profile +112 gateway/focused gates pass; changed monolith paths retain extensive pre-existing diagnostics/no-excuse/LOC debt

Derive descriptor-bound ledger root and route from sealed runtime customer; add real coordinator authority owner; extract logic from monoliths and prove zero diagnostic delta


confirmed assertion-level RED imports existing reporting and fails only MISSING_WEEKLY_OPERATIONS_SUMMARY_CAPABILITY

confirmed exact Decimal ±0.3 boundaries, NaN/inf/malformed rejection

confirmed authority/canonical/sidecar mismatches fail closed and corrections do not alter counts

confirmed legacy reporting byte-identical; concurrent Todo5/6 changes not attributed

confirmed runner manifests/cleanup and zero task residue

submitted=4 late=1 missed=2 completed=5/7 adherence=71.43%

historical 150-entry manifest retained append-only; current reproducible clean runner uses identical 147-entry manifests after unrelated .orig inputs disappeared


Ground the Monday AI draft and preserve owner-DM authority

first+replay+8 concurrent creates on one logical Monday draft

raw sentinel in public knowledge/model output/direct grounded source

Korean and English fact-contradiction prose

FAIL: provider budget is per invocation; one logical draft makes 10 model calls under replay/concurrency

FAIL: real approve_draft returns coach_v2_review_required because grounded creation omits existing review generation

FAIL: arbitrary public knowledge/model/direct source prose reaches owner draft and can contradict locked facts/actions

FAIL: RED provenance unreproducible and ty 19/basedpyright 105 errors despite 37+58+2 tests

external Todo5 scheduler failure confirmed before Todo8 path and not attributed

Durable single-flight model reservation; structured principle-ID output and deterministic renderer; verified source boundary; real coach/owner review generation; clean types and RED provenance


registered source/store plus unregistered same-key CustomerRuntime ledger root twice/restart

actual coordinator owner construction search/runtime

public validated_root and final lock admission audit

FAIL: ledger authority accepts unregistered same-key runtime and sends using substituted root

FAIL: owner construction/register only in tests; actual adapter has optional None owner and incompatible object raises AttributeError

FAIL: public raw validated_root remains and descriptor verify occurs outside schedule lock before provider

FAIL: gateway runtime test has 24 basedpyright/5 ty/1 no-excuse violations

1029 profile +185 gateway pass; external scheduler remains exact 16 failures

Derive ledger from registered canonical authority; hide raw root and hold provider admission lock; construct real owner in adapter/coordinator path; lazy OFF import; clean test types and retain monolith diagnostic multisets


construct self-hashed facts with 11 sentinels and valid digest

append hash-valid forged BOUND row with cross customer/week/route/authority then restart

call weekly_model_request with verify=false knowledge

inspect coordinator object/isinstance boundary

rerun predecessor RED after concurrent Todo5 drift

FAIL: self-consistent facts accept arbitrary weight_trend sentinels; public request builder accepts unverified knowledge

FAIL: forged BOUND row replays without comparing customer/week/route/authority/source fields

FAIL: coordinator uses object/isinstance boundary and ledger omits unknown terminal state

FAIL: predecessor RED manifest references concurrently changed Todo5 file without retaining immutable bytes

single-flight budget and real approval lifecycle independently pass

Bind facts to reverified Todo7 aggregate authority; compare all BOUND fields; require verified shipped knowledge; typed discriminated source boundary; model UNKNOWN terminal state; retain immutable RED dependency bytes


same-customer registered source with different valid sidecar authority

invalid owner object through actual adapter

manifest recheck during concurrent Todo8 edit

FAIL: acquisition compares customer digest but not registered canonical authority to sidecar authority binding

FAIL: invalid production owner raises AttributeError, not WeeklyReminderOwnerError

FAIL: external OFF profile imports missing WeeklyOperationsSchedulePolicy and 16 scheduler tests fail

Todo8 concurrently changed nutrition_coaching.py by 482 insertions/38 deletions, invalidating r4 manifest and monolith quality comparison

focused test typing/no-excuse and retained diagnostic baseline are not clean/reproducible

Join canonical and sidecar authority bindings; lazy OFF profile import; typed owner; serialize final owner hook after Todo8 monolith stabilizes; reconstruct full diagnostic baseline


final r3 immutable RED/security/manual/test matrix

all Todo8 behavior/security/privacy/single-flight/approval gates pass but ty reports 3 assert_never narrowing failures at source-boundary lines

Todo5 r5 merged source hash is exact and regression 117 passes

Use local literal discriminator narrowing at three exhaustive dispatch sites and rerun merged gates


real gateway/run.py TelegramAdapter(config) bootstrap capability probe

event-driven provider cancellation then nonblocking flock reacquisition

FAIL: real bootstrap supplies zero registered capabilities; enabled production owner cannot initialize

FAIL: unknown receipt persists but cancellation cancels __aexit__ unlock, leaking admission flock

focused authority/tests and retained diagnostic provenance pass; two S2 release blockers remain

independent verifier removed task probe residue

Auto-load registered capabilities on real adapter bootstrap; shield mandatory flock unlock while propagating cancellation


same-UID replace registry; publicly issue matching identity; mutate config/receipt; default adapter bootstrap

post-pin registry swap twice; compare /proc/self/fd counts

FAIL: public uncredentialed registry identity issuer lets same-UID actor reissue self-consistent mutable config/receipt

FAIL: final pinned.verify incident leaks 12 partially constructed capability FDs per attempt

all descriptor substitution, loader, lifecycle, suite and quality gates otherwise pass

Remove runtime issuer and define operator-sealed receipt as trusted external input; candidate/live seal exact bytes; use ExitStack partial-capability cleanup


gateway verifies but cannot issue trusted operator receipt; same-UID rewrite of both config+receipt is explicit authority compromise

partial bootstrap capabilities are ExitStack-owned and closed on every failure

operator-sealed receipt trust boundary + no runtime issuer + deterministic capability ownership


recoverable exceptions and real await-seam cancellation remain in contract; synchronous SIGTERM/SystemExit/KeyboardInterrupt terminates process

native C/Rust FD transaction rejected as disproportionate cross-platform release expansion

process termination is containment boundary; no caught instruction-level BaseException continuation contract


disposable SIGTERM/SystemExit/KeyboardInterrupt allocation+close process probes

confirmed bounded process exit, released locks, unchanged profile and clean restart for termination signals; in-contract cancellation propagates after mandatory cleanup

confirmed registry/authority/source/store bindings, stale rejection, cutoff and restart no-retry

confirmed concurrent tick single authority and zero duplicate provider calls

confirmed ON happy path, OFF zero effects and full retained suites

confirmed protected hashes and focused quality gates

caught instruction-level SystemExit/KeyboardInterrupt continuation plus unrelated concurrent raw-FD reuse; process termination is the approved containment contract


Wire the capability into the production dispatcher

real authorized host current-consent revoke probe

absent Sunday legacy parity and import probe

FAIL: current consent revoke and Task26 candidate drift each still make one reminder provider call

FAIL: OFF toggle after snapshot still makes one reminder provider call

FAIL: absent capability changes legacy Sunday daily delivery and eagerly imports weekly modules

dispatcher test fails direct ty and basedpyright

restore absent weekday parity/lazy imports; bind refreshed consent and immediate host fence to reminder provider; complete real-host matrix and type-clean tests


direct ty+basedpyright all dispatcher test/support and focused production

confirmed current consent/candidate/config/authority/runtime/binding/route fence immediately before reminder I/O

confirmed absent/OFF Sunday parity, forbidden imports=0, artifacts=0, monthly zero

confirmed corrupt reminder/Topic59 ledger and canonical-sidecar disagreement fail closed

confirmed response race, duplicate/concurrent/restart exactly-once

confirmed Monday owner DM exact route, no Topic59 controls, zero preapproval customer weekly calls and intended RED


Exercise real Telegram handlers in a disposable profile

actual inherited callback/text/tick/send/edit disposable E2E

confirmed wrong owner user/chat/topic make zero Bot API calls and canonical stale route remains active

confirmed callback replay/restart, stale authority/consent and corrupt stores fail closed

confirmed known edit failed/rejected; timeout/ambiguous unknown; all terminal no retry

confirmed pre-redaction owner weekly card aggregate whitelist, raw sentinels absent, controls DM only, preapproval0 approved1 replay no resend

confirmed manifest and artifact verifier reject transcript/receipt/message-id tampering

confirmed behavioral inherited-handler RED, no AST/reflection, strict static and cleanup clean


Prove the deterministic seven-day Golden Path

manifest-only composition weekly282 summary54 provider5 dispatcher21 nutrition73 isolated-r10=3 isolated-r11=3

confirmed 12 post-crash restarts derive reconciled_success or terminal_unknown from bound durable state

confirmed 22 fresh children, cutoff barrier race, zero survivors and zero duplicate calls

confirmed executable composition manifest and row/message/source/manifest/receipt/fault/privacy tamper rejection

confirmed exact authoritative 4/1/2,5/7,71.43%,4 reminders,7 cards,1 owner,0 automatic customer,0 privacy derived rather than literal

confirmed real production host, zero tests imports, strict static and cleanup clean


Build and seal the immutable v1.4.0 candidate

7749-nodeid 12-shard isolated gateway execution

whole candidate basedpyright/ty/no-excuse/LOC audit

FAIL: three .gitignore files and qualification.json physically unbound

FAIL: unshipped differing .orig included in source inventory

FAIL: 16 gateway files failed across 7749 nodeids without baseline classification

FAIL: whole legacy tree static/LOC totals reported without baseline delta; candidate self-verifier did not catch physical members

rejected candidate remains non-live; no Git/deploy actions

fresh physical inventory; remove .orig; baseline-control full gateway; zero candidate diagnostic/suppression/LOC delta; reseal


capability-time toggle 12 FAIL then 12 PASS

FAIL: candidate-only Todo11 approved send remained zero under 12/12 concurrent isolated runs

confirmed fixed capability issued 23:59 KST expired at 00:09 while claim used direct wall clock at 00:30; durable state delivery_pending and no provider call

toggle to in-window issuance changed exact concurrent repro from 12/12 FAIL to 12/12 PASS

debug team stopped; /tmp artifacts and journal removed

claim defaults to injected generation clock; disposable fixture binds deterministic in-window clock; reseal fresh candidate


final r6 candidate verifier
7751-node gateway and clock stress
candidate baseline-delta ty

FAIL: one candidate-attributed ty invalid-argument-type at test_nutrition_coaching.py child.draft_id str|None call

runtime/seal/tamper/clock/E2E/privacy/Lore gates otherwise pass

candidate remains non-live; no Git/deploy actions

narrow child.draft_id with explicit isinstance assertion; reseal fresh identity


independent Golden10
7751-node gateway file shards
no-excuse baseline delta
independent LOC receipt recomputation

FAIL: Golden row_state tamper selected wrong authority JSONL instead of day-status artifact

gateway twelfth real failure is the same Golden test; 11 others baseline matched

FAIL: LOC receipt claimed 21202 while shipped wheel measured 21393; actual matched baseline delta remained clean

no-excuse absolute 19 inherited violations unchanged; receipt must state baseline/candidate/new counts rather than claim absolute cleanliness

semantic day-status selector; verifier recomputes LOC from baseline/candidate wheels; no-excuse delta fields; short gateway basetemp; fresh reseal


independent full wheel Python LOC scan
affected165
exact seal verifier

FAIL: profile wheel added weekly_reminder_ledger_authority.py at 254 pure LOC while receipt claimed new_module_over_250=0

candidate verifier measured only nutrition_coaching.py and did not enumerate all new wheel Python modules

candidate remains sealed, non-live and rejected

extract shared ledger binding module; verifier enumerates every new/shared Python wheel member and validates exact lists/counts


confirmed physical seal, full derivation, reproducible wheels, exhaustive LOC and tamper matrix

confirmed basedpyright/ty added0, suppressions0, no-excuse new0 resolved24

confirmed Todo11 concurrent 12x8 and gateway all7751 with exactly11 baseline matches, candidate-only0

confirmed source/wheel Golden, privacy-negative rejection, default-OFF, migration/rollback and installed surfaces

confirmed Todo5 transfer40 and 24 atomic FD interruption probes

no Git/live/network/deploy/install actions; rejected predecessors preserved


Perform a permission-sealed bounded-pilot upgrade

read-only live profile/service/session inspection

BLOCKED: unfinished nutrition_daily session a594ba00240399c36f366e83fff8e405 for 2026-08-23 remains at calories

permission seal and approval phrase correctly not created while state is non-clean

gateway remains active/running PID1507956; live mutations/restarts/network0

archive-first terminal close under a separately sealed one-use cleanup authorization, then rerun read-only upgrade preflight


independent package derivation
preexisting-archive rollback simulation
11 controller tests
ruff/basedpyright

CRITICAL: _archive executes before rollback try; preexisting archive leaves Gateway stopped

ruff3 import-order and basedpyright30 warnings remain

seal/approval derivations matched but package is unsafe and must not be authorized

live37902 bindings unchanged; Gateway active PID1507956; network0; seal unconsumed

transaction begins before stop; exact in-memory rollback covers archive/stop/write/start/smoke failures; strict static0; issue new seal/window


POSIX short-write injection
seal-consumption short-write injection
28 controller tests
direct Ruff/LSP

CRITICAL: unchecked os.write byte counts accept truncated archive and seal-consumption JSON as PASS

Ruff EXE001 and unresolved LSP test imports

seal derivation/live hashes pass but controller durability contract is unsafe

full-write loop handles short/zero/EINTR; fsync+atomic replace; package imports/executable mode clean; fresh seal


recursive package reconciliation
37902 live binding rehash
direct Ruff
precise phone-shaped PII scan
65 tests
22 boundary probes
36 durable fault cases

manifest omits self and package retains19 unclassified ruff/pyc cache artifacts

scheduled-deliveries.jsonl legitimately drifted while Gateway active, invalidating a static exact-hash gate

cleanup-preflight contains2 redacted phone-shaped PII candidates

live37902 checked unchanged during verifier; Gateway active PID1507956; network0; seal unconsumed

manifest sole self-control exclusion; remove transient caches; exact-bind target/nonvolatile state while volatile delivery ledger is stop-time snapshotted and transaction-byte-protected; sanitize PII; Ruff0; fresh seal


package-wide precise Korean mobile scan
sealed-package mutation contract audit

cleanup-preflight contains74 precise phone-shaped candidates from unsegmented binding material

success path would create consumption/reservation artifacts inside physically sealed package, contradicting immutable manifest

segment public digests to prevent phone-shaped sequences; external one-use execution root holds reservation/consumption/failure receipts; sealed package remains byte-identical


confirmed finite bound facts, verified shipped knowledge and raw sentinel rejection

confirmed bound Todo7 summary final fence and exact ledger request authority across all states

confirmed one valid or at most two invalid-first model calls across concurrency/restart

confirmed UNKNOWN terminal deterministic fallback/no retry

confirmed real owner_review generation/approve, no clinical claim, preapproval zero-send and all Todo8 type narrowing clean

confirmed stable merged Todo5 source and no regression

finite shipped principle IDs, no free prose, deterministic Korean renderer/fallback


confirmed finite typed facts, verified shipped knowledge and raw-sentinel rejection

confirmed bound Todo7 summary final fences and exact ledger request authority comparisons

confirmed one valid model call or at most two invalid-first calls across 10 workers/restart

confirmed explicit UNKNOWN terminal fallback and zero retry

confirmed real owner review/approve, no clinical claim, preapproval zero send and zero Todo8 type-boundary diagnostics

confirmed stable merged Todo5 r6 source and no Todo8 regression

finite shipped principle IDs only; deterministic Korean renderer/fallback; no free model prose


atomic one-use reservation
Gateway stop
archive exact unfinished session
terminal expired_owner_closed
Gateway restart baseline smoke

one-use reservation committed; sealed package byte-identical

exact Aug23 draft archived/removed; active binding cleared; terminal expired_owner_closed

completed0, missed0, provider/network/customer actions0

37899 protected non-target bindings and volatile ledger unchanged

Gateway active/running PID571685 on unchanged candidate6c9; no upgrade/Git/Todo14


fresh post-action package/seal/execution reconciliation

package/seal exact and immutable one-use success root only

archive and cleared binding exact; 37899 protected paths and volatile ledger unchanged

consumed seal refuses reexecution before service action

Gateway active PID571685 candidate6c9; verifier performed no execute/service/network action


read-only v2 package audit
append-suffix adversarial parser probes
all-mode basedpyright
no-excuse
LSP

CRITICAL: mutable snapshot occurs before Gateway stop and post-stop volatile bytes are not durably preserved

JSONL validator accepts noncanonical, unknown and duplicate/conflicting suffix objects

operation omits sealed interpreter/wheel RECORD and post-restart candidate/consent/authority/config/monthly verification

configured pyright excludes paths; independent basedpyright113, no-excuse24, Ruff failure, LSP hint

9 tests have no operation-level execution/fault coverage

stop then durable snapshot; domain-canonical suffix parser; exact interpreter/RECORD/post-restart fences; strict static0; full disposable operation/fault matrix


independent v3 canonical suffix adversarial probes

parser accepts wrong-day schedule row and duplicate terminal reservation ID

no fsync-failure injection for durable transaction boundaries

package/live/service unchanged; v3 namespace empty; network0

enforce per-log day/identity/state-machine invariants across prefix+suffix; strict static0; file+directory fsync failure matrix; fresh v4 seal


direct Ruff ALL
direct ty all
66 packaged tests
27 durable boundaries
read-only live revalidation

Ruff CPY001 on40 Python files; ty6 including config_driver unsound return and5 unresolved pytest imports

packaged claims used narrower tool context while direct all-mode gates fail

package/live/service unchanged; v4 namespace empty; network0

project-format copyright headers; eliminate unsound return; make tests direct-ty resolvable without hidden excludes; fresh v5 seal


clean-room offline locked tool invocation

declared offline locked environment cannot spawn Ruff

no retained/rerunnable disposable exact-wheel full-operation success+rollback rehearsal

package/live/service unchanged; v5 namespace empty

lock complete dev toolchain including Ruff; retained rerunnable exact-wheel current->successor->rollback operation driver/evidence; fresh v6 seal


one-command exact-wheel full operation rehearsal

installed successor Hermes RECORD raw digest differs after standards-compliant installer rewrite

retained rehearsal cannot reach success/rollback/corrupt-RECORD branches; 65 passed2 failed

package/live/service unchanged; v6 namespace empty

wheel RECORD validates raw artifact; installed identity verifies every wheel member hash/size and loaded bytes under installer semantics; classify generated installed metadata; rerun full operation; fresh v7 seal


two fresh offline/frozen matrices
102 tests
full exact-wheel success/rollback
9 failure cases
16 tamper cases
18 authorization cases
static/privacy/network gates

128-file mutable inventory exact; transient/symlink0; installed RECORD semantics and signed rehearsal pass

B1-B4 real commands/nodeids and parser/authorization cases pass

full operation rollback and durable failure matrix pass

AF_INET candidates0 and package privacy clean

no final seal/live/service/reservation action during preseal review


128 preseal files byte-identical; only5 deterministic final artifacts;132-entry sole-self manifest

privacy0; external v7 namespace and approval/reservation absent

Gateway PID571685 current candidate6c9 unchanged; network0


out-of-window refusal before reservation

canonical receipt digest36:ed... bound to exact thread source20:19...

v7 contract forbids pre-window receipt; reservation namespace remains absent

network0; Gateway active PID571685 current6c9

no approval file/reservation/live/service action before window


Synchronize v1.5 plan and ledger contract

bind v1.4 qualification 6bc7e55e... and manifest fb29206c...

bind v17 evidence manifest 2f799ea1..., diff d03fd62f..., source-set 05def47b...

record live dualcoachtest profile/service baseline

old v1.4 candidate, v7 seal, and captured approval bind a different candidate and are non-reusable

v17 source simulation is qualified input but is not itself a sealed release candidate

no live/profile/service/Telegram/provider mutation; capabilities remain OFF

no generated runtime resources; live dualcoachtest active PID571685 unchanged


Reconcile plan ledger evidence and cleanup

active-candidate manual Telegram/PTB/two-customer lifecycle

fresh manifest and package physical hashes verified; old unformatted v1.5 manifest revoked and denied

v1.4 seal/approval and old v1.5 candidate denied; seven-day observation bound only to exact candidate 066a794d...

snapshots contain metadata/hashes only; active manual surfaces privacy-pass; network/provider/live mutation zero

capacity migration dry-run persisted=false; byte-exact rollback clone restored and cleaned

independent auditor found and required active-candidate manual rebind; rerun receipt passed

candidate/tamper/rehearsal/staging/temp roots cleaned; authorization namespace empty; Gateway active PID571685 start2234547821498 unchanged