# Claim graph

## Verified claims

Pending research waves.

## Nodes

| claim_id | statement | claim type | risk | scope | intent ids | supporting observations | contradicting observations | independent groups | convergence | counter-search | primary backing | dependencies | status | synthesis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Choi Coach public nutrition principles can be distilled from attributable public sources. | evidence | normal | public doctrine | I1 | pending | pending | pending | pending | pending | pending | source waves | unresolved | pending |
| C2 | Specific calorie/macro or food-timing doctrine claims require source-level support before admission. | safety | high | nutrition doctrine | I1,I3 | pending | pending | pending | pending | pending | pending | source waves | unresolved | pending |
| C3 | Profile feedback can receive nutrition doctrine and observed-only user history. | code | normal | feedback pipeline | I1 | existing feedback code | pending | profile/core | pending | n/a | local source | implementation | unresolved | pending |
| C4 | Unverified Instagram-only claims are excluded from active doctrine. | safety | high | admission gate | I3 | existing doctrine | pending | profile/source | pending | pending | local doctrine | implementation | unresolved | pending |
| C5 | The product is an AI coach informed by public principles, not the public coach. | policy | high | identity | I2 | existing SOUL | none | profile | supported-single-source exception | n/a | local profile SOUL | none | supported | pending |
| C6 | Source provenance and access limitations are recorded with doctrine evidence. | policy | normal | research record | I3 | existing doctrine | none | profile | supported-single-source exception | n/a | local doctrine | none | supported | pending |
| C7 | Public channel/blog attribution is insufficient to claim identity, affiliation, qualifications, or endorsement. | policy | high | identity | I2 | O3 | pending | skeptic + source territories pending | partial | pending | RSS/channel source only | source waves | partial | pending |