# Intent vs reality

| intent_id | expected truth | observed reality | diff | violated invariant | intent source | supporting observations | status | linked claims |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I1 | Nutrition feedback is grounded in publicly verified Choi Coach nutrition principles. | Existing doctrine has only broad nutrition guidance. | Nutrition-specific evidence must be researched and bounded. | Evidence-grounded coaching | User request, 2026-07-18 | Existing doctrine review | violated | C1-C4 |
| I2 | The coach may reference the public coach's principles but must not impersonate or copy the person exactly. | Existing profile has a non-impersonation rule. | Preserve boundary while expanding knowledge. | Identity safety | User request + profile SOUL | SOUL.md | true | C5 |
| I3 | Public-source confidence and access limitations remain visible. | Existing doctrine marks Instagram mirrors/challenges as pending. | Admission gate must retain this rule. | Provenance safety | Existing doctrine | doctrine.md | true | C6 |